My point is the ramifications of this ruling are huge even though member states are presently passing laws in direct contradiction with this ruling.
Let's be clear here, I hate the Digital Economy Act. But I want my parliament to repeal it.
As much as I hate the idea of SOPA, as much as I hate the digital economy act, as much as I love privacy and vehemently argue for it, this is a very, very worrying ruling for anyone who values democracy.
As Switch says in the Matrix, "Not like this... not like this".
Perhaps (quite obviously from the d/vs) I didn't say it right or this is not the place to say it or perhaps you think I'm misunderstanding complex laws that I am definitely not even a novice in, but this is how I feel.
The fact that they are unelected and capable of overturning, reversing, or arbitrarily altering legislative decisions is exactly the point of judicial entities. Democracy is good because it's better at protecting rights than other forms of government - but if judges can do a better job, let them.
Disclaimer: American writing here. On this side of the pond, the courts are the only thing keeping us from racing into an uncontrolled police state.
That is very much within the scope of what judges are for in many countries, including the various legal systems of the UK:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judicial_review
Checks and balances....