Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence
by juve1996 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:51AM
(#32619663)
It's hard to argue that something that took until the 1920s to complete is decisive. The American Indian wars didn't end until 1924. That's hardly decisive.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I think you would need to start be defining “decisive” for this context. Not sure the debate makes sense otherwise. Why does it matter if it was decisive or not?
Re:The Best Books on the Great Divergence
by juve1996 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @03:39PM
(#32622380)
Because the post I was replying to disagreed with the decisive nature of the conflict.
> Why does it matter if it was decisive or not?
It goes against the entire theory of the book - if it's argument was true, why did it take centuries to ultimately conquer the americas?
But Until decisiveness is defined it’s not really a debate. “Decisive” is not a concrete term, it’s subjective.