News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:The Penguin Random House trial by chrisseaton on Saturday August 27, 2022 @07:46PM (#32624382)
> to publish anything new, you need social media presence, writing on something that appeals to a mass market, which passes sensitivity readers, and gets past gatekeepers who are essentially redditors

You really don't. I've been working with a new author about to publish recently and he's just a regular bloke and his work doesn't seem to hit any of your criteria. Are you sure your impression is grounded in reality?

Re:The Penguin Random House trial by motohagiography on Saturday August 27, 2022 @08:40PM (#32624652)
Just some experience with publishing business as a writer several years ago, and knowing the people socially.

Maybe I'm missing who is challenging the established narratives and taking the risk as an iconoclast. Who is publishing right now whose ideas are challenging? Taibbi? He still compromises himself for access. Hirsi Ali? She still hedges, even though she's probably got more balls than anyone these days. Houellebecq is only tolerated because he's unthreatening to anyone. The Slate Star Codex guy writes like he still needs brunch invites. Substack is great, but it's not the discourse. The examples I'm thinking of stood on their own so well that they kept their subjects honest. Orwell, Mailer, HST, Mencken, Hitchens, Vidal, Hersh. Writers who traded on integrity to their craft so that their subjects were measured against it. Very best of luck to your writer, I hope you can serve his work honestly.

Re:The Penguin Random House trial by chrisseaton on Saturday August 27, 2022 @08:46PM (#32624677)
> Maybe I'm missing who is challenging the established narratives and taking the risk as an iconoclast.

I think you're possibly moving the goalposts from simply 'publish' to 'be internationally recognised and lauded for major critical thinking'.

Re:The Penguin Random House trial by mellosouls on Sunday August 28, 2022 @04:22AM (#32626698)
I don't think that's fair; it was clear from the post you challenged that the criticism was about lack of new ideas and commentary especially that countering safe narratives.

The poster responded with plenty of examples which you've dismissed with the unfortunate "goalposts" remark.

Re:The Penguin Random House trial by chrisseaton on Sunday August 28, 2022 @04:35AM (#32626763)
> it was clear from the post you challenged that the criticism was about lack of new ideas and commentary especially that countering safe narratives

Not sure what thread you were reading - the one I responded to said it was impossible in general to get anything new published. You can see hundreds (thousands) of new published works every year. They moved the goalposts by then saying that they only consider publishing to mean critical work.

Re:The Penguin Random House trial by 5560675260 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @05:15AM (#32626914)
Reread first two sentences of the post that started this thread. They clearly state that books are being published and what goes into getting those books published. This wasn't about what OP "considers publishing to mean", it's what OP considers to be worth being read.
Re:The Penguin Random House trial by yywwbbn on Sunday August 28, 2022 @08:32AM (#32627895)
If any newly published book is by definition not worthy enough to be read, according to OP. It’s really possible to prove he’s wrong. Is it?
[dead]
Re:The Penguin Random House trial by dang on Monday August 29, 2022 @03:44PM (#32642625)
Re:The Penguin Random House trial by jkeat on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:35AM (#32626046)
Being unconventional means value for sure https://www.reddit.com/r/TrueAnon/comments/wzjewu/taibbi_rem...
Re:The Penguin Random House trial by motohagiography on Saturday August 27, 2022 @08:53PM (#32624708)
If you aren't recognized for major critical thinking, I'd say you're an entertainer who should be writing sitcoms, not books.
Re:The Penguin Random House trial by chrisseaton on Saturday August 27, 2022 @08:56PM (#32624722)
You’ve gone from lamenting the difficulty of publishing to advocating that we shouldn’t publish most books.

You’re on a wild roller coaster of opinions there!

Re:The Penguin Random House trial by manuelmoreale on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:55AM (#32626129)
What an odd take. So if something is not internationally acclaimed and you’re recognized as a major critical thinker then you shouldn’t write books?

How do you get to that point without taking the risk in the first place?

Writers have to start somewhere and they have to publish something in order to have the chance to become recognized.

And even if they fail at that they can still have an impact on someone else’s life in one way or another and to me that’s already valuable enough.

Re:The Penguin Random House trial by user_named on Sunday August 28, 2022 @02:02AM (#32626160)
If you want the book to be profitable then yes. Small exception for how tos or if you're backed by a large brand so the author becomes irrelevant.
Re:The Penguin Random House trial by psi75 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @09:14PM (#32624808)
There are tiers of what it means to "get published".

If you want your book to get a decent editor and maybe get a print run in the three or four digits, you don't have to deal with all the faddish bukkake (social media presence, trendy subject matter, performative wokery designed to signal virtue without actually changing anything or challenging capitalism, dodging cancel mobs). You can just write, and you may be able to find an audience organically if you put time and money into it. You probably won't, however, make enough money to write full time.

If your focus is on getting set up to make enough money to write full time, then you do have to worry about all that garbage, because there just aren't many good book deals to go around.

Re:The Penguin Random House trial by stubish on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:36AM (#32625806)
Yes, 'getting published' refers to people with a $0-$10000 advance from a small independent press through to the million dollar deals discussed in the article. And nobody can guarantee that you will sell enough to get past your advance, but being a social media personality is a huge boost. Fantastic reviews and most awards and prizes do not actually indicate good sales. To make a living, you need to get on the best seller lists. What we now call going viral.
Re:The Penguin Random House trial by gumby on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:27AM (#32625770)
I think your assertion is a bit hyperbolic, but for the last 30 years or so I’ve mostly given up reading fiction by living authors. There are tons of good books, and if a dead author is good enough to still be in print it’s sonable signal that the book might be worth reading.
Re:The Penguin Random House trial by stubish on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:42AM (#32625831)
This certainly depends on the genre. There are a number of major genres that do not age well. Older readers can be happy reading the fiction that reflects the world they grew up in, but to new readers reactions can rank between 'quaint' and 'appalling'.
Re:The Penguin Random House trial by psi75 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @09:08PM (#32624781)
The present reality is that all publishers have been reduced to vanity press, and they don't realize it yet.

In theory, publishers provide a real service, because self-publishing well is expensive (four, five digits easily). In theory, they should be offering access to people who couldn't afford what it costs to self-publish to the expected standard. In practice? The only people who can get in are people who have the connections and financial resources not to need the help. Whoops.

What we're learning about publishing (which we already knew, those of us who've been studying it) is that no one is good at selling books. Most self-publishers aren't, most traditional publishers aren't, and most PR firms are only good at taking and spending your money. We just don't have a good understanding of why individuals buy books (it changes) and there's a lot of evidence, sadly, that book sales are only loosely correlated to the quality of the writing (in the long term, quality matters more, but a book that dies in the short term won't have a long term).

Re:The Penguin Random House trial by JeremyReimer on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:26PM (#32625201)
Quote: "self-publishing well is expensive (four, five digits easily)"

This is basically correct, although it depends on the definition of "well". You can get a halfway decent cover for $100-$500, and you can get a halfway decent copy editor for about $500-$1000. Tools like Scrivener can handle all the ebook and paper edition formatting for you, with built-in templates, so that's another $100 or so for the tooling, but you can reuse this for future books. Publishing to Amazon and other places (like Smashwords) is free, and this includes print-on-demand paperback copies as well.

What it does take is a lot of time for learning how to use all the tools and to navigate the many options available for covers, editing, etc.

As far as marketing expenses go, there are no good ways to spend money to sell books. I think you're correct that nobody knows how to do it. If you don't win the lottery and get featured on a celebrity's book club, how is anyone supposed to ever know that you even released a book?

Re:The Penguin Random House trial by ghaff on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:08PM (#32625411)
I'd say you can get the mechanics taken care of for the low four-digit figures. Publicity and marketing? The sky is the limit if you don't already have a following. I get a ton of requests for podcasts and interviews related to books. Which I 95% ignore. You probably want to do marketing yourself which is a major undertaking and probably won't work.