Re:Why are D-sharp and E-flat considered to be two different...
by wizofaus on Sunday August 28, 2022 @05:13PM
(#32632113)
I chose the word "smother" deliberately, though maybe "blur" would be better. There's quite a bit of debate as to how the pitch of a note with vibrato is perceived. It definitely isn't right in the middle which might be the naive hypothesis.
And you're right, we don't play "based entirely on just intervals." What we do is constantly adjust our intonation depending on whether we need it to be "just" with respect to something else (like other notes in a chord), or whether we are free to use a more "melodic" intonation. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QaYOwIIvgHg for a good demonstration -- note that he talks in formal terms like "play x in the Pythagorean system," but I think you can largely see this as a rationalization of what players do naturally).
Finally, the presence of vibrato doesn't really obviate intonation concerns, sadly. There's a lot of theoretical debate about how the pitch of a vibrated note is perceived (is it the highest pitch in the range that determines whether the note sounds in tune? etc.), but in practice you can easily verify that adding vibrato to an out-of-tune scale will not make it sound any more in tune, nor will adding it to a shift mask a slightly-missed shift (if only!).