Re:Cops wanted to keep mass surveillance app secret; privacy...
by vlod on Friday September 02, 2022 @04:45PM
(#32695512)
Thanks for posting this, I was not aware how far they've strayed off civil liberties.
Have not investigated this, but pg [0] seems to thumbs down ACLU and thumbs up FIRE:
Re:Cops wanted to keep mass surveillance app secret; privacy...
by hnbad on Friday September 02, 2022 @06:14PM
(#32696316)
FIRE is primarily funded by conservative and libertarian foundations and pg (much like most VCs) is libertarian. I'm not saying this to dunk on them, but it's unsurprising that pg would tend towards FIRE over ACLU, which is funded by slightly more progressive libertarian foundations (unless you consider George Soros a leftist).
Re:Cops wanted to keep mass surveillance app secret; privacy...
by rufus_foreman on Friday September 02, 2022 @02:07PM
(#32693913)
>> a truly civil-liberties-only ACLU
Take a look at FIRE, https://www.thefire.org.
[dead]
Re:Cops wanted to keep mass surveillance app secret; privacy...
by weberer on Friday September 02, 2022 @10:57AM
(#32691587)
You've seriously misread that paragraph. It's not saying those ideas are absurd, but that they are not civil liberties issues. This is spelled out in the very next sentence.
>Such reasoning expands the ACLU's mission to include pretty much any domestic policy issue.
I wish people wouldn't be so quick to rush to take potshots at political opponents. It lowers the quality of discussion for everyone and will eventually just turn this place into another Reddit.
Re:Cops wanted to keep mass surveillance app secret; privacy...
by CWuestefeld on Friday September 02, 2022 @10:33AM
(#32691308)
The word "absurd" doesn't show in the article, that's your characterization.
What the referenced article is saying is that to the extent that these things are "civil rights" issues, everything is thus a civil rights issue, and thus a focus on civil rights is meaningless.
Re:Cops wanted to keep mass surveillance app secret; privacy...
by woodruffw on Friday September 02, 2022 @10:42AM
(#32691408)
"If X is Y, then all Z are Y" is a kind of reduction to absurdity argument. The GP's characterization is correct, and nitpicking the fact that Reason doesn't actually use the word "absurd" doesn't meaningfully change the argumentative tack they use.
https://reason.com/2022/08/31/the-student-loan-debate-shows-...
I would support a truly civil-liberties-only ACLU, but not what they currently are.