Bradley_A_Pliam
Bradley_A_Pliam on Hacker News
What part is incorrect? That there is a desire and need for an observable beginning? That I said it "might", in other words, could potentially have come into play? I don't think you know that this has not happened. How can you possibly know? You are entitled to believe what you like, but use the word "incorrect" when you know something is false. Something is not necessarily false just because it contradicts your beliefs!
I find this to be the crux of the issue. To be exempt from the rules that material things must follow, you simply need to designate it as space.
If space is what fills an area between object A and object B and that space grows or expands. This is no different than object A moving away from object B. What's the difference? There seems to be none.
I'll be up front about this. I'm in way over my head in this discussion, but in my mind, still, not all interactions are with particles. There are fields such as gravity, that affect wavelength.
And what about particles we do see? What if the debris we know is out there (the stuff of collisions and non-congealed leftover particulates, early gases since its many light years away) over immense distances have an accumulative affect? We see the red sunset but do not discern any individual particles with our eyes.
Then there are the things we don't see. Dark matter... and so much of it. I'm guessing that disproving the relevance of all of this has proven tedious, and recounting it to a newbie like myself even more tiresome!
Violating the cosmic speed limit is not only not a "perfect model" it's an atrocious model. Wouldn't you agree? It's a model that incorporates hard contradictions to itself.
You are saying I'm a lay person? You nailed it. I'm quite curious though about what would be so "advanced" that pop-science writers would not want to at least allude to it, since just Doppler redshift observations seems like not such a sturdy foundation, especially without anything else buttressing it!
I don't doubt that the "tired light" theory has been slain. I can update my orientation from your informed response without hesitation. However, I don't think I'm truly talking about the "tired light" theory in a way that plugs into your understanding of it. Although I mention debris in the article, and then kind of took it off the table, what I still have left to posit is that light propagation looses energy over billions of light years, not some short distances that can be tested in a lab or verified via other corroborating observations that relate to shorter distances or parallax geometry. I've completely placed my theory and conjecture out of reach of the lab! Or have I? If I have it might not be worth much in the community of experts, but it still means something to me because I feel like, and nobody seems to be responding to this in any detail, cosmic speed limits are being broken all over the place, as my article states.
I worded my reply poorly. I mean to say, Your notion or model of the universe is all downstream of assumptions that redshift can only be related to the Doppler effect (apparently there are a couple types of Doppler effect as the article mentions and links to info relating to "a normal Doppler redshift"). If everything rests on that assumption, it would be something to scrutinize if more and more observed astronomical data continues to pour in contradicting the big bang or expanding universe.
Separating "space itself" from the objects that are governed by universal laws is like saying there could be a north pole without a planet such as Earth. Take away Earth, you have no north pole. Take away objects in motion, you have no basis for talking about spacetime. That's just my intuition, but it seems to point to a gap in explanations, at least from science popularizers.
> that process just changes the frequency of photons, but not their density in space.
Frequency is precisely the necessary thing that needs to be considered as an observed phenomenon that can have alternative explanations, since frequency relates to shifting toward red.
Are you saying that density/luminosity is an independent way of corroborating universal expansion? I don't believe that's the case.
Neither luminosity nor redshift seem, IMHO, to be strong enough evidence to uphold a "preposterous" (to use Sean Carroll's favorite descriptive term for the world) theory that massive things are not just traveling but accelerating away from oneanother.
Thank you for the link. I will be checking that out.
I'd just like to emphasize that this was "prior thinking"
> "Professor Carroll, ... has reasons for his faith in the expanding universe theory, “evidence” which he gives here."
Does anyone know where this list of 4 or 5 evidences that the universe is expanding are that Sean Carroll outlines? I had the link but am not finding it!!
Your argument is not that effective for any who do not see evidence of a big bang. Steady state seems unlikely, perhaps a crude starting point, but it was closer to a model of the universe with sources and sinks, which are abundant and are everywhere.
Clearly Einstein missed his opportunity to lead the way in devising a theory of quantum mechanics, he was using his intuition and his method of thought experiment, and did not progress our understanding there. But when it comes to larger, more stable phenomena, I'm not so sure his intuition was so far off
I'm not putting forth any "conspiracy theory". You should know that human preference can cause people to act individually and independently in ways that conform to that preference. This is not conspiracy, it is confirmation bias. Groupthink may be at play, but this is also different from conspiracy because there is not necessarily any deliberate plotting to control going on necessarily. So with all the gradations of stuff in between extremes, you've not only placed me in an extreme, you've chosen the wrong extreme.
I've been a part of a subculture that lied to me, something not related to physics or STEM, but after years of drinking the koolaid I finally learned the emptiness of what the community of 'experts' were saying and what so many followers were swallowing whole. This experience damaged my ability to just believe experts. It has affected me in such a way that I don't just give people a license to do handwaving indefinitely. I've come to realize that my intuition could've freed me earlier on from the falsehood that an entire population was swallowing. This time around, I went with my gut. This time I want to know if there is coercion at play (calling people "crackpots" and shaming) or if there is evidence that needs to be laid out.
This is all downstream of assumptions that redshift is a certain kind of doppler effect. Redshift could actually be something other than that, and space from outta nowhere feels like just wishful thinking to me. And why is that space getting introduced without also bring with it its own time component? This seems to contradict your point that we don't just deal with space, but spacetime!
This explains why there is no "epicenter to speak of", but why is that expansion faster than the speed of light? How could it be? And is the evidence for that expansion really that solid?
Apologies for that. Good point. Probably deserves an edit
That would be much appreciated. I'm interested in learning even if it takes me away from things that seem intuitive. So as I've mentioned in my article, light from more distant objects could be shifted red, not by a dopplar effect, but by its interaction with space debris or just propagation itself over extremely long distances. Where the expanding universe theory seems to "go wrong" is by violating the cosmic speed limit.
After seeing more results and news coming from the JWST, it felt like time to pull the trigger on this article. I probably should've dug into Professor Sean Carol's list of evidence for the prevailing interpretation of redshift coming from distant objects. I may be eating crow for this neglect. Wouldn't be the first time.
Posted by
Bradley_A_Pliam on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:28PM
from the jarbles.substack.com dept.
Looking for input and feedback on this. I'm understanding the lack of vocal public responses on HN to be rooted in the threat of career jeopardy and the risk of employer retaliation. Am I right? Or is there some other reason people care so little about addressing directly the ways that software and the software industry can become more geared toward shaping an ethical and sustainable world? Third option, I have a verbose document on a huge subject that is not fleshed out enough.
If there isn't a top down effort, it will be a sluggish, "I'll get to when I feel like it" approach to dealing with existential threats to the human race. We have to come to terms with the fact that utopian dreams must be, to a large extent, deferred in order to do what is right for the planet with an every shrinking window of time. That means utilizing existing power structures. As I said, authoritarianism is a present reality that gets things done, though freedom-loving Americans fail to notice this. I don't want authoritarianism, I'm hoping for a signaling and messaging from influencers and power-brokers to coalesce a national response to urgent issues.
In version #8, I've provided more organizational structure to this document. Please feel free to offer your feedback, objections and advice. This is a work in progress.
Posted by
Bradley_A_Pliam on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:36AM
from the unitraverse.com dept.
That book looks quite fascinating but it advocates change through each individual (within a class of engineers), therefore it is not placing the urgency that is needed right now for change in our society, banking instead on long-term changes that will be too little too late.
FWIW, it is not that implausible that the world moves toward authoritarianism. This is the most crude but effective path toward achieving coordinated responses to a centralized mandate. I'm hoping for a different solution, think pervasive messaging without the force of the law. Not as with the Matrix, but as in "Life is Beautiful" the dad protects and elicits advantageous life-saving behavior from his son.
Also I wanted to mention Joseph Merz argument (https://www.planetcritical.com/p/urgency-action-and-ethics-j...) that it is too hard to go down the educational route, he wants to focus on direct influence of human behavior. Sound evil? It's basically trying to do what advertisers have done to us for decades or more.
The impossibility of the Arrow Theorum is not dealt with in a society that has maximized freedoms of the individual, based on pure volunteerism. Virtually every other type of society has a way of dealing with this limitation with large numbers of people. The solution has been government that either uses coercion or enticement to overcome this problem of diversity of wills.
The title of the document should've been posted: "A 21st Century Software Ethics Manifesto:facing unbridled realities brought about
by software" but I wanted to raise a question that it raises.
We are like a tapeworm, in the aggregate, destroying its host if we don't have high level thinking about our host planet that coalesces into a voice that most of the organism responds to
Posted by
Bradley_A_Pliam on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @05:12PM
from the unitraverse.com dept.
If we all act in our own self interest, that should seem to include taking care of our host planet. But what I see and call out in this Ethics and Software Manifesto is that, in the aggregate, the giant organism of all humans acting together in this world, resembles a giant tapeworm. What do you say?
Added a Table of Contents for easier perusal.