News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by ars on Monday November 21, 2011 @05:06AM (#3260599)
Yes, this really is an amazing rover! But I wonder why they chose such a complicated landing sequence. So many places where things can go wrong.

I hope this rover actually does land successfully - with its RTG power source it could last for decades!

Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by ANH on Monday November 21, 2011 @08:05AM (#3260947)
In a recent press conference (think it was this one: http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/18431005) one of the MSL engineering managers was asked this question. He said it's because of both the weight of MSL and the landing accuracy requirements. They considered a boatload of configurations before deciding on this one.
Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by Sharlin on Monday November 21, 2011 @06:53AM (#3260802)
The landing sequence isn't actually that much more complicated than that of the MERs. It just needs to be much more precise because you must make a soft touchdown instead of dropping the rover from a height. See http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tma2pt0k6UQ
Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by yaix on Monday November 21, 2011 @11:53AM (#3261735)
I had the same thought. This "sky crane" thing doesn't look like a good idea. I hope it'll all go well.

The rover is awesome though. They should build 20 of them and send them to all planets and some of the moons as well.

Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by jawher on Monday November 21, 2011 @03:26PM (#3262663)
While I share your enthusiasm, I'd like to point out some problems with "Sending rovers to all the planets": 4 of them are gaseous giants, literally no solid ground to land on. Venus is a no go too with its crushing atmospheric pressure, sulfuric acid clouds and 400+ c° temperatures.
Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by yaix on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @04:46AM (#3264837)
Where there's a problem, there's at least one solution. I have no idea how to building a bot that can run science experiments in 400+ °C sulfuric acid clouds, but I bet its possible.
Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by nknight on Monday November 21, 2011 @05:31AM (#3260646)
Because Mars is a pain in the ass to land heavy gear on.

There's too much gravity, too little atmosphere, and we haven't perfected AI. You can't rely entirely on parachutes, the air bags they used on the last few landings won't hold up to something so heavy, and landing with direct use of retrorockets would pretty much require a human pilot to be sure of -- and even if we had a human pilot, the enormous amount of dust it would kick up is problematic.

Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by robin_reala on Monday November 21, 2011 @07:40AM (#3260891)
The retrorockets on Nasa’s Phoenix Mars mission exposed ice upon landing, which was decidely unproblematic :)
Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by khafra on Monday November 21, 2011 @08:48AM (#3261063)
The obvious solution is to terraform Mars so it has a substantial atmosphere.
Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by Symmetry on Monday November 21, 2011 @09:10AM (#3261138)
Or build a beanstalk on Mars. Much easier than on Earth!
Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by rbanffy on Monday November 21, 2011 @06:14AM (#3260732)
They could have practiced on the moon...
Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by Sharlin on Monday November 21, 2011 @06:47AM (#3260790)
No, they couldn't. They are two completely different beasts, and present totally different engineering challenges. Or, to be more precise, Mars presents difficult engineering challenges, Moon doesn't.
Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by nknight on Monday November 21, 2011 @06:46AM (#3260788)
Even if they had the budget for a 1-ton lunar probe, landing on the Moon bears almost no resemblance to landing on Mars. The Moon's gravity is 0.16g to 0.38g on Mars, and the Moon has no atmosphere at all. This makes direct rocket landings far easier and completely changes the landing profile.
Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by rbanffy on Monday November 21, 2011 @08:10AM (#3260958)
Obviously the Moon is a very different environment, but it's also much closer to home (which makes it a lot easier to find out what went wrong). It's a little cheaper in terms of fuel, and the trip is much shorter. We can't say we have any recent experience with easy rocket moon landings either.

There are so many new ideas being employed for the first time I don't feel sure it will work. I assume they did several crane drop tests indoors, but I don't know if they did outdoor tests with a chopper attached to the crane module to see how stable the crane platform needs to be and with the crane module using its own rockets (tethered to a tower, maybe) to control its position while a reduced mass rover simulator touches down. Like I said, tons of new ideas, hardware and software that have never been used (and that won't be used together until they get to Mars) that will all have to work perfectly the first time.

Again, I'm all in to sending this rover to Mars, but shouldn't we be sending rovers to the Moon for some time now? These people are much smarter than either you or me, but it doesn't change the fact engineering progresses incrementally and it seems we are jumping up the stairs and skipping steps. I only hope we don't break a leg here.

I am an engineer. We don't like complicated things.

Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by jerrya on Monday November 21, 2011 @09:52AM (#3261265)
The earth is an even closer place to land on.
Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by rbanffy on Monday November 21, 2011 @11:15AM (#3261585)
Of course. I wouldn't suggest landing on the Moon something that never landed on Earth. I wouldn't land on the Moon (or Mars) anything that didn't land reliably over Earth a hundred times, until we understand thoroughly what can go wrong.

I would be perfectly confident with a device you could trow it out of a plane, that would parachute until a reasonable altitude, engage rockets to hover and lower a rover to the surface a dozen times without incident.

It'll be at least 30 years until we can inspect the crash site to learn what went wrong.

Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by pavel_lishin on Monday November 21, 2011 @02:09PM (#3262347)
And how do you translate what you learned from a parachute landing on Earth to the moon?

It's like assuming that you can easily swim five miles because you can easily jog five miles.

Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by rbanffy on Monday November 21, 2011 @03:28PM (#3262672)
For the Moon, we would use rockets, or a crane attached to a vehicle with rockets. For Mars (and Earth, or Titan) we add parachutes to the mix because there is an atmosphere. From hovering-stage until rover deployment, everything is the same except for wind, which would be absent on the Moon.

The idea is that you have to lower a car-sized rover from a hovering rocket-powered platform that has to remain relatively still regarding the ground. On Mars, the platform would use parachutes to slow it down. On the Moon it may not be needed at all, but you would use rockets, if you still needed the hovering platform approach (say, landing a very heavy habitation module).

Throwing the probe out of a plane, letting it descend on parachutes for some time and then making it hover using rockets until it gently deposits a rover on the surface seems a good way to make sure we know how to do all the required steps for a successful deployment on Mars. Lots of important variables are very different - Mars' atmosphere is very thin, so the crane would have to use far more power to slow itself down (or a much larger parachute), but the gravity is lower, so the rover would descend more slowly and it would require less power to hover. There could be some wind, but the forces applied to the vehicle would be different than what would be on Earth (Martian atmosphere is thin, but the winds are faster). The whole operation appears to me somewhat similar.

Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by ars on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @04:17AM (#3264776)
No one is arguing about the need for testing. They are saying that testing on the moon adds nothing.
Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by rbanffy on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @07:30AM (#3265231)
It would at least prevent us forgetting how it's done ;-)

I think it'd be worth, and relatively easy, to operate a rover on the Moon. Remember we don't always know what we should have learned until after we try. This Mars rover is a huge step. Huge steps is someting engineers should learn to avoid.

Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by adaml_623 on Monday November 21, 2011 @05:16AM (#3260620)
Anybody else notice that the page title is "10 Amazing Things NASA's .... etc"
Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by jerrya on Monday November 21, 2011 @10:01AM (#3261299)
Does anyone notice that the image with the rover and its chem cam is straight out of H. G. Wells?

Compare and contrast:

http://i.space.com/images/i/13468/i02/nasa-curiosity-rover-m...

with

http://i.imgur.com/kYofe.jpg

This leads me to believe that our Martian rover needs some sort of acoustic imaging devices.

Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by adaml_623 on Monday November 21, 2011 @10:44AM (#3261471)
Maybe they are expecting 'trouble'. Certainly they seem to be downplaying the fact that they are deploying an autonomous robot with a laser that can vapourise stone.
Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by ortusdux on Monday November 21, 2011 @09:17AM (#3261153)
#12: MMRTG Nuclear Power Source. Deviating from its predecessors, Cursorily will be powered by 10 pounds of plutonium dioxide. Earlier, solar power rovers, had to hibernate during long periods of darkness, and at times these hibernations proved mission ending (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spirit_rover#Stationary_researc...).
Re:11 Amazing Things NASA's Huge Mars Rover Can Do by Loic on Monday November 21, 2011 @10:51AM (#3261493)
Is it me or on all the pages of space.com you cannot find a single link to the NASA website? As soon as you try to get more about the project, you are sent to previous stuff on space.com but no links to the original source, that is, the NASA website. Very annoying...