News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by ghshephard on Thursday November 24, 2011 @06:58PM (#3275755)
Seems like there's an opportunity here - how difficult would it be for a fan to video / stream the "all-22" from high angle (read nosebleed) seats? I've brought my Laptop and SLR into football and baseball games (Oakland), so they aren't that strict about allowing media/comms equipment in.
Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by ubernostrum on Thursday November 24, 2011 @10:16PM (#3276087)
Amusingly, baseball broadcasts would also benefit from a broader view.

Televised baseball consists almost entirely of views of the pitcher and the batter, and only turns somewhere else to show where the ball ended up or to focus on a runner who's doing something.

And that misses out on so much of the actual game. The standard view from center field, looking at the pitcher and the batter, can't show you an infield shift. It can't show you how deep the outfielders are playing. It can't show you players reacting to signs from managers and coaches. It can't show you anything except one tiny portion of what's actually happening on the field.

And so you can't really understand why things happen the way they do -- somebody hit a little bloop single into right field? Maybe it was poor defense that allowed it to happen, but maybe there was a shift on and the outfield was playing deep. You don't know, and won't see, any of that in a televised game.

Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by whatusername on Thursday November 24, 2011 @10:31PM (#3276111)
Have you ever seen televised test match cricket? The CG overlays (bowls short/long, the direction the batter has played each shot, the positions of the fielders) -- add a heap of info (that a TV can show better than being there in person)
Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by babar on Thursday November 24, 2011 @07:06PM (#3275765)
I am pretty sure the NFL would shut down any distribution very quickly - not sure how much of an opportunity there is if it blatantly violates someone's IP rights. What I don't understand is why the NFL wouldn't use it to generate more revenue. Do they really think the criticism would be any worse than it is today with 24/7 sports talk and online message boards? Why not have the criticism be more grounded in reality?
Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by ghshephard on Thursday November 24, 2011 @07:30PM (#3275801)
I'm a pretty strong supporter of IP rights - but in this case I feel capturing the game that I'm watching falls into grey area - something akin to a bootleg of a concert.

I agree it's likely that a live stream would be shut down fairly quickly, particularly at scale, but I'm thinking a combination of after-the-fact + some intelligent post-processing might be useful/valuable.

Admittedly, the majority-value is in the real-time production, but, by providing after-the game all-22 videos, you might be able to fly somewhat under the radar.

I've never been asked to stop taking pictures with my (admittedly small) 70-200 lens - and it's usually perched atop a rail for the entire game - I could just as easily have been filming the entire game as snapping pictures.

Looking at various venue's policies - it would be hard to do this on a reliable basis with a larger lens: http://www.coliseum.com/info/prohibiteditems.php

But, the all-22 isn't really a zoom situation anyways...

Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by yarzigard on Thursday November 24, 2011 @09:37PM (#3276020)
I can see them not letting you film in the stadium, but how about you rent a blimp, and get sufficiently above/outside the stadiums airspace?
Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by rsanchez1 on Thursday November 24, 2011 @07:53PM (#3275843)
Yeah, I think that's just an excuse they're using. Today's 24-hour media subjects athletes to extreme scrutiny. Any action results in intense criticism. If any athlete does something tabloid-worthy, people will know. Adding more "data", the All-22 footage, won't change the situation much. The owners probably have this irrational fear that this footage will let opposing teams gain greater insights into their teams strategies, and while the NFL might want to open this additional line of revenue, the owners might have their hands tied.
Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by malbs on Thursday November 24, 2011 @10:14PM (#3276079)
but the teams already have access to the footage, it's the fans who dont
Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by matdwyer on Thursday November 24, 2011 @07:02PM (#3275761)
That would work for about 20 minutes until they find out your location and throw the book at you for broadcasting a copyrighted event.

You got an SLR in, but try "filming" a game with it - you'll be stopped in under 10 minutes, I promise you

Also, that isn't like the streaming sites where you can be at a desk in Sweden and re-broadcasting games fairly anonymously... they'd just walk up to your seat and escort you out.

Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by SamReidHughes on Thursday November 24, 2011 @08:23PM (#3275895)
> That would work for about 20 minutes until they find out your location and throw the book at you for broadcasting a copyrighted event.

Um, no? There is nothing copyrighted about the on-field action of a football game. All they can do is kick you out of the stadium.

Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by matdwyer on Thursday November 24, 2011 @10:11PM (#3276074)
Go try it and let us know how it works out. Nearly every professional sports team has policies against recording (even your own home videos) at the games. You'll promptly be asked to leave if you don't comply.

By your logic, If Fox has the superbowl, NBC could sit above an open stadium in a helicopter and broadcast the whole game - I don't think thats the case, but I don't have the laws to back it up.

Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by burgerbrain on Thursday November 24, 2011 @11:03PM (#3276168)
"You'll promptly be asked to leave if you don't comply."

That is exactly what he just said....

Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by maqr on Thursday November 24, 2011 @08:42PM (#3275934)
I'd honestly be surprised if it wasn't some kind of serious crime. The NFL is very aggressive about IP.
Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by jwallaceparker on Thursday November 24, 2011 @11:47PM (#3276240)
>> Um, no? There is nothing copyrighted about the on-field action of a football game. All they can do is kick you out of the stadium.

The NFL leases exclusive rights to TV stations to broadcast the action.

Anyone else who broadcasts the action will get sued and shut down.

Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by ars on Friday November 25, 2011 @12:40AM (#3276322)
His question is what law gives the NFL this right. You can't just claim "I own" this.

As far as I know I am allowed to record anything I want. Perhaps not with audio, but I am not aware of any law that gives someone the right to prevent video recording.

They have the right to kick you out (if they catch you), but not to prevent recording.

If you know of such a law, please post it.

Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by learc83 on Friday November 25, 2011 @01:47AM (#3276443)
http://www.harvardlawreview.org/media/pdf/united_states_v_ma...

2007 the 2nd circuit upheld an anti-bootlegging law, that prevents people from selling unauthorized recordings of live concerts.

I don't agree with it, but I think that under the law an NFL "performance" might be covered.

Of course the concert is a performance of a copyrighted work so who knows unless the teams are merely "performing" copyrighted written plays?

Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by SamReidHughes on Friday November 25, 2011 @05:23AM (#3276758)
Concerts (and plays, speeches, etc) are performances, which are different from improvised speech and athletic competitions.
Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by baddox on Thursday November 24, 2011 @11:14PM (#3276188)
Don't be so quick to attribute saneness to IP protection laws. Don't they still do the whole "any rebroadcast, retransmission, or account of this game is prohibited" thing?
Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by matwood on Friday November 25, 2011 @08:59AM (#3277074)
I believe the teams jerseys, likenesses, logos, etc... all fall under copyright.
Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by w1ntermute on Thursday November 24, 2011 @07:06PM (#3275768)
What about posting it after the fact? If you were to use a small enough camera (as technology advances, this will only get easier), it's very possible you could make it through a game without getting caught.
Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by matdwyer on Thursday November 24, 2011 @07:08PM (#3275776)
Sure, you could have a go-pro or something, but it wont be anywhere near what people will pay for. They want the full overhead view so they can track the plays & the movement of each player - you're still not getting that angle from the nosebleeds.

Regardless, its an awful lot of work which is a) still illegal (therefore risky) b) difficult to market and c) completely obsolete the second the NFL network starts a new TV/online network for it

Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by w1ntermute on Thursday November 24, 2011 @07:18PM (#3275791)
Well, it's better than nothing. From what it said at the end of the article, it doesn't look like the NFL has any plans to start selling this information to fans any time soon.
Re:The sports footage you won't see on TV this Thanksgiving by brownie on Thursday November 24, 2011 @07:07PM (#3275774)
The leagues would take you to court if you tried to openly sell that vision. There's a reason that they have the "expressed written consent" message tacked on to every broadcast.