News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by kragen on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:08PM (#32783553)
For those who aren't aware, in addition to inventing Rust, Graydon also wrote Monotone, the source control system whose internal design Git is based on. Interpersonally he can be prickly sometimes but his opinions are well worth listening to.
Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by tbrownaw on Friday September 09, 2022 @10:26PM (#32787152)
> Monotone, the source control system whose internal design Git is based on

Huh? They both use content-addressing (identify everything by its hash) which leads to the nice property that history is cryptographically immutable, but at least Mercurial also does (and is also older than Git).

But other than that, they're fairly different.

The concept of what a branch is is fundamentally different. In Git, it's a pointer to a revision, and has a home (it's mutable scalar that a URI could point to). In Monotone, a branch is "all revisions - whether or not you know about them - that have a certificate that you trust that says they're in that branch".

(I describe that as Monotone being distributed as in Usenet, while Git is federated as in Email.)

Monotone treats a file as an object (so it can be explicitly renamed or deleted), where Git only has "this tree has a file at this location" and then can infer renames or deletes or creates (or copies or splits or whatever).

Plus of course there's the whole "monotone uses SQLite" thing.

Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by atgreen on Friday September 09, 2022 @07:38PM (#32786170)
This is unfair. I worked with Graydon years ago and he was always pleasant, helpful, and interesting. I wish I worked with more people like Graydon.

Regardless, you are right to point out two of his contributions that have left an indelible mark on our industry.

Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by kragen on Friday September 09, 2022 @07:54PM (#32786276)
I want people who don't wish they worked with more people like Graydon to read the slides anyway instead of replying to my comment with "well actually Graydon is the kind of person who..."

I'm glad to hear you got along well.

Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by faitswulff on Friday September 09, 2022 @06:48PM (#32785819)
> Graydon also wrote Monotone, the source control system whose internal design Git is based on.

Huh. I wonder if that played a part in Torvald’s being open to Rust in the Linux kernel.

Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by kragen on Friday September 09, 2022 @08:47PM (#32786584)
It's an interesting question, but I suspect that the technical attributes of Rust as it exists today play a much larger part in Torvalds's choices than does its origin many years ago.

In particular, Rust is less error-prone than C, rather than more so (as is arguably the case for C++), and it does not require the importation of a large runtime into the kernel. And, unlike for example Lua or Scheme, a number of kernels have already been written in Rust, some of which are already fairly full-featured: https://github.com/flosse/rust-os-comparison

Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by nextos on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:36PM (#32786845)
Also Rust semantics is more amenable to formal verification. This might have major implications in 5-10 years time.
Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by everybodyknows on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:12PM (#32784297)
Also the core code (in C++) of the Stellar consensus-based cryptocurrency.
Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by ModernMech on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:34PM (#32784572)
> Interpersonally he can be prickly sometimes

Aren't we all? What's the point in saying this? I find him quite pleasant.

Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by kragen on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:38PM (#32784617)
I want people who don't find him quite pleasant to read the slides anyway instead of replying to my comment with "well actually Graydon is the kind of person who..."

I'm glad to hear you get along well.

Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by Waterluvian on Friday September 09, 2022 @05:17PM (#32785038)
I think it’s a bit unfair to many people to try to normalize prickliness by saying everyone is.
Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by TheAceOfHearts on Friday September 09, 2022 @05:46PM (#32785285)
How much choice do you think prickly people have in who they become?

If I'm an asshole, and I recognize that I'm an asshole, but I'm either unable or unwilling to change, would you kill me if I asked it of you or society at large? I certainly don't want to be this way, but find I have little choice in the matter. Any signs of mercy for those of us who are born to suffer?

Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by eternalban on Friday September 09, 2022 @06:30PM (#32785679)
(to be clear, I did find your post funny, so this is friendly feedback.)

> How much choice do you think prickly people have in who they become?

It boils down to if you think being an asshole is congenital and impervious to efforts at self-improvement.

Personally I think we humans all hunger for love and acceptance, and a generous dose of love is Alchemical and can transmutate the lead of assholeness to the gold of beautiful conduct. So next time you see an asshole, give them a hug.

> I have little choice

As a last resort, you could always self-isolate. :}

Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by Waterluvian on Friday September 09, 2022 @06:04PM (#32785436)
I’m saying not to dismiss prickliness by declaring that everyone is. Everyone isn’t. Some, many, most? are, sure.

“There’s no point singling out people who steal bulk bin candies. Everyone does it.” is the sentiment that sits wrong with me.

Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by User23 on Friday September 09, 2022 @07:39PM (#32786178)
Virtually everyone is prickly when suitably provoked. Some people are just more easily provoked to prickliness than others. Some of it is probably just temperament, but for celebrities in the tech space, I wouldn’t be surprised if they have to deal with an aggravating number of annoying people and that sours their disposition.

All that is a long way of saying have some empathy at the very least and some sympathy if possible.

Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by freeopinion on Friday September 09, 2022 @06:04PM (#32785442)
What if, instead, somebody could offer you a path to change, as unlikely as it may seem? How unwilling are you?
Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by wrycoder on Friday September 09, 2022 @06:59PM (#32785906)
I wish people would find a new word, instead of persisting in using gutter English. Not just back alley, but gutter.
Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by antonvs on Saturday September 10, 2022 @12:53AM (#32787894)
The word “prickly” is neither back alley nor gutter English. The relevant dictionary definition is “ready to take offense” or “easily irritated”. Here’s the etymology: https://www.etymonline.com/word/prickly
Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by wrycoder on Saturday September 10, 2022 @01:51PM (#32792873)
I was referring to “asshole”.
Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by freeopinion on Friday September 09, 2022 @06:00PM (#32785408)
Did somebody wake up on the wrong side of the bed?
Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by googlryas on Friday September 09, 2022 @06:17PM (#32785560)
Maybe reading the literal words, we are all a little prickly sometimes. The intent is probably a polite way of saying "he is frequently an asshole for no apparent reason".
Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by kragen on Saturday September 10, 2022 @12:02AM (#32787694)
No, if I had meant that, I would have said it that way, probably because (much as I wish it were otherwise) I am frequently an asshole.
Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by antonvs on Saturday September 10, 2022 @12:55AM (#32787899)
You’re being a bit prickly about this.
Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by kragen on Saturday September 10, 2022 @01:05AM (#32787942)
Ha!
Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by agumonkey on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:08PM (#32784241)
Oh I had no clue he was behind monotone nor git's lifting it.

Have you both collaborated on something ?

Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by zoltar on Friday September 09, 2022 @05:26PM (#32785125)
Linus was hanging out in the monotone list for a bit and was a little frustrated with the performance at the time. https://lwn.net/Articles/132161/
Re:Graydon Hoare: 21 compilers and 3 orders of magnitude in ... by agumonkey on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:34AM (#32788666)
interesting bit of history

also reread about https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cogito_(software)

it's funny how like a few other projects, the original high level interface (cogito) got canned and the low level one ended up the main. I've read this about apt (which was a sub project of a big debian graphical package management) and lisp too.