News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Progress against SOPA by Matt_Cutts on Monday November 21, 2011 @02:03PM (#3262319)
My point is that in 20-25 years, the fight to protect the internet will be easier--not completely hands off, but easier--because more people will understand technology. But in the mean time, we absolutely do have to take action to protect the net ourselves.
Re:Progress against SOPA by roc on Monday November 21, 2011 @02:24PM (#3262416)
> "more people will understand technology"

When has this ever happened? As technologies approach the refinement of appliances, it looks to me like the general understanding plummets. Under-the-hood complexity all but kills the tinker class and buries the professional class in detail that further muddies their attempts to talk to the average person.

Consider hardware issues. In absolute numbers there may be more hardware tinkers than 25 years ago. But as a ratio of technologists, they're shrinking. And as relevant to popular opinion and voting, the general public has no more (though not clearly less) understanding or appreciation for hardware freedom issues. Trusted computing, the issue of yesterday's hardware freedom battles, is simply the reality of mobile computing.

Re:Progress against SOPA by brlewis on Monday November 21, 2011 @03:23PM (#3262654)
If the RIAA tried today to lobby for a law that all Interstate highways include checkpoints to search cars for infringing copies of movies or books, they wouldn't find a sponsor. This is not because the public has a deep understanding of auto mechanics. It's because the public understands that traveling at highway speeds is desirable and checkpoints to serve a special interest are not. It's hard to sway people today by arguing that highways make it too easy to transport infringing copies.
Re:Progress against SOPA by roc on Monday November 21, 2011 @03:42PM (#3262723)
> "It's because the public understands that traveling at highway speeds is desirable and checkpoints to serve a special interest are not."

15 years ago I'd be agreeing with you. But the drunk driving checkpoints, the Patriot Act checkpoints, border security and the TSA nonsense makes it a little difficult for me to trust the public's ability to recognize serving a special interest for what it is, when it's bearing a promise that honest citizens have nothing to fear.

If the RIAA were lobbying for checkpoints, if they insisted it would only affect "rogue" streets and that the critics of their proposal were just those who profited from the flow of illegal goods, I honestly would not feel comfortable enough to bet money on whether people pushed back.

Re:Progress against SOPA by brc on Monday November 21, 2011 @06:32PM (#3263317)
Absolutely. The madness of TSA checkpoints which everyone glibly accepts while privately thinking it is a giant waste of time proves your point well.

Everyone always thinks these things will make things better for them, while assuming it will cost them nothing.

And as always, some hawk will be saying 'won't someone think of the children'.

Re:Progress against SOPA by wtallis on Monday November 21, 2011 @04:36PM (#3262918)
General understanding of appliances may not be very detailed, but on the other hand, we've got the first-sale doctrine, Magnuson-Moss, the Clayton Act, and others that make buying and selling tangible consumer goods more or less fair, reasonable, and predictable even to those who don't know much about those laws or the technology at issue.

When you buy a car, you don't need to worry about whether getting an oil change from Jiffy Lube will get you in trouble the next time you take the car to the dealer for repairs. Those issues are settled, but not for cyberspace. When you buy software or hardware that includes software, no assumptions are safe, and you have to know quite a bit about the law and technology to figure out what your rights might be.

Re:Progress against SOPA by glhaynes on Monday November 21, 2011 @03:09PM (#3262598)
Consider hardware issues. In absolute numbers there may be more hardware tinkers than 25 years ago. But as a ratio of technologists, they're shrinking.

I'm not sure this is true. I'm not saying it isn't, but it's at least not obvious. (Unless you're counting, say, anybody who today owns a smartphone as a technologist.)

Re:Progress against SOPA by roc on Monday November 21, 2011 @03:28PM (#3262668)
I was just relying on personal experience with programmers and IT people.

When I started programming 20 years ago, pretty much anyone who worked at any level with computers could build a PC. These days, half the programmers I know can barely maintain their machines, let alone build one from parts. [1]

If you told them they should oppose some piece of legislation because it would bar them from loading whatever OS they wanted on the hardware they purchased, they would (and do) shrug. They fully consider their choice to be synonymous with the hardware they bought in the first place. They don't think it at all odd that Android phones ship with locked bootloaders.

[1] I don't mean to disparage them; some of them are fantastic programmers. That said, I do know far too many of them who are running home wifi with whatever configuration the Comcast/UVerse guy set up.

Re:Progress against SOPA by corford on Monday November 21, 2011 @03:57PM (#3262779)
Assuming your experience is not isolated, I find that very scary.
Re:Progress against SOPA by einhverfr on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @01:01AM (#3264316)
Well, I have always found the oldest documentation of a network or computing principle to be the clearest because it usually has not been so obscured by later attempts to make sense of it....

How many folks do I have to explain why the Open Systems Interconnect network model doesn't match what happens with TCP/IP over the wire?

I do think that we've create a class of specialists who protect their specialties in part through obfuscation.

Re:Progress against SOPA by firefoxman1 on Monday November 21, 2011 @02:40PM (#3262485)
Absolutely right. The rate of new people understanding technology is pretty rapid at first, but then flatlines. I think actually less people understand how a car works than 2 generations ago, but when the Model T first made it to mass market the number of people who understood how the automobile works grew each year. But that trend couldn't have continued or everyone would be an expert mechanic by now, and that obviously isn't the case even though more people than ever own a car.
Re:Progress against SOPA by jbjohns on Monday November 21, 2011 @05:18PM (#3263056)
I totally disagree. In fact, I would say the only thing that's saved us thus far is that those in power don't understand technology. If they would have been able to see what the internet was capable of, they would never have allowed it to be so open. When the day comes that the power hungry know technology as well as we do the real fight will begin.
Re:Progress against SOPA by joe_the_user on Monday November 21, 2011 @05:37PM (#3263145)
Yes...

The thing about "understanding" and "misunderstanding" is that since any censorship approach would break the web, any effort at censorship benefits from "playing dumb", not describing the complexity of the situation and instead reducing things to simple claims like "we need to stop the bad stuff on the net..."

The one thing that might help us in twenty years is that public might be sophisticated enough to not be as easily fooled by such claims. On the other hand, seventy years of an automobile-based society has not made everyone into auto mechanics...

Re:Progress against SOPA by mdc on Monday November 21, 2011 @02:39PM (#3262478)
If technology stood still, that might work. In 20-25 years, all politicians will understand the web and email, but the same kind of politician that today is ignorant of the web will then be ignorant of technologies x, y, and z that are new and cutting edge.
Re:Progress against SOPA by olaf on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @03:46AM (#3264707)
I think, this is a dangerous illusion, nothing will get easier, there will always be enemies of freedom, fighting hard for their goals (control, exploit, suppress others)! I suppose, this fight is a never ending story.
Re:Progress against SOPA by brc on Monday November 21, 2011 @06:40PM (#3263337)
I think this overlooks the underlying trend, which is the growth in lobbying funds. Until the linear growth upwards of lobbying funding changes, I don't think it will make any difference what the average makeup of people will be.

If anything, future voters who are being born today will grow up with internet services intwined in their lives, and may be even less understanding of the free and open nature of the internet. They may be broadly brand-loyal to an internet property that doesn't yet exist. Imagine a Facebook size company that is for SOPA-like laws because it is funded by vested interests.

No, I'm not optimistic about these things getting better over time. I actually think it needs a second-amendment type intervention to cut off these types of approaches in the future. 'The right to keep and bear websites' - that type of thing.

On the other hand, one thing the internet is good at is routing around attempts to damage it. I can see alternative systems popping up quickly to counteract any regulatory damage to DNS.

Re:Progress against SOPA by charlieok on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @11:52AM (#3266235)
It isn't that congresspeople (or voters) don't understand, or like, technology. The funding chart in your post is all the explanation that is necessary.
Re:Progress against SOPA by clarkevans on Monday November 21, 2011 @02:13PM (#3262357)
Matt, Why do you think so? This isn't obvious to me.
Re:Progress against SOPA by yellowbkpk on Monday November 21, 2011 @02:39PM (#3262476)
If I said "I need to change my spark plugs." to you today, would you understand what I mean?

If I said it to your ancestors in 1911, would they understand what I mean?

Over time, the median understanding across the majority of the world of any particular technology goes up as more people get exposed to it and its intricacies. As I understand it, Matt is saying that a larger majority of the world will understand the details behind the internet and its vulnerabilities, thus making it easier to communicate why the issues are important.

Re:Progress against SOPA by nitrogen on Monday November 21, 2011 @02:38PM (#3262471)
I can't speak for Matt, but the argument I would use is that the current politicians are largely from the generations that preceded the technological revolution. Given another generation (~25 years), more of the Internet generation will be in control.

It speaks to a larger problem with the American political system, in my opinion, which is that the decisions that affect the next two or three generations are being made by people who came of age two or three generations ago, giving the status quo an undesirable inertia.

Re:Progress against SOPA by CamperBob on Monday November 21, 2011 @03:39PM (#3262708)
Yeah, just like the generation that dropped acid at Woodstock is now running the DEA.