No, they don't.
The majority go with the defaults, and most of the rest stick to the first thing that "works for them".
If they try something else it's usually because of either mass promotion (like with Java in the late 90s) or hype by a smaller team of early adopters (like with Node and such), not by patiently looking and evaluating solutions alone.
>Quality always rises to the top. That's a law of nature.
That's not even close to a law of nature.
In fact, "crap rises to the top" might be closer to being that. I mean, if you want a blatant example, see the music top-10.
But even they won’t find you if you don’t have an SEO-optimized page, for example, to give you a somewhat extreme example. Just doing nothing and waiting for someone to come is not an option.
Not really. Think about it for a moment: are there more people actively searching for better solutions to each and every single problem they may or may not know they have? Or are there more people like you and me who go about their day just fine completely oblivious that there might be out there a far better way of doing things, or not even bothering to spend a second to address some nuisance they have?
> If industries spent all of their marketing budget on research and development, we'd live in a very different world.
Yes, it would be a world where fortunes were spent on R&D whose outcome benefitted no one at all because no one ever heard about the outcome.
Also, as a corollary to your anti-marketing stance, multiple redundant R&D projects would be wasting resources developing stuff that was already developed and reinventing the wheel primarily because no one knew that it was already done.
I'm sure you are able to understand that actively spreading information is far more effective in getting the message out than sitting on your rear-end expecting that people are suddenly magically aware of you and things just drop from the sky onto your lap.
Sitting on your ass looking at ads is what advertizers want you to do. And it's in their interest to foster the belief that you couldn't survive without it.
That is definitely not a law of nature.
Problem is that today most technological needs are already filled by good programs so adding significant new value to peoples lives is extremely hard, so it is very unlikely that you can make naturally growing programs today on a tiny budget.
And this group was the one in charge of "fixing their relatives' computers", so we were all too happy to tell them about Google: this is how word-of-mouth worked for them.
And second, hierarchical organization does not mean at all quality is on top.
Social animals organize into hierarchies precisely because hierarchies bubble quality to the top.
Deers have antlers for reasons other than competing with other deer. To defend themselves from predators.
Since they have them, they use them to settle differences in quality. In this case, quality of self-defence.
Violent dominance is a very good way to describe hierarchy in many extant social mammals. Tyrants arise every day in both human and non-human animals. We aren't a century removed from one of the worst here in 2022. Are you thinking of eusocial mammals? The'yre closer to what you're describing here.
Also, in herd animals like sheep the hierarchy consist on basically more aggressive individual eating fist and getting what they want. But, the other members dont follow them and there is no meaning of leadership. Just that, if you are stronger and beat others, you can eat first or pick place to sleep.
> Social animals organize into hierarchies precisely because hierarchies bubble quality to the top.
They don't. In business, it can be "cheapest" or "lies the most convincingly" or "has the right connections".
Even among humans, the quality that fairy often bubbles on top is violence. You see that everywhere in the world. In Chechenia it is Kadyrov and his quality was "born to correct dad and already have proven he is ruthless when dad dies". The quality that got Adolf Hitler on top was "good speaker, able to channel fear and hate".
Those are extreme examples, but I wanted something super clear. What bubbles on top is what bubbles on top. It can occasionally be quality, but it can be host of other things too.
Seen it in dogs too, seen it a million times in people. Those are more artificial situations though.
If the animals making up the hierarchy disagrees with the individual on top, they remove it from the hierarchy. Easily. That's the whole point of herds, packs, and hierarchies. Together stronger than alone.
> If the animals making up the hierarchy disagrees with the individual on top, they remove it from the hierarchy. Easily. That's the whole point of herds, packs, and hierarchies. Together stronger than alone.
You write about it as if animals were rational systems thinkers and that is just not so.
It's quality as in the degree of excellence of pushiness.
> In this case, lower quality individual bubbles on top, cause other horses don't want to deal with jerks aggression.
That would be a higher quality individual, according to the horses.
> You write about it as if animals were rational systems thinkers and that is just not so.
We're talking about behavior that evolved millions of years ago in crustaceans, the serotonin brain system that specializes in regulating social hierarchies in animals, is still present and functioning today in you and the horses. Attribution of rationality is on your part, and in no way diminishes the effectiveness of the social brain, and the hierarchy which it encodes.
Hierarchy is one approximate solution, but hardly the globally optimal one.
The misconception is people confuses Betamax with Betacam, (both from Sony). Betacam was the Sony format for broadcasters, and the one with high quality (sound and picture). But bloody expensive.
Betamax lost due two to reasons. (1)tapes can only record 1 hour. Not enough for most recordings. Sony addressed the wrong market. (2) Price and retail distribution.
In other words, Betamax lost because VHS has a better market fit, and the market choose the technology that allowed to have theater movies in the video rental store.
(I was a Beta owner back in the 80s).
Guess then the point is that there is not one single scalar "quality" and things are not one-dimensional.
It implies that people aren't actively looking for better solutions to their problems, which is just blatantly false.
If industries spent all of their marketing budget on research and development, we'd live in a very different world. Maybe even a better one. A world where companies aren't asking "how can we fool people into buying more of what we're already making" and instead ask "what can we make that's so good it practically sells itself?"
Quality always rises to the top. That's a law of nature.