News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by Tsagadai on Thursday November 24, 2011 @09:32PM (#3276012)
Yeah, all those arts graduates filling prisons with dissidents. There are already calls in the comments for a similar system in other countries. Why should university be about getting a job? Shouldn't university be about learning, and being recognised for learning. A history major or a poetry degree may not be the best way to get a job but I would prefer to live in a society with poets and historians.

Jobless, educated young people are copping a lot of flak from the media everywhere at the moment. They are a drain on the economy, "they are the 99%", they are having Arab springs where spring lasts all year, they are making molotovs in Greece. They are agents for changing society.

The underlying current of this idea in education is that we should all be happy little workers. Universities have been commercialised away from being the places that brought about the Enlightenment to places for turning out more advanced labourers. Universities are becoming (some have already become) an extension of the standard school system.

I found university to be a cacophony of ideas and viewpoints that until that point I had never really experienced. It introduced me to thoughts and ideas I may have never of experienced if I stayed in a small country town. Degree-mills rarely ever have this sort of environment and if all universities are reduced to churning out technical apprentices the world will be a worse place for it.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by Radim on Thursday November 24, 2011 @10:07PM (#3276063)
I didn't see any mentions of banning "poets and historians" in the article (though I just skimmed to be fair). What I saw was China cutting public funding for some majors.

If someone wants to be a poet, or a historian, or anything else, more power to him. Why on everyone else's money, though?

To be honest, if your calling to become a poet is stopped by a government's funding decision, you wouldn't have made much of a poet anyway.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by ceol on Thursday November 24, 2011 @11:00PM (#3276163)
How do you quantify the importance of a major compared to another? Certainly poets, historians, artists, and writers have more than a monetary importance in society. How do you measure the inspiration a great writer generates? How do you objectively compare the societal benefit of a mathematician versus a historian so that you can mete their funding accordingly?

I see a lot of "bootstraps" comments in the tech field— specifically about the liberal arts— and it's a shame. I wouldn't be in this field if it weren't for some of those "worthless" degrees like English (great writing helps the learning process) and Design (people are attracted to good-looking websites).

My apologies if I got a little ranty. It just irks me to see someone putting down another field of study as though they're a drain on society.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by philwelch on Friday November 25, 2011 @05:43AM (#3276783)
If you push on the supply side without pulling on the demand side, you're going to squash a lot of liberal arts majors against the wall. As a society, we are probably employing more academics than ever: more historians, more philosophers, more classicists, more literature critics. But we are producing even more graduates and graduate students who there are fundamentally not enough positions for, later on up the pipeline. And the typical English BA who works as a barista doesn't necessarily produce lots of poetry or anything on their free time.

Poets and writers today, and throughout time, live unique, often impoverished existences without necessarily being part of an academic establishment or having relevant education. Or they make tons of money selling dramatic scripts to the masses. If Shakespeare were alive today he'd be a screenwriter.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by GHFigs on Friday November 25, 2011 @02:39AM (#3276513)
How do you objectively compare the societal benefit of a mathematician versus a historian so that you can mete their funding accordingly?

From the article:The government will soon start evaluating college majors by their employment rates, downsizing or cutting those studies in which less than 60% of graduates fail for two consecutive years to find work.

Setting aside the question of whether that is a particularly good method, I'd like to suggest that it's at least more objective and quantifiable than just presuming that a degree in any given subject is equally the cause of or prerequisite to greatness in a given field, and therefore of equal value. Great art doesn't depend on art degrees to the same extent that great science depends on science degrees.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by jiggy2011 on Friday November 25, 2011 @02:47PM (#3278014)
The problem surely is that your evaluating by employment rates right now , this will not necessarily be so in the future and the govt probably isn't the best at predicting future demand. Geography is also a factor here.

What you risk doing is grossly over subscribing 'boom' fields and driving down salaries of competent people within those fields.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by _delirium on Friday November 25, 2011 @05:51AM (#3276793)
If someone wants to be a poet, or a historian, or anything else, more power to him. Why on everyone else's money, though?

If someone wants to become a Flash-game developer or make webapps, more power to him. Why on everyone else's money, though?

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by geebee on Saturday November 26, 2011 @10:09AM (#3279881)
I can think of a couple of answers...

First is that no education should take place on someone else's dime. Let the market sort it out. So don't subsidize literature or mathematics, film studies or nuclear engineering. Step back and let the market work it out.

The second is that the government should subsidize education, on the notion that some fields, such as science and engineering, generate positive externalities that can't be recouped by the practitioners of these fields. As you can probably tell, I think there's a lot of merit to this argument, especially in core science. I think that a scientist or engineer who earns 100K a year often generates far more wealth than, say, a mortgage broker who earns 100K a year. It does make sense to me that the government would try to find ways to encourage this.

If you feel this way, you probably don't mind educational subsidies and tax breaks for certain types of activities (by the way, I read somewhere that China has excepted software engineers from certain types of income taxes).

While I probably sound enthusiastic about this kind of arrangement, the truth is I'm ambivalent about it, largely because I have serious doubts that this kind of government interference will work. Instead, it often leads to a system that is easily gamed (engineering majors take the subsidy and then go work on wall street, and get a tax break because they write software for trading algorithms).

So in the end, I tend to favor a more hands-off, market based approach - though with some state subsidies for certain educational paths and research activity.

Lightweight yet effective and highly competent government... I do think it's possible, and the societies that figure it out will run circles around everyone else.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by potatolicious on Thursday November 24, 2011 @11:39PM (#3276226)
> "Shouldn't university be about learning, and being recognised for learning."

Not when it costs six figures and puts people neck-deep in debt.

I want to live in your utopian world, where people get educations just because. We would all be better off.

But the truth of the matter is, for a lot of people there are two choices after high school:

A - Pay $[bignum] for education that has high employability and will give them the knowledge and qualifications necessary to find work, which is absolutely necessary if they ever hope to repay said debt.

B - Pay $[bignum] for education that has low employability and will not give them any of the qualifications sought for in in-demand jobs. They will still owe $[bignum] which will compromise all other aspects of their lives.

I see your line of argument a lot whenever this topic comes up. My challenge to you is: besides a lot of feel-good platitudes, how will your system work? How will people feed themselves, clothe themselves, and put a roof over their head - their head full of wonderful perspectives and understanding but no job?

The "we can all get comprehensive" education idea died when education became expensive. It died when globalization squeezed the American middle class to become more desperate and ever more critically reliant on continued employment. Far from being the norm, the age of comprehensive college education was a brief blip in thousands of years of human civilization lasting no more than a few decades. The gravy train has come to a full and complete stop, and it's time for industrialized nations to clue into something: life is tough. You scramble to survive. High-minded ideology comes second to the survival of yourself and your loved ones.

If, in this topsy-turvy struggle you can find time to fit in a comprehensive education. Good for you - you won. The rest of the world isn't so lucky.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by bandushrew on Friday November 25, 2011 @12:24AM (#3276302)
Education plus time to think drives innovation.

In your 'real' world where everyone must frantically scamble to survive, civilization never leaves the caves.

We have massive surpluses across the world, 98%R of the wealth is owned by a tiny fraction of the people, food is piled up and wasted to protect markets, and yet there are still idiots claiming that we just cannot afford to educate everyone.

We cannot afford not to, if we want to survive into the 22nd century and beyond.

Its not a gravy train, our surpluses drove our technological advantages, which in turn drove our surpluses.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by potatolicious on Friday November 25, 2011 @12:52AM (#3276340)
Don't get me wrong - I'm absolutely of the position that education can, and must be cheaper for society to function.

But what should and shouldn't be is of cold comfort to someone leaving high school right now, who is forced to make this choice in a world where education is expensive. I'm sick and tired of people shaming everyone for getting a "useful" education.

I'm all for education reform - note in my original post I mentioned that comprehensive education died when it got too expensive. But can we, for once, stop booing and shaming people who choose rationally within the existing system? Can we also stop giving people excuses for choosing poorly within this system?

We have a society where it costs six figures to get a degree. This is a damn shame and should be fixed. But knowing this people still get degrees they can't afford, and then tell a sob story to the press about how their $100K+ degree can't find them a job. Well, shit.

The solution to this problem is to make education cheaper, not to shelter and coddle people who are incapable of making a rational decision.

[edit] To address your point:

> "Education plus time to think drives innovation."

I agree, but I do think that we are inevitably returning to a state where education plus time to think are going to become rare luxuries. Our innovation will suffer as a result - has already suffered as a result.

But I don't think there's anything we can do to stop this. The US gained an incredible industrial lead over the rest of the world early on, which allowed to elevate its quality of life well beyond anything the world had seen, which in turn drove the wheels of innovation and invention.

But decades of mismanagement, rampant robber-baron capitalism, and simple globalization has meant that the US middle class is gutted. It's getting more and more desperate out there - more and more people working multiple jobs, more and more people making large cutbacks to their quality of life to make ends meet. This is a vicious cycle, to be certain, but I can't see how to stop it.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by kalleboo on Friday November 25, 2011 @05:45AM (#3276786)
> I want to live in your utopian world, where people get educations just because.

You're welcome, we call it Sweden.

Higher education is free (before this year it was even free for non-swedes), and you get a stipend to pay for food/rent as long as you keep passing courses.

I know someone who's about to get a physics degree and is going to go into bartending afterwards since it seems more fun. I also know people who get education after education (stuff like psychology, history) while they figure out what they want to do.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by lucasjung on Friday November 25, 2011 @07:10AM (#3276895)
Does everyone get this free education, or just some people? I grew up in Germany, where only a small percentage of students got into Gymnasium (as opposed to more trade-oriented high schools), and only a small percentage of them got into universities. I'm not saying this is necessarily bad, just that it doesn't line up with the idea of a utopian world where everyone gets a free university education.

>Higher education is free...and you get a stipend to pay for food/rent as long as you keep passing courses.

This actually created a huge problem in Berlin when I was living there. Being in the university system was such a good deal that nobody wanted to leave. Students would change majors every few years to avoid graduating for as long as possible, sitting through courses they didn't really care about because it was easier than graduating and working for a living. Classes became terribly over-crowded: when walking around the campus area, you could tell the students apart from people who just happened to be passing through, because the students all carried folding chairs with them because none of the classrooms had enough seats. To compensate, they had to dramatically reduce the quotas for incoming students, so the students who were loitering in the university system were effectively blocking younger students from ever having the opportunity to get a degree.

I don't know if/how they ever fixed this problem, but I'm sure it's very hard to fix short of putting a hard limit (e.g. 4 or 5 years) on receiving the stipend.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by kalleboo on Friday November 25, 2011 @07:25AM (#3276913)
> Does everyone get this free education, or just some people?

Yeah, there's room for everyone. Class sizes are limited so acceptance into programs is merit-based (high school grades or a special test), but worst case you just have to settle for a less prestigious school.

There is actually a time limit to the stipend (IIRC 300 weeks of study) to avoid abuse, but it's also dependent on you actually passing courses.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by yummyfajitas on Friday November 25, 2011 @09:00AM (#3277076)
I'll stick to the US. I don't think I'd enjoy reducing my consumption/income to Swedish levels.

http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/03/super-economy-in-o...

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by kalleboo on Friday November 25, 2011 @10:23AM (#3277245)
What you do is your choice. Not everyone measures wealth in dollars http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satisfaction_with_Life_Index
Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by tptacek on Friday November 25, 2011 @01:29PM (#3277802)
That's an index premised on the hypothesis that "happiness" correlates in significant part with "access to education". It's unsurprising that Sweden does better on that index than the US, while doing poorer on others. That feels cherry picked.
Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by kalleboo on Friday November 25, 2011 @08:41PM (#3278812)
No, it's an index based on asking people how they feel. From one of the sources of the wikipedia article: "Participants in the various studies were asked questions related to happiness and satisfaction with life". The health/wealth/education correlations aren't actually part of the index, they're just comparisons made afterwards to help understand what improves happiness.

I only picked that specific one since it was the first google result for my search terms.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by cbs on Friday November 25, 2011 @11:39AM (#3277467)
Shhh... don't bring up those crazy ideals here. We all know that the end all and be all of the world is the free market's sociopathic fundamental that "more money, and more money alone, always means better".
Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by Roybatty on Friday November 25, 2011 @12:12PM (#3277547)
Of course not. We know that Obama and Nancy Pelosi know how to spend our money better than we do.
Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by tptacek on Friday November 25, 2011 @01:32PM (#3277813)
If you find yourself typing "Pelosi" or (usually) even "Obama" on HN, you're doing something wrong. I didn't just downmod this comment; I flagged it. It was unworthy of 'yummyfajita's parent comment. If you're going to call people names and write DailyKos/RedState-style comments, you can safely assume 'yummyfajitas is going to represent your views here more thoughtfully than you and save yourself the trouble.
Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by Roybatty on Friday November 25, 2011 @11:38AM (#3277465)
And most people don't measure wealthy by what some dingbat socialist says.
Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by Roybatty on Friday November 25, 2011 @11:36AM (#3277458)
And you leftists continue to lie and say it's free when everybody knows it's not.
Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by ansgri on Friday November 25, 2011 @01:41AM (#3276435)
Well, Russia is(was?) that utopian world where you can get education comparable to MIT for free, "just because". Everything changes, though.
Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by MatthewPhillips on Thursday November 24, 2011 @09:53PM (#3276044)
Agreed. I have a history degree, and program professionally. Universities are about expanding your mind, not turning into Good Employee.
Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by SeanLuke on Saturday November 26, 2011 @11:03PM (#3281649)
This feels like the anecdote. I suspect you're far from the typical history major case. How about all those history majors now working at McDonalds: were they well served by their mind-expansion experience?
Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by mahyarm on Friday November 25, 2011 @11:23PM (#3279052)
I don't need a university to expand my mind.
Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by ColdAsIce on Friday November 25, 2011 @03:08AM (#3276550)
Well hey there mate, I have a BA in History and program professionally too. JavaEE at work, and python on GNU/Linux all the way at home.
Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by jmilloy on Thursday November 24, 2011 @10:22PM (#3276100)
I don't think that cancelling a major automatically means that all liberal arts classes are nonexistent. I majored in math and cs, but went to France for a term, and took philosophy, drawing, music, history, and comparative literature. I don't think my school would become a degree mill just because it didn't offer a complete degree for history.
Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by Tsagadai on Thursday November 24, 2011 @10:57PM (#3276158)
I majored in CS and maths too and like you I also took advantage of various electives (psychology, philosophy, anatomy, genetics, public health). I spent a lot of my time attending friends lectures as well because you could just walk in and join the discussion without enrolling in the course. At university I would talk to people (students, academics, university staffers and researchers, hangers on) who specialised in an amazing array of topics. I would get interested in the practicalities of structural engineering for abstract architecture or plant sucrose transport channel manipulation simply by finding someone and talking to them about it.

If a school doesn't offer an entire history program, the chances of meeting someone really interested and specialised in history go down dramatically. A program isn't cut in isolation, courses are dropped, academics are fired, research programs are ended and opportunities are lost. Some universities have cut back to only offering first year courses in humanities (which you could probably learn everything from such courses with wikipedia, Khan Academy and an understocked library). You are unlikely to find people with more than a passing interest in a field if it isn't available for research at a university. Cut enough programs (or only offer a few to start with) and the school is a degree mill.

Highly specialised universities are often dead ends socially. They aren't fun places to visit, people are only there for that piece of paper that gets them a job. I've worked in a technical campus that was completely silent at night. The students would go across town to another university because "the music was better" or "it's more fun there". If there are no bands forming in an Engineering department there is something seriously wrong with the creative environment of the school or with the people who attend it. If you really want to find out why this is such a terrible idea go somewhere that has already done it.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by yummyfajitas on Friday November 25, 2011 @11:16AM (#3277403)
I've worked in a technical campus that was completely silent at night. The students would go across town to another university because "the music was better" or "it's more fun there".

Translation: "Women don't go to technical schools, lets go where the women are."

This problem could also be solved by pairing technical educations - an engineering/nursing school would not suffer this problem.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by fmota on Thursday November 24, 2011 @10:35PM (#3276117)
On a global scale, a liberal arts curriculum is the exception, not the rule. I highly doubt that Chinese universities have liberal arts curricula.
Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by est on Thursday November 24, 2011 @10:15PM (#3276085)
> Why should university be about getting a job? Shouldn't university be about learning, and being recognised for learning.

Chinese university has a different definition. It's like vocational schools rather than college. Chinese vocational schools are like dirty work training camp.

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by GHFigs on Friday November 25, 2011 @02:37AM (#3276511)
The problem is not (e.g.) poets and historians, but that the supply of people-qualified-to-be-poets and people-qualified-to-be-historians exceeds the demand for them.

(Full disclosure: I am a high school dropout, so I'm not qualified to do anything.)

Re:China to cancel college majors that don't pay by justlearning on Thursday November 24, 2011 @10:18PM (#3276091)
I agree, although in theory.

It would a different set of priorities for a single child whose parents toiled in government factories (or even to till land - often migrating across countries to work just because they were 'transferred'). The culture of aspiring to be an artist or a 'non-professional' (defined locally as not one who brings a pay check every month; not the freelancer kind) has yet to be cultivated. (The irony is - pre communism era was the opposite; it was artists all around)