News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Associations of body mass index, fasting insulin and infl... by evol262 on Monday August 29, 2022 @06:42PM (#32644495)
> it's saying that high BMI as a cause of premature death is likely just a proxy for high fasting insulin and inflammation and is not _by itself_ life shortening.

No, it is not. We should be very clear that high BMI is, in fact, life shortening.

High BMI is, in fact, strongly correlated with atherosclerosis. It is, in fact, strongly correlated with decreased lung volume and risk pulmonary edema. It is correlated with clot formation and stroke. It is correlated with fatty liver disease. It is correlated with decreased bone density, which leads to a heightened risk of throwing embolism-causing clots if a fall leads to a break. It is correlated with a variety of cardiac events, mostly around hardening valves and fat buildup in cardiac tissue causing lessened output while there is more circulating blood volume. It is correlated with difficulties administering anesthesia or intubating patients in case of emergency. It is correlated with...

Being obese is still horrifyingly unhealthy even if high fasting glucose is just a proxy for some of those factors (which it is not, as this study is terrible).

Re:Associations of body mass index, fasting insulin and infl... by woleium on Sunday September 11, 2022 @04:43PM (#32803107)
All valid points, thanks :)
Re:Associations of body mass index, fasting insulin and infl... by mgarfias on Monday August 29, 2022 @10:54PM (#32646141)
Well shit, my BMI is 35. And I've got a pair of stents in my ticker. OTOH I'm doing crossfit 3x/week. And can dead lift over 300# so I feel like I'm getting better. ALso, I'm built like a fireplug, so probably not fat as just big. BMI is a shitty measure.
Re:Associations of body mass index, fasting insulin and infl... by nradov on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @01:29AM (#32658718)
What is your actual body fat content? And I mean by a real test like a DEXA scan, not calipers.
Re:Associations of body mass index, fasting insulin and infl... by mgarfias on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:09PM (#32743240)
whoops, didnt see this. No real test done. My scale (that i haven't jumped on in forever) says like 35% at the last "scan".
Re:Associations of body mass index, fasting insulin and infl... by woleium on Sunday September 11, 2022 @04:42PM (#32803095)
Those scales use electrical resistance as a procy measure of water density, a proxy of muscle to fat ratio. It's a tenuous link and isn't all that accurate. If you can afford the $100, go get a DEX scan.