News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU Court of Justice: Censorship in Name of Copyright Viol... by kiba on Thursday November 24, 2011 @06:06PM (#3275667)
I value my liberties more than I value any democractic institution.
Re:EU Court of Justice: Censorship in Name of Copyright Viol... by fauldsh on Friday November 25, 2011 @06:15AM (#3276819)
This is something I find very interesting. A non-elected official provides something interesting, they are not fighting to be re-elected every year. If they are not worrying about re-election they are able to pass unpopular laws and they aren't worrying about raising money for election campaigns. If we give them the benefit of the doubt (wisely or not) that they want the best for the country then there are clear positives to the very fact they aren't elected. I find it funny that in the UK there is much more vocal opposition to the EU making laws than to the power The House of Lords has (this is my own personal experience with no evidence whatsoever). And even funnier that I find myself agreeing with the vast majority of the contributions these two non-elected entities provide.
Re:EU Court of Justice: Censorship in Name of Copyright Viol... by srl on Thursday November 24, 2011 @10:36PM (#3276119)
This.

The fact that they are unelected and capable of overturning, reversing, or arbitrarily altering legislative decisions is exactly the point of judicial entities. Democracy is good because it's better at protecting rights than other forms of government - but if judges can do a better job, let them.

Disclaimer: American writing here. On this side of the pond, the courts are the only thing keeping us from racing into an uncontrolled police state.