News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by rcarr on Saturday September 03, 2022 @10:56AM (#32702432)
“No politician wants to tell us the real story of fossil fuel depletion. The real story is that we are already running short of oil, coal and natural gas because the direct and indirect costs of extraction are reaching a point where the selling price of food and other basic necessities needs to be unacceptably high to make the overall economic system work.“

This is the real problem and also the lie. The people to whom the prices are “unacceptably high” are the people at the top of the pyramid who would subsequently need to pay appropriate wages. I would hazard a guess that if you took the current wages of workers which have essentially stagnated and regressed for fifty years and raised them to where they would have been had they been increasing at their pre 1970s rate, and then compared that purchasing power to where prices are at now, all of a sudden the prices of things would not seem so out of whack.

Executive suite are still getting ridiculous pay rises, investors are still getting ridiculous returns, meanwhile the same companies are continuing to try to shaft workers with below inflation pay rises. You cannot skim in this fashion indefinitely, eventually you get to the point we’re at now where the jig is up, you’ve put so much wealth at the top that it collapses the pillars holding the whole system up.

You cannot just park billions of money in ‘safe’ assets (e.g housing) like Smaug the dragon because you’re afraid of losing money. The money represents resources. If you’re not smart enough or brave enough to choose worthwhile and worthy people and enterprises, organisations etc to invest the money in then you don’t deserve to have it and it should be reallocated via the mechanisms of the market to smarter people who do. Yet the government keep bailing out failing company or bank after failing company or bank rather than letting the natural reallocation occur. And so we end up with a zombie economy that preys on the living to feed the dead.

Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by javisnsi on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:08AM (#32702556)
> No politician wants to tell us the real story of fossil fuel depletion.

I am not sure I am convinced with the author's argument. Even if we put aside how all (or most) politicians and public fossil fuel companies (who should disclose existential risks for the company) are conspiring together to lie, I don't understand what is the motivation is for all these parties to work together to lie, just to keep wages low (but if execs are getting ridiculous pays, wages for the company as a line item are perhaps still high). Wouldn't companies see an existential risk and plan ahead to try to diversify investments, rising pricing if its progressively getting expensive over the years to produce etc..

Reminds me of what a friend recently told me - Its funny how the politicians/government/bureaucracies are both incapable of doing anything useful yet also capable of world wide conspiracies.

Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by rcarr on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:18AM (#32702666)
There doesn’t need to be a conspiracy. All it needs is for the majority of people in leadership positions to act in their own self interests rather than in the interest of the people they’re meant to be representing. The outcome is the same as if there was a big conspiracy theory. It’s like having two functions, you put the same variables in, the function bodies are different, but they both spit out the same result.
Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by javisnsi on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:32AM (#32702813)
Well, I suppose then I didn't understand the motive well - How does the public fossil fuel company benefit by this (its illegal to make false disclosures to investors afaik)? how do politicians across the spectrum (who keep fighting about climate change and effect of fossil fuels) benefit from this? And, just curious - on the academic front, I keep reading about effects of emissions from fossil fuel and projections for 50-100 years, why is there so little about when we run out of fossil fuels (maybe they have a motive to be quiet/lie too) but I suppose I don't see it.
Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by peteradio on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:59AM (#32703140)
One theory: Thomas Malthus was 300 years early. None of the solutions to the problem are touchable so instead nobody does anything except protect themselves and let the horror show carry out naturally. The survivors will live prosperously for a time and the same thing will probably happen again and again and again. To be clear we will never really run out of energy but we will again and again run out of compassion.
Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by rcarr on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:34PM (#32703496)
This is pretty much spot on. Javinsi is thinking too high level compared to how the executives and politicians think.

The self interested majority (not all) do not care about these problems. They can’t act on them without risking their own positions because the solutions are unpalatable to the people they rely on to maintain their stations. Subsequently these are things to be kicked down the road for someone else to address. The politician only really cares about getting re-elected, the executive about closing the latest deal. They only care about the medium to long term in as much as it allows them to keep gaining in the short to medium term.

The majority of people at this level are over 40. They likely have only 40 - 50 years left to live (we’re going with higher life expectancy because they’re wealthy). They will likely be retired in 20 to 30 years. As long as things are ok in that time frame they’re golden. Get enough money for some nice houses scattered around the world near some good golf courses. Trump is literally the archetypal representation.

Look at house prices in New Zealand. They’re literally buying property there because they think in a worse case scenario, if the entire system collapses they can just ride out the storm until it either rebuilds itself or they die of old age in relative luxury. Keyword: relative. So long as they’re still in an elevated position they do not really give a fuck if things go backwards, even for themselves.

And even if they do fail in the short term the consequences are negligible. Look at some failing companies from ten years ago and see what the CEO is doing now. Nine times out of ten they’re either CEO or chairman somewhere else or retired. You have to REALLY fuck up a la Elizabeth Holmes to fall out of favour of the ‘network’.

You even see this in fiction. When Tyrion needs Bron’s help he won’t do it for the money: he wants a castle. Bron is smart and gets the game: if he wants to escape the life of being a hired killer for good he needs to join the nobility network, not just collect a paycheck. The castle would grant him that.

Closer to home, I recently worked at a company on an application that was so slow it was bordering on unusable by the users. The engineers had been trying for years to get resources for a rebuild. Yet all the business department cared about was adding more features because they could make more money from them. This inevitably kept making the problem worse. Taking the time out to refactor the program was unglamorous and didn’t give the business department anything to show the top dogs who were clamouring for growth, growth, growth. Eventually that program will get to a point where it is unusable. The parallels with the global situation are easy to see.

Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by roenxi on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:48AM (#32702999)
I don't personally bother reading Tverberg articles, and I'm not about to start now. That being said, if we stick to just that quote, it is easy to justify.

If you have a situation where doing a thing has worked for more than 50 years years, and there is a theory that thing is suddenly going to stop working then it is a very rare person who will stand up and say or act on that politically. Large groups of humans are devastatingly evidence-driven and can't cope with simple leaps of logic like doing the same thing will get a different outcome.

So in this case, if we are about to hit peak oil and suddenly the global economy starts collapsing there is no way the politicians would sound the alarm. They'd be waiting patiently until public understanding of the matter was very high. You can see that behaviour all the way through resource problems.

Politicians can't even sell spending the same amount of money as they tax; they aren't going to try and pitch doing without energy until the crisis has well and truly hit. There is no upside for them.

Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by nevrherd on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:17AM (#32702660)
Their plan is project an image of cool headed control to keep their power and status quo intact as long as possible. No reason to be the one to risk destabilizing things that work well for them. Even if society intentionally reorganized itself, institutions may become meaningless, ending the good times for leaders and their cottage industry the institution provides.

I don’t think it’s an intentional conspiracy, but lack of material upside (the root of power being material ownership), for powers that be to risk their power and (for some) legacy as being the one in charge when it all went sideways. Such folks do not live long after the fall.

Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by peteradio on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:12AM (#32702600)
Conspiracy to sit on you hands looks a lot like incapability to do anything.
Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by chrisco255 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:43AM (#32702954)
The costs of extraction have nothing to do with it. It's just dysfunctional political systems that toggle back and forth between "let's ban fossil fuels", and "omg, the greedy gas companies are charging $6 a gallon!" The former caused the latter. Very little investment has been made in tapping new wells because of hamstringing by ESG virtue signaling. As a result, we're in a pickle.

The inflation we're experiencing has nothing to do with energy supply, it has everything to do with monetary, diplomatic, and fiscal policy.

Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by AstralStorm on Saturday September 03, 2022 @02:04PM (#32704425)
I really hate it when people are spewing garbage mixed with fact.

Yes, the inflation has nothing to do with energy supply, or even price of digging it all up. The pricing of it is always driven by a plausible excuse and greed.

No, investment in tapping new wells is at an all time high, and for example has turned USA into a net oil exporter. Gas too. Thing is, fossil fuels are not evenly distributed, nor do we want to use them to heat up the planet more. So when a major producer is cut off or decides to do everyone in, we get a price spike, and prices rarely return to baseline.

Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by thrown_22 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:07AM (#32702542)
You're making the mistake of thinking money means anything.

Economics is a thin veneer we put over thermodynamics to make accounting easier.

Whenever the thermodynamics doesn't work economics stops working either. The 1970s were a short period were thermodynamics were sub-optimal. The dark ages were a longer period.

Money is ink on paper or bits in a computer.

Neither of those things runs a tractor or lets water flow.

Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by soco on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:14AM (#32702611)
You're right, money don't run tractors or flow waters. But they build serious incentives for either - people won't run a tractor if the incentive is missing, or a too strong incentive might stop a water flow.
Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by thrown_22 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:16AM (#32702645)
People don't run tractors. Fossil fuels do. And we've been told that we're phasing out fossil fuels some time between 2030 and 2050.

How do we run tractors then?

Probably with horses. Welcome to 1500. Please mind the plague.

Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by kwhitefoot on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:48AM (#32703000)
Electricity?
Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by andsoitis on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:13AM (#32702602)
> Economics is a thin veneer we put over thermodynamics to make accounting easier.

Shouldn't it be "Economics is a thin veneer we put over thermodynamics to make trade / exchange easier"?

Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by rcarr on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:30AM (#32702791)
“Money is ink on paper or bits in a computer. Neither of those things runs a tractor or lets water flow.”

Yes but they tell the people who have the fuel and the water where they should send it: the highest bidder.

The person who is willing to spend the most money has:

a) acquired more money than competitors through smart decisions that have added value to people who have in turn given them their money

b) decided they have a more pressing need for those resources that they will outbid the other buyers rather than wait for a drop in prices or to seek an alternative.

If the buyer does not make good use of his newly acquired resources he will soon lose money and will not be able to compete with the other buyers.

This is how the economic system is meant to allocate resources. To people who have a proven track record of making decisions with successful outcomes.

If you start bailing out failures as happened in 2007-2009 you break this fundamental allocation of resources to where they will be most appropriately used based on the historical precedent of success. And when that happens you get what we have now, which is a breakdown of the entire system.

Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by yunohn on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:28AM (#32702781)
> Economics is a thin veneer we put over thermodynamics to make accounting easier.

Maybe you could link a source explaining this correlation with some examples? Otherwise, it just sounds like “higher salaries for more effort”, which is obviously false.

Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by ETH_start on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:54AM (#32703072)
>>The people to whom the prices are “unacceptably high” are the people at the top of the pyramid who would subsequently need to pay appropriate wages. I would hazard a guess that if you took the current wages of workers which have essentially stagnated and regressed for fifty years and raised them to where they would have been had they been increasing at their pre 1970s rate, and then compared that purchasing power to where prices are at now, all of a sudden the prices of things would not seem so out of whack.

There are several things are wrong with this:

Wages have grown at their fastest rate in history, globally, over the last 30 years:

https://www.csmonitor.com/layout/set/amphtml/World/2016/0207...

It is only in the advanced economies where wage growth has slowed. And the slowdown is much less severe than commonly believed. I personally spent years promulgating this graph all over the internet:

https://imgur.com/BlEiA9d

I wish someone had pointed out to me in what ways this graph is misleading. This article does a good job of doing that:

http://www.brookings.edu/research/opinions/2014/12/22-source...

To summarize:

1. Wages are just one component of employment compensation. When the nonwage components - which have grown faster than wages - are factored in, you see the line track productivity growth much more closely.

2. Another factor creating the illusion of a growing gap between productivity and worker compensation is the use of different inflation indexes to measure productivity and worker compensation. The indexes largely mirrored each other before 1973, but diverged significantly since then, leading to inflation-adjusted worker compensation growth appearing artificially depressed compared to inflation-adjusted productivity growth.

3. Worker compensation growth has in fact slowed somewhat, and almost all of this slowdown can be explained by the commensurate slowdown in productivity growth in the US.

>>investors are still getting ridiculous returns

Investors are not getting ridiculous returns. If you look at labor's share of national income, it has largely remained the same if you exclude just one asset category: housing, where rent has increased faster than not just inflation, but income as well. See Figure 3:

https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/2015a_r...

And the solution to outsized gains due to housing scarcity is not to ban profiteering. It's to solve the housing scarcity problem. One study estimates that if just three cities - San Francisco, San Jose and New York - had limited the growth of their housing sector regulations to that of the median rate of all US cities, US GDP would have grown by 36 percent more between 1964 and 2009:

https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/mac.20170388

Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by AstralStorm on Saturday September 03, 2022 @02:06PM (#32704447)
Wages have not been tracking productivity though. The gap ever widens. Last time it tracked was in the 70s. No matter how you inflation adjust.

Fossil fuel companies (Shell and BP at least) reaped billions USD windfall from all the issues with war.

Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by ETH_start on Sunday September 04, 2022 @09:17AM (#32712723)
Employer compensation has almost tracked productivity..

Like I explained, the slight gap is due to a slight increase in capital's share of national income, and that is solely due to housing.

Re:The World’s Energy Problem Is Far Worse Than We’re Being ... by rcarr on Saturday September 03, 2022 @02:15PM (#32704536)
> Wages have grown at their fastest rate in history, globally, over the last 30 years: https://www.csmonitor.com/layout/set/amphtml/World/2016/0207... It is only in the advanced economies where wage growth has slowed.

Exactly. Most likely as a direct response of MBA CEOs of advanced economies outsourcing manufacturing to foreign companies to increase their bottom line. Then a pandemic happens and you realise that you have no domestic manufacturers of medical equipment because government and enterprise have not fostered an environment of self sufficiency. And then academics scratch their heads and wonder why movements like Brexit gain traction. (For the record, I voted against Brexit although I am not sure how I would vote if the referendum was held again.).

> 1. Wages are just one component of employment compensation. When the nonwage components - which have grown faster than wages - are factored in, you see the line track productivity growth much more closely.

Maybe in America with its ludicrously expensive health system. In the UK with the NHS I'm not seeing anywhere near the increase in benefits to compensate for the loss in wages. And what real point is my pension when I can't afford to get on the housing ladder because my wages are too low to keep up with house price inflation? All of my pension will end up being subsumed by rent. If anything, the rise of freelance working shatters this argument because when you freelance you receive no benefits. Ask anyone in the EU who is earning decent wages and it is always the freelancers.

> 2. Another factor creating the illusion of a growing gap between productivity and worker compensation is the use of different inflation indexes to measure productivity and worker compensation. The indexes largely mirrored each other before 1973, but diverged significantly since then, leading to inflation-adjusted worker compensation growth appearing artificially depressed compared to inflation-adjusted productivity growth.

Again, I'm not buying this. If anything, most articles I read seem to use the lower CPI instead of RPI which I think is ridiculous. Perhaps the mismatch is to do with outsourcing manufacturing bases? Is productivity accurately measured? According to google:

"Productivity measures the efficiency of a company's production process. It is calculated by dividing the outputs produced by a company by the inputs used in its production process."

In an age where accountancy tricks are routinely used to minimise declared profits to shield against paying tax, are we 100% sure that the "outputs produced by a company" are accurately reflected in the statistics?

>And the solution to outsized gains due to housing scarcity is not to ban profiteering. It's to solve the housing scarcity problem.

Do not agree. Speak to any real estate agent and they will tell you that huge numbers of houses are being sold to foreign investors that then sit empty. There is zero point in building more houses if all the houses are just going to be sold to people with capital who don't even live in the country. You can build and build as much as you like but they will just snatch them up with above asking price offers fully in cash. First you have to ban people who don't live in a country for more than six months of the year from purchasing property. That in of itself might fix the problem. If it doesn't, then you need some kind of tax to make mass landlording an unprofitable business. If you don't, you just end up in the same situation where a few large companies with capital hoover up everything. You can't have an situation where a few giants effectively control everything with something as vital to survival as housing. There has to be appropriate regulation. An exponential tax on property ownership would be one such solution. And then finally, yes, build houses and ignore NIMBYs.