News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Non Fungible Tickets by chizhik-pyzhik on Friday September 02, 2022 @10:27PM (#32698028)
This is a great example of taking a concept that originated in cryptocurrency and removing the cryptocurrency part.

There's no need to make a ticket transferrable and tracked with a decentralized ledger... but the uniqueness+art aspect is still pretty neat.

Re:Non Fungible Tickets by janstice on Friday September 02, 2022 @10:52PM (#32698183)
Disagree on the no need to make a ticket transferable part - this is the place where NFTs make the most sense - there really is only 1 seat 22B at the Lakers game next Saturday, but in an untrustworthy secondary market I want to know that what I’m buying is (a) legit and (b) the only version in existence.
Re:Non Fungible Tickets by searchableguy on Friday September 02, 2022 @10:58PM (#32698217)
In practice, most conferences don't want to allow transferable tickets because it ends up with a scalper situation.

The scalper will annoy everyone and take any money that would otherwise go to conference.

Secondary market for tickets is very small.

Re:Non Fungible Tickets by runnerup on Friday September 02, 2022 @11:49PM (#32698488)
As with all things that scalpers re-sell which are not necessary for survival and health I find myself unable to come to a reasonable answer for why the first sale shouldn't be at market price.
Re:Non Fungible Tickets by jcparkyn on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:02AM (#32698576)
Complete speculation, but I would guess that in many cases the company/organisation running the conference would want lots of people to come (e.g. for marketing or hiring purposes), even if they could increase total ticket revenue by raising prices.

Selling expensive tickets is also bad PR, which might be worth more to the organisers than the extra ticket revenue.

Re:Non Fungible Tickets by iamkroot on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:41AM (#32698805)
I've always figured you could just do an auction.

Say you have 500 tickets. You give everyone who wants to go 48 hours to submit how much they're willing to pay for a ticket. At the end of the time period the 500 people whose bids were the highest all get the tickets.

You could publish the current price of the tickets during the bidding time frame and allow people to modify their bids at any point.

The final price would be whatever the 500th lowest bid was. In the event of a tie, choose randomly among the people tied for 500th.

I imagine this would be greeted with complaints about how it gives the rich an advantage, but I can't think of a fairer way to distribute tickets that also avoids the scalper problem.

Re:Non Fungible Tickets by ddevault on Saturday September 03, 2022 @03:11AM (#32699505)
Cultural events should not be the exclusive domain of the wealthy. The free market is not God. Rubbing more capitalism into a problem makes that problem worse, not better.

https://pitchfork.com/news/ticketmaster-hit-with-class-actio...

Re:Non Fungible Tickets by yellowapple on Saturday September 03, 2022 @03:13AM (#32699510)
> In practice, most conferences don't want to allow transferable tickets because it ends up with a scalper situation.

In practice, whether or not scalpers exist is of very little relevance to most conferences, because...

> The scalper will annoy everyone and take any money that would otherwise go to conference.

...that money wasn't going to go to the conference anyway, because the conference is charging less than the market price (i.e. what the scalper is able to get away with charging). That money would go to the conference if the conference did charge the market price... and then the scalpers wouldn't have any margins left and therefore would have no reason to be scalpers anyway.

As for "annoy everyone", in practice that's also of very little relevance once the conference actually has your money. The only people it'd annoy are the ones trying to buy tickets, and it'd only be particularly annoying if scalpers were the only option - i.e. if the conference was already sold out, and therefore had already taken as much money as it possibly could.

----

The more reasonable answer for why conferences don't want transferable tickets is because they often tie tickets to attendees' identities (e.g. photo ID) and that connection becomes impractical unless the conference is actively involved in the transfer process. The reasons for that are partially addressed through NFTs (namely: wanting to ensure that it's an authentic ticket that actually belongs to you), but also partially not addressed (namely: security, especially if you have particularly-high-profile speakers and/or attendees).

Re:Non Fungible Tickets by RHSeeger on Saturday September 03, 2022 @10:38AM (#32702277)
Many artists specifically don't charge "market value" (ie, the most they possibly can) for tickets, because they want their fans to be able to attend the event; not just the wealthy ones. Scalpers buying out the tickets and reselling them higher defeats the point of this.
Re:Non Fungible Tickets by bombcar on Friday September 02, 2022 @11:46PM (#32698469)
Stubhub disagrees.

And venues would love scalper if they got a cut.

Re:Non Fungible Tickets by XorNot on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:32AM (#32698742)
I helped build this system for a major ticketing company. We used a database, that was it - because its pretty simple overall when you're taking a cut. Confirm original barcode, mark transaction, issue a new barcode.

At performance time only the new barcodes work, and if you didn't get it through the ticketing company then you were just out of luck.

Re:Non Fungible Tickets by TheDudeMan on Friday September 02, 2022 @10:58PM (#32698214)
> This is a great example of taking a concept that originated in cryptocurrency

What concept are you talking about? Venue tickets have been a thing for a while.

Re:Non Fungible Tickets by boffinism on Saturday September 03, 2022 @03:30AM (#32699599)
I believe the concept referenced is the one mentioned in the second paragraph: uniqueness+art.
Re:Non Fungible Tickets by TheDudeMan on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:22PM (#32709487)
Like a painting?
Re:Non Fungible Tickets by boffinism on Sunday September 04, 2022 @03:46PM (#32716977)
... within the context of ticketing.
Re:Non Fungible Tickets by TheDudeMan on Friday September 02, 2022 @10:49PM (#32698167)
How else would you make a digital ticket transferable (on 3rd-party marketplaces) and verifiably authentic? Honest question. It's probably possible.

The problem today is that if I buy a 2nd-hand a concert ticket on <literally any marketplace>, I might be getting screwed with a counterfeit ticket (as far as I know).

Re:Non Fungible Tickets by thatguy0900 on Friday September 02, 2022 @11:49PM (#32698491)
Do they actually want easy, transparent, not Grey market digital ticket secondary markets? Sounds like a heaven for scalpers and speed purchase botting.
Re:Non Fungible Tickets by boffinism on Saturday September 03, 2022 @03:32AM (#32699610)
Is the "3rd-party marketplace" bit a hard requirement? If I'm organising an event and I am ok with tickets being transferred, would it satisfy requirements if I offered a mechanism for transfers myself?