Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia
by ErrantX on Thursday November 24, 2011 @04:00AM
(#3273704)
Actually; that is a prime example of where the deletion process is failing - because the only option is "delete or not delete".
That article is a problem; if you read it, it is not a biography, it describes an event. Which, I suspect, is the point the nominator was trying to make.
For a reader, the content is better presented in an article on Women's rights in Egypt (or activism in Egypt) with the title redirected there.
Alternatively there is always Wikinews.
Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia
by sammyo on Thursday November 24, 2011 @08:33PM
(#3275915)
Looking through the list of deletion candidates I saw merging as an alternative to a delete.
This one was sponsored by a very prolific Wikipedian, though, who has a particular affection for the rule that one event doesn't make you notable:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion...
Which is totally outrageous. It's tempting to conclude the nominator was just an idiot, or possibly pursuing some conservative agenda. But by Hanlon's Razor, I assume that the nominator was just less aware of this story than others. Maybe it's a good thing that such articles can be challenged. I wish it had been speedy-kept though; it's embarassing to have the deletion templates on the article.
There is unanimous agreement that the article must be kept, so far. So, the system is working. Kind of.