The "law" is doubling density every two years.
So strictly speaking it is done because it has taken longer than two years. But if you choose the looser interpretation and simple read it as, transistor density increases with time, then it's not dead.
Probably the bigger deal is cost per transistor is actually going up with the new nodes.
https://www.fabricatedknowledge.com/p/the-rising-tide-of-sem...
and
https://www.eetimes.com/moores-law-dead-by-2022-expert-says/
Approximately none of the growth thus far involves stacking transistors on top of each other, unless you count 3D NAND flash memory. FinFETs and upcoming GAAFETs are less planar than traditional transistor designs, but still don't get you two or more separate transistors stacked on top of each other. Actual 3D stacking of transistors on a single wafer is still nothing more than a hot topic for R&D, and stacking multiple dies full of transistors is pretty much only done with memory so far.
FinFETs effectively lets us pack transistors closer. This is because much of the structure of a transistor is in a 3D fin that sticks out of the wafer. By making the fin taller, you can pack the transistors even closer. But it can be argued that by volume, transistors are basically the same size. GAAFETs lets us go even further with this idea.
So if you still think you're right, kindly post your citations. Here are mine:
"Moore's law is a term used to refer to the observation made by Gordon Moore in 1965 that the number of transistors in a dense integrated circuit (IC) doubles about every two years. "[0]
"Moore's law is the observation that the number of transistors in a dense integrated circuit (IC) doubles about every two years"[1]
"Moore's Law refers to Gordon Moore's perception that the number of transistors on a microchip doubles every two years..."[2]
[0] https://www.synopsys.com/glossary/what-is-moores-law.html
You could keep transistor density fixed, but still double the number of transistors in a chip ... by using bigger chips. And that is naturally more expensive because they are more likely to be defective and require more sophisticated packaging. 3D stacking of smaller chips is another approach, since we usually only talk about the 2D area of a chip. This requires more advanced packaging, but substantially increases the likelihood of building a functional device.
The loss of Dennard scaling makes it more interesting to investigate ASICs because CPUs won't necessarily eat your lunch in two years. And circuit cleverness is one contributor to Moore's Law that Moore talked about in his 1975 address.
So Moore's Law is in some ways dead (number of instantaneously useful transistors is NOT doubling every two years) and other ways alive (useful work is improving rapidly so long as you can decompose your workload into leaning on the accelerators like YouTube did), depending on how you measure it.
https://hasler.ece.gatech.edu/Published_papers/Technology_ov...
https://static1.makeuseofimages.com/wordpress/wp-content/upl...
And actually, this is the case because new processes efficiency gains are lower than in the past. It's something that's been said before (and I read about it on HN, it was just years back and I don't have the reference at hand now ;), but when process improvements were fast making a custom ASIC didn't really make sense: by the time the ASIC was designed and debugged and deployed, a few years were spent and a recent CPU was nearly as good as the custom ASIC for no risk and less effort.
Doing an ASIC is hard and takes time, and having a slower pace of improvement for new nodes efficiency makes it easier to justify the long deployment. There is now time to use such an ASIC with a noticeable gain, and absorb the cost and gain. Still, this is for a Youtube or Google (TPU) or Amazon (Graviton) or Apple. You need this scale still to absorb the development cost.
> definitely
Would you care to post some definite citations? Or would you like to dispute my citations listed above?
When the least cost offering improves, when things get better and cheaper, everyone follows. The lowering cost per function increases the addressable market, which can then sustain increasing investments. This is the virtuous cycle that moved the industry forward for a long time.
When the economic part stops, when you can get more transistors but only at a higher cost, then the virtuous cycle stops. Technical progress do continue, but you will have less players at each new step: only those who can absorb the increasing costs will keep on playing at the leading edge. And production costs will still rise. If the market gets smaller due to increasing prices, and the production cost keep on raising, you will see a slow down as it will take more time to amortize investments.
The big players are worried about this: slow down has in itself the specter of followers catching up (eventually...), leading to commoditization. We're definitely not there yet, but it's not a good perspective. Definitely bad for their stock. So the cost has been taken out. At first the NRE part was dropped of the equation, to consider only the cost per transistor. For this one can also be creative: considering the fabs amortization, or after? Makes a big difference (see the issue car makers have in getting new investments at "old" nodes: message from the big guys is move to smaller nodes, even if it's not always convenient). But in the end it's been simpler to just drop the least cost aspect completely. The industry PR had good results on this ;)
For small to medium fabless players, Moore's law has been over for a while. For the biggest players it's also over now: there's still technical progress on transistors per device, but at an increasing cost.
It's not always a smooth process: if you're an Apple, you can gain on the cost by going vertical (good-bye Intel margin). But it's a bold move not for all, and it's a one off gain.
Moore's law is over. Tech progress is not. For HN readers who can afford the increasing cost of the devices and are reading regularly from the big silicon vendors that "Moore's law is still going strong yoo-hoo", when it's been neutered to transistors count only, it may be easy to miss.
[1] https://newsroom.intel.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/11/2018/...