News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia by bane on Thursday November 24, 2011 @12:58AM (#3273314)
But you know as well as anybody that quite often in AfD notability is firmly established and an overzealous WP nerd will just simply ignore it because they feel the need to protect the electrons they believe have come to serve them in their virtual fiefdom.

And to be clear we're not talking about cases of obvious vandalism, there's plenty of cases where perfectly WP conformant edits are made, marked for deletion and then the inevitable shit fight where sources are provided clearly establishing notability are provided only to be tossed aside.

If a reason for ignoring the provided evidence is given it almost always surrounds the following terms in the sentence you quoted:

"significant", "reliable", "independent"

Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia by neilk on Thursday November 24, 2011 @03:33AM (#3273656)
I don't follow AfD closely. I'm a programmer. But I just had a look through the latest AfDs and I have to say there's little I disagreed with.

This one was sponsored by a very prolific Wikipedian, though, who has a particular affection for the rule that one event doesn't make you notable:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion...

Which is totally outrageous. It's tempting to conclude the nominator was just an idiot, or possibly pursuing some conservative agenda. But by Hanlon's Razor, I assume that the nominator was just less aware of this story than others. Maybe it's a good thing that such articles can be challenged. I wish it had been speedy-kept though; it's embarassing to have the deletion templates on the article.

There is unanimous agreement that the article must be kept, so far. So, the system is working. Kind of.

Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia by ErrantX on Thursday November 24, 2011 @04:00AM (#3273704)
Actually; that is a prime example of where the deletion process is failing - because the only option is "delete or not delete".

That article is a problem; if you read it, it is not a biography, it describes an event. Which, I suspect, is the point the nominator was trying to make.

For a reader, the content is better presented in an article on Women's rights in Egypt (or activism in Egypt) with the title redirected there.

Alternatively there is always Wikinews.

Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia by sammyo on Thursday November 24, 2011 @08:33PM (#3275915)
Looking through the list of deletion candidates I saw merging as an alternative to a delete.
Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia by bane on Thursday November 24, 2011 @11:15AM (#3274688)
Right. Being able to flag anything for deletion, then going through the hassle of defending it puts the onus on not deleting it, not on those who want to delete it, which I think it wrong.