Re:Irata.online: A PLATO service for retro computing enthusi...
by AlbertCory on Friday August 26, 2022 @01:12AM
(#32603589)
internet-history@ is an old-fashioned mailing list, so you can probably read the archives if you want. As I recall, there was someone there who really resisted the consensus that PLATO didn't contribute much.
Re:Irata.online: A PLATO service for retro computing enthusi...
by felixgallo on Friday August 26, 2022 @10:22AM
(#32607916)
with respect, it contributed immensely. USENET traced a lineage to PLATO notesfiles. That was the http equivalent until http came along.
Re:Irata.online: A PLATO service for retro computing enthusi...
by TMWNN on Friday August 26, 2022 @03:22PM
(#32611646)
>USENET traced a lineage to PLATO notesfiles.
I am aware of no such connection. Usenet is a product of Duke and UNC, not UIUC. More to the point, its specifications are very similar to that of the near-contemporaneous SMTP. AlbertCory mentions RFCs; both Usenet and SMTP are fully described in various RFCs. PLATO is not.
PLATO did inspire Lotus Notes; Ray Ozzie attended UIUC.
Re:Irata.online: A PLATO service for retro computing enthusi...
by AlbertCory on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:28PM
(#32625216)
Yeah, like you I'm just challenging the claim that they contributed to the Internet. OP claimed some credit for USENET, and I said "OK, then what RFCs did they contribute to?"
I never really thought about PLATO being described in an RFC. But "the internet" is: TCP, SMTP, DNS, SNMP, Telnet, FTP, BGP, etc. etc.
"Intellectual influence" ? Sure, ok, but usually that would show up as citations in other publications.
Re:Irata.online: A PLATO service for retro computing enthusi...
by AlbertCory on Friday August 26, 2022 @11:42AM
(#32608933)
How many entries in the RFC index have PLATO developers as authors? It sounds like there should be a few, at least.
Good grief. The Friendly Orange Glow certainly doesn't claim that, so to hear that people would claim otherwise is mystifying. It's that relative lack of contribution to what would become the Internet that caused PLATO's relative obscurity today in computing history compared to Stanford, Berkeley, and MIT's contributions (and, probably, the chip-on-the-shoulder attitude that I imagine drove the discussion you cite).