News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After years of setbacks, NASA’s SLS moon rocket is ready ... by simonebrunozzi on Monday August 29, 2022 @02:46AM (#32635391)
You are being upvoted, but I think that when looking at your proposal seriously, it has flaws.

Let's try with an example.

Until now: government pays $100 to build a rocket to go to the Moon, say $50 now and $50 at launch. Rocket explodes? No problem, you still get your $50.

Your proposal: government pays $100 to build a rocket to go to the Moon. $50 now, $50 if it lands. Ops. No one shows up. Err... Let's try $60 now, $40 if it lands? Nope... Still nobody around to get this contract...

Why? Because a company would charge you (simplifying a bit) $150, of which $100 now, and $50 if the rocket lands.

Congratulations. You have contributed to ballooning the Space budget. Taxpayers are thankful.

Re:After years of setbacks, NASA’s SLS moon rocket is ready ... by dmurray on Monday August 29, 2022 @03:46AM (#32635655)
Spacex seem to be quite successful with a business model of undercutting the cost-plus incumbents. Why wouldn't other companies do this if government incentives were tweaked to favour them a bit more?
Re:After years of setbacks, NASA’s SLS moon rocket is ready ... by hef19898 on Monday August 29, 2022 @05:57AM (#32636365)
We have no financials of SpaceX, except some partial leaks that are now almost a decade old. On the other hanf we have fully audited budgets of NASA. Hard to conpare those two.
Re:After years of setbacks, NASA’s SLS moon rocket is ready ... by panick21_ on Monday August 29, 2022 @09:53AM (#32638270)
If SpaceX overspent on fixed-cost programs by billions and billions they wouldn't exist anymore.
Re:After years of setbacks, NASA’s SLS moon rocket is ready ... by mabbo on Monday August 29, 2022 @09:51AM (#32638222)
But that isn't how it works now. How it works now is "You build a rocket to go to the moon. Try to keep the price down, but we'll pay whatever it costs. Plus a profit margin when you're finished."

The bidder say "I can do it for $100". Fantastic! Then they go 'over budget' (as planned) and spend $1000, and the government pays it anyway because the contract says they must. Plus $20 profit.

Meanwhile the Commercial Resupply Services missions have been a poster-child for cost-savings.

The taxpayers truly thank you for 'saving them money'.

Re:After years of setbacks, NASA’s SLS moon rocket is ready ... by wumpus on Monday August 29, 2022 @04:56AM (#32636073)
There are several examples of recent competitions that undercut your thought experiment: HLS, Gateway Resupply, Commercial Crew, Commercial Cargo, ...