News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by cs702 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:04AM (#32619145)
It appears many experts disagree with your assessment of this multiple-prize-winning book:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guns%2C_Germs%2C_and_Steel

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by funklute on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:10AM (#32619218)
Like the parent, my impression from discussing this very book with many people who work in the academic social sciences, is that Guns, Germs and Steel is largely discredited today. This might actually be an example of a situation where the wikipedia article is simply out of date, incomplete, and/or biased.

I would instead recommend reading the heavily moderated r/askhistorians sub-reddit for a description of that is more in line with mainstream academic thinking. For example https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/6meq1k/a_det...

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by treis on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:31AM (#32619411)
It seems like GG&S was the way people sounded "smart" for a while and now the way is to say "well actually....". Mostly it seems because people don't like the conclusions.

Like the post as an example. It says the European conquest was "hardly decisive". Which is just so ridiculous that it should disqualify them as a source.

But moving on they try to say that native alliances were the most potent weapon. Which is again just so ridiculous. Small pox wiped out double digit percentages of the indigenous population and devastated their society.

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by karpierz on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:38AM (#32619496)
> Small pox wiped out double digit percentages of the indigenous population and devastated their society.

This is the kind of cherry picking I was talking about. It'd be like saying "disease killed a large portion of Jews during WWII". Technically, it's true. A lot of Jews died from disease (in concentration camps). But it avoids asking the question of "were there any aggravating factors (like sudden displacement from homes, famine, violence, etc.) that caused them to become more susceptible"?

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by inglor_cz on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:04AM (#32619803)
Like being a virgin population in which the new pathogens could spread like wildfire, being totally unknown to their immune systems?

We have just seen the same with covid, where the entire humanity was a virgin population. And covid mortality was basically nothing compared to smallpox and a host of other Old World diseases.

Notably, the only disease to spread the other way round, syphilis, was very severe too. It took several generations for syphilis to mutate to a more chronic form.

And, notably, even though famine and violence weren't exactly rare during the later colonial conquest of Africa, it usually wasn't the natives who died of diseases, but the whites, who just couldn't tolerate local diseases such as malaria, to which the indigenous population was somewhat resistant.

There is a reason why the only significant white population in Africa is located in territories with more European-like climate, where the disease situation wasn't as dire as, say, in Congo.

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by ALittleLight on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:01AM (#32619773)
I read Guns, Germs, and Steel a long time ago, but I'm pretty sure it focuses quite heavily on disease wiping 90+% of the native population and how decisive that was. I remember this because I was shocked when reading it that the percentage might be that high. One clue that the book is concerned with disease is the second word in the title.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by WalterBright on Saturday August 27, 2022 @12:15PM (#32620544)
It might not be that high. Estimates of pre-Columbian population vary by a factor of 10.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by nyolfen on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:45AM (#32619574)
it is estimated that 90% of new world natives died of smallpox and viral herpes immediately following contact with europeans -- that is, after initial contact with a small number of europeans on the western fringes, disease swept across the entire hemisphere and destroyed civilizations. it is literally the single most important factor in the history of western colonization. the europeans that colonized the americas arrived in a postapocalyptic wasteland.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by karpierz on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:03AM (#32619794)
> it is estimated that 90% of new world natives died of smallpox and viral herpes immediately following contact with europeans

Can you give an academic citation for this?

I can't find anything that would support these numbers, they're high even for older work that's since been debunked (and especially not "immediately"). I suspect that there's a methodological error, but I can't say for certain until I actually see how you've come to these numbers.

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by treis on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:01AM (#32619771)
It's not cherry picking. We have millenia's worth of evidence that people without immunity to Smallpox die at a very high rate if infected. The indigenous population of the Americas had no immunity when exposed to small pox. So they died at a very high rate.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by WalterBright on Saturday August 27, 2022 @12:59PM (#32620911)
Historians have no idea what the pre-Columbian population was, so estimates of death rates have huge error bars.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by treis on Saturday August 27, 2022 @01:19PM (#32621097)
We know the mortality and virulence of smallpox and the other diseases that the indigenous population had never seen. From that you can estimate a death rate and it's clear that the toll would have been devestating. How devestating might be subject of some debate but no doubt that it was very bad.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by WalterBright on Saturday August 27, 2022 @01:52PM (#32621408)
No, we don't, because we have no remotely accurate numbers on the pre-Columbian population.

The reason we have reasonably accurate measures of the mortality of the Black Death in medieval Europe is some areas kept written records of who died and who didn't. Yet the mortality rate of that is still in dispute.

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by treis on Saturday August 27, 2022 @02:24PM (#32621699)
I'm not sure what part you're disagreeing with. Do you dispute that we know smallpox's mortality rate? Or that we have a reasonable idea of what it (and other diseases) would do to a population with no natural immunity?
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by WalterBright on Saturday August 27, 2022 @03:40PM (#32622394)
I dispute that we have a reasonable idea of how many native americans it killed, because we have no idea how many pre-Columbians there were.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by treis on Saturday August 27, 2022 @04:28PM (#32622860)
AFAICT nobody is talking about "how many" except for you. My argument was percentage based and for that the total population is irrelevant.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by WalterBright on Saturday August 27, 2022 @06:20PM (#32623828)
How many matters very much, as that determines the percentage.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by amanaplanacanal on Saturday August 27, 2022 @07:09PM (#32624142)
But you can go the other way though. If you have the ending number, and some other way to estimate a percentage, that would give you the starting number.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by WalterBright on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:31PM (#32625511)
It's a pretty big stretch to extrapolate from a few samples to two continents.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by treis on Saturday August 27, 2022 @07:59PM (#32624445)
No, the virulence and mortality of the disease determines the percentage.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by WalterBright on Sunday August 28, 2022 @10:25PM (#32634191)
Um, virulence and mortality is expressed as a percentage.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by treis on Monday August 29, 2022 @08:57AM (#32637597)
It is a percentage. Smallpox kills roughly 30% of infected people. Doesn't really matter if if 100k, 1M, 10M or 100M are infected. Roughly 30% of them will die.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by WalterBright on Monday August 29, 2022 @02:06PM (#32641402)
Like I said, it's a great stretch to extrapolate a few samples to two continents of people. There's a lot of genetic diversity in the Americas, and different lifestyles. Thinly populated areas are not going to spread the disease like thickly populated ones, etc.

Besides, the claimed number was 90% now it's 30%?

Also, look at the way Covid behaves. Despite modern statistics, what a mess of unpredictability and controversy it has. Medieval statistics, which are often little more than guesses, are going to be far less reliable.

> It is a percentage

I know what percentages are. I was simply amused by your claim that the percentage could be determined from the percentage.

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by treis on Monday August 29, 2022 @03:47PM (#32642665)
>Like I said, it's a great stretch to extrapolate a few samples to two continents of people. There's a lot of genetic diversity in the Americas, and different lifestyles. Thinly populated areas are not going to spread the disease like thickly populated ones, etc.

A few samples? Smallpox has been around for millenia and has caused epidemics with significant mortality where ever it was found. The idea that something about the genetic diversity or lifestyles of the indigenous populations of the Americas is frankly ridiculous. Especially given the numerous and consistent first hand reports that Smallpox and other diseases ravaged the native population.

>I know what percentages are.

Do you? Because you keep talking about the total population or the number of killed when I speak about death rates and percentages.

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by WalterBright on Monday August 29, 2022 @09:09PM (#32645547)
> Smallpox has been around for millenia and has caused epidemics with significant mortality

No argument there. But "significant mortality" is not a percentage. Accurate records were not made or kept in a way that would provide a percentage. In the case of the American population, there are no records. Just WAGs (Wild-Ass Guesses).

> The idea that something about the genetic diversity or lifestyles of the indigenous populations of the Americas is frankly ridiculous.

Really? It's true for every other population. Do you not know that city dwellers are far more susceptible to epidemics than rural or nomadic tribes? Did you know that Covid infection rates vary from state to state, country to country, in ways that defy easy explanation?

> Especially given the numerous and consistent first hand reports that Smallpox and other diseases ravaged the native population.

What first hand reports in North America? In South America, do you really believe the Spanish Conquistadors kept accurate epidemiological records?

> Do you?

Yes. To compute a percentage you need a numerator and a denominator. The denominator in this case would be the population of two continents, which nobody has any idea of.

If Covid has taught us anything, it is that childishly simplistic extrapolations of statistics across orders of magnitude are fraught with error, gross error, and catastrophic error.

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by googlryas on Saturday August 27, 2022 @02:22PM (#32621679)
I think this is exactly it. When it first came out it was trendy to quote the book about why certain things were the way they were. Then, people got tired of it and now it's trendy to say "well actually...", To the point on the history subreddit, if you even mention the title, a moderator bot posts a form response saying "well actually..." Without even knowing the content of the post.

I hope we can soon reach a stage where we can accept the book for its good parts, understand it's shortcomings, and have more realistic viewpoints of academic/mass-appeal works and rely less on trends to tell us how we should feel.

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by cs702 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:24AM (#32619353)
I started reading the comment you link to in that subreddit, but I had to stop after it claimed that

> The European conquest [of the Americas] was hardly decisive. Furthermore, the difference between hemispheres wasn’t all that great.

I had to stop because that's the kind of statement on which lots of people -- many of them smarter and more knowledgeable than me -- strongly disagree, often with ideological or religious fervor. I have no interest in or patience for that kind of debate, so I will skip out from this thread.

That said, if you and others think the Wikipedia page on this best-selling, award-winning book is out of date, you should try to update it.

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by funklute on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:32AM (#32619427)
I'm struggling to decide whether to take this critique seriously or not.

You yourself told the parent "many experts disagree with your assessment", when the parent clearly indicated that they simply were following what appears to be the academic consensus on this book, today.

The link I provided has a clear link to further work you can go explore, and make up your own mind. But I sort of suspect that in the three cases of 1) the parent comment, 2) the wikipedia article, and 3) now this statement about the American conquest, you have already decided what you want to believe.

I'm not personally an expert in this field. So I am not going to go and update the wikipedia article. What I am going to do, is to listen to the people who are experts in the field. I actually loved Diamond's book when it first came out, but over many years, I have not found a single academic historian who had good things to say about it. And it's not for lack of trying. As much as the book has received many awards, it is today simply a fact that it has a very fraught reputation in academic circles.

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by meany on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:27AM (#32620046)
I think one of the challenge with relying on academics of History or anthropology is that, unlike physics, consensus doesn’t necessarily progress towards a more accurate interpretation. I think the post above is suggesting that the linked academic has a agenda that is guiding their analysis. For instance they write that more advanced technology really is just more European. That rather than being more technologically “advanced” Europeans developed technology for a different context. Perhaps it’s inaccurate, but conclusions like these seem to some to be motivated by the need to retell events to achieve/support social justice movements today.

I love reading history, but I am concerned that all historical narratives are illusions - stories we string together from a minuscule subset of the data we’ve captured in writing or other records. This is particularly problematic if people, including academics, see the outcome of their historical interpretations as influencing modern power struggles.

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by funklute on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:49AM (#32620290)
> I think one of the challenge with relying on academics of History or anthropology is that, unlike physics, consensus doesn’t necessarily progress towards a more accurate interpretation.

I think this statement needs some very strong evidence to be even considered in passing. This statement is essentially saying "the entire field is bad at their job".

For individual academics and sources, yes, I agree that one should be vigilant. But the academic consensus is a different matter altogether, and the base assumption simply has to be that the field as a whole moves forward. Otherwise it becomes very difficult - maybe even impossible - to have any sort of evidence-based discussion.

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by meany on Sunday August 28, 2022 @04:27AM (#32626725)
My undergraduate degree was in history from a top 10 university. Only say this to illustrate that I respect and love history. I thought I was going to become a historian. That said, the field has practical limits not faced by the hard sciences. You can’t test or prove your theories in History and many other humanities/social science. The best you can do is provide evidence that an event occurred. It’s the inherent limits of the field. How do you conclusively prove the cause of the French Revolution or the reasons the Japanese surrendered in WWII?

So how can you validate that any reinterpretation is forward progress and not just a change?

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by suoduandao2 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:11PM (#32755106)
>This statement is essentially saying "the entire field is bad at their job".

Well, are there academic historians who dispute that fact?

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by cwalv on Saturday August 27, 2022 @04:11PM (#32622710)
> the base assumption simply has to be that the field as a whole moves forward. Otherwise it becomes very difficult - maybe even impossible - to have any sort of evidence-based discussion.

It seems like this "assumption" needs to be qualified with time scales for disambiguating trends from "facts" .. otherwise this is equivalent to saying that academic consensus can never be wrong

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by funklute on Saturday August 27, 2022 @04:21PM (#32622799)
> otherwise this is equivalent to saying that academic consensus can never be wrong

No it is not. I said that the assumption must be that the consensus becomes less wrong over time, not that it is never wrong. Those are two very different statements.

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by cwalv on Saturday August 27, 2022 @05:22PM (#32623341)
Over how much time? Does "consensus" never make a wrong turn?
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by funklute on Sunday August 28, 2022 @02:31AM (#32626275)
Well, academic consensus usually takes a long time to build. And obviously it can take wrong turns (and there are plenty of examples of that historically, often due to work based on incomplete or wrong data - though arguably even if the academic consensus has been wrong on an absolute basis, it has often been "correct" in light of the available evidence).

But nevertheless, it should be obvious today that (probabilistically) the best understanding of the world - for laymen - is achieved by trusting the academic consensus. Anything else quickly veers into anti-intellectual, conspirationist mumbo-jumbo.

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by abecedarius on Saturday August 27, 2022 @03:55PM (#32622553)
> the base assumption simply has to be that the field as a whole moves forward.

Nature doesn't care what anyone thinks our base assumptions have to be. Parapsychology had a decent run academically for a century, and still isn't quite dead.

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by juve1996 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:51AM (#32619663)
It's hard to argue that something that took until the 1920s to complete is decisive. The American Indian wars didn't end until 1924. That's hardly decisive.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by meany on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:32AM (#32620096)
I think you would need to start be defining “decisive” for this context. Not sure the debate makes sense otherwise. Why does it matter if it was decisive or not?
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by juve1996 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @03:39PM (#32622380)
Because the post I was replying to disagreed with the decisive nature of the conflict.

> Why does it matter if it was decisive or not?

It goes against the entire theory of the book - if it's argument was true, why did it take centuries to ultimately conquer the americas?

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by meany on Sunday August 28, 2022 @03:17PM (#32631173)
But Until decisiveness is defined it’s not really a debate. “Decisive” is not a concrete term, it’s subjective.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by cwalv on Saturday August 27, 2022 @04:23PM (#32622817)
Just because a conflict/war hasn't been officially resolved or declared over by both sides doesn't mean the final outcome isn't clear.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by allturtles on Saturday August 27, 2022 @02:15PM (#32621607)
GG&S rubs academics the wrong way for a couple of reasons:

1) It accepts as a fact that the Europeans had superior technology to the peoples they encountered elsewhere, which is now perceived by many academics to be a form of racism/eurocentrism. (see the discussion in the linked threads about how the Europeans weren't really that advanced)

2) Materialist explanations are out of favor. Everything is supposed to be about culture and ideology and social construction, and everything is supposed to be "contingent" (i.e. not pre-determined by material factors like geography or superior technology - see the discussion in the linked thread about "determinism," which is a bad word).

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by funklute on Saturday August 27, 2022 @03:47PM (#32622472)
"supposed to be" is perhaps not quite the wording I would use.

My understanding is that these kinds of materialist explanations are out of favour because they have some genuine shortcomings: 1) they are largely untestable/unfalsifiable, so they veer into pseudo-science, 2) they have a tendency to cherry pick data, and 3) related to the second point, they tend to ignore the importance of the precise historical context (e.g. whether a certain king is particularly ambitious or not, could in certain cases shape the history of a region for decades or centuries to come - this is difficult to accommodate in more systemic theories).

Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by allturtles on Saturday August 27, 2022 @04:52PM (#32623072)
(1) applies to pretty much any kind of historical argument, and historians who emphasize contingency are by no means immune to (2) (I'd say this is a weakness of humanity generally!). (3) is a reasonable argument, but the converse can also apply. I think we should be open to the idea that some historical developments hinge on individual human action, but others don't.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by photochemsyn on Saturday August 27, 2022 @12:44PM (#32620785)
One rather blatant error is the treatment of Easter Island - which the author portrays as a self-inflicted catastrophe. In reality, there are probably three general phases of Eastern Island inhabitation: (one) initial discovery and subsequent deforestation, (two) a long period of relatively stable population, (three) raids by European pirates who murdered or transported most of the population to work as slaves in Chilean guano mines. The third issue is entirely neglected in that book. Not a very good sign, really.
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence by allturtles on Saturday August 27, 2022 @04:45PM (#32623012)
That's a different Jared Diamond book, Collapse.