News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why are Pakistan’s floods so extreme this year? by hedora on Friday September 02, 2022 @04:58PM (#32695648)
Water infiltration is measured by digging a small hole, filling it with water, and seeing how fast it drains. There's no way that regenerative agriculture has changed soil composition multiple feet down, which is what would be needed for the soil to absorb multiple feet of water.

I went to check the above sentence, and the first hit was this detailed article from Washington State, which analyses Brown's claims in detail, and explains why the scientific community is skeptical of them:

https://csanr.wsu.edu/regen-ag-solid-principles-extraordinar...

Anyway, even if, as Gabe Brown claims, regenerative agriculture is an order of magnitude more effective than expected, and you applied it to 100% of the land in Pakistan, it would still only reduce flooding by less than a foot.

Re:Why are Pakistan’s floods so extreme this year? by mountaintimefrm on Friday September 02, 2022 @05:40PM (#32696030)
> Water infiltration is measured by digging a small hole, filling it with water, and seeing how fast it drains.

Informally yes, but the scientific way is to use a ring infiltrometer: https://www.fao.org/3/s8684e/s8684e0a.htm -- Basically instead of digging a hole, you pound a pipe into the ground and then fill the pipe with water.

As for agricultural practices being able to change soil composition multiple feet down, trees and tap-rooted plants are very effective at placing large volumes of organic matter at depth. One example, Lacy Phacelia (Phacelia tanacetifolia) is an annual plant that produces a dense fibrous root system that reaches a depth of 4 feet; in the fall the Phacelia plants die, and their roots decompose at depth, creating pathways for water infiltration while also increasing soil organic matter at depth. The same goes with other trees and shrubs. The farmer from the "It ain't much but it's honest work" meme, Dave Brandt, has some really enjoyable presentations on youtube about improving soil composition at depth.

Re:Why are Pakistan’s floods so extreme this year? by worik on Friday September 02, 2022 @05:13PM (#32695775)
> . There's no way that regenerative agriculture has changed soil composition multiple feet down

How do you know that?

How deep do roots go? Do worms dig? Do you know?

I do not. But I am not making assumptions

Re:Why are Pakistan’s floods so extreme this year? by hedora on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:10PM (#32720080)
Read the article I cited.