I, personally, am not happy about the way that this or the subscription update have been handled because, to me, it makes me question how they would communicate something far more serious. If they're delisting forum posts because of a decision to not update their app in the Mac App Store yet, how can I be sure that they won't delist forum posts when they have a data breach? How can I be sure that they're not obfuscating other things that are more important than forum posts to try and sweep bigger issues under the rug? It's like the old adage goes - "If you're willing to lie about something that doesn't matter, what are you willing to do about something that does?"
These moves are forcing me to, at the very least, start looking at a new password manager. 1Password is still the best, in my opinion, in terms of features and usability but that won't always be the case and transparency and respect for your users are far more important to me than niche features. If I can't trust your company over something small, there's no way I'm going to continue trusting them with some of the most important info in my life. I currently use both LastPass (not a fan) and 1Password. I'll be re-evaluating KeePass and Bitwarden because of this.
I'm waiting for someone to actually build a better 1Password, learning from the mistakes, rather then migrating to something else right now.
As a happy paying (both corporate and personal) Bitwarden user, the only gripe I had was the lack of multiple-profiles on the same device (which was recently added and works great). We came from KeePass though, so we're likely a more "spartan" user of password managers than some.
EDIT: was unaware of it of 1password integration with Fastmail. This is actually possible.
* their problem doesn't seem to be "we don't have developer bandwidth to add this nice feature," but rather (from my perspective) they're so lacking in discipline and execution. In other words, the PR to fix any such bugs would be so massive as it might as well be a fork
* and that's just on the bugfix side -- anyone who thinks manually created folders are superior to tags ... well, there's no PR to fix that
* them being open core(?) makes contributing feel like free labor for a commercial company. I have less heartburn contributing fixes to GitLab because they do have a for-real open source offering (the CE edition) that one can run without drama
They've managed to implement it in their clients in March this year [1], and I've been moving some of my shared credentials over to a self-hosted Vaultwarden server.
What other features do you think are missing from Bitwarden?
[1] https://bitwarden.com/blog/account-switching-phased-rollout-...
The subscription/cloud pushing added to that.
In the best case, a low level employee made bad choices. More likely than that, a higher level leader in one of those orgs is enforcing a policy decision of theirs. I seriously doubt a C level is involved in any way with this decision.
I just don't see how this decision has any bearing on my trust in what they're building.
1. Senior staff, including Dave (the owner of AgileBits), participate in the forums and are participating in the exact discussions in question while completely ignoring the questions people are asking. It would be hard for them to claim ignorance of what's going on.
2. This also happened during the subscription phase and it happened during the sunsetting phase of standalone vaults so this isn't a first-time incident or atypical of how they respond to stuff from a PR standpoint. It seems like, as a company, their position is to ignore the things that they don't have canned responses for and only answer the things they do have canned responses for and it's obvious that this is what happens to everyone participating.
Again... product-wise, 1Password is superior in almost every way to others. As a company, though, it's hard to continue to support them when it would be far more effective to just be honest and say "We've decided not to do x at this time because of y" or "We're going this route because of y and we understand that that's not for everyone but it's much harder for us to do x when only z% of people use the feature."
It's because 1Password was targeted at tech enthusiasts at the beginning and has migrated to a mass-market product over time. The desires of the tech enthusiast group differ (on average) from the goals of a mass-market consumer product. Every time they switch away from something enthusiasts value (perpetual licenses for a specific version, optimized native apps) the early adopters get upset. The average user doesn't care all that much.
> If you’re making six figures writing software and think $3/month for a cornerstone of your security suite is offensive, you need to grow the fuck up, frankly.
For me, it's not about the cost. It's about managing one more subscription. My credit card bill is full of little monthly subscriptions, and at this point I'm tired of adding new subscriptions at every turn. Subscriptions aren't a big deal for the first 5-10 services, but once you're juggling 20+ recurring charges for things that don't really need to be recurring charges, it's tiresome.
I would gladly pay a premium to have a one-and-done license (for a specific version, just like they did in the past) that didn't add yet another monthly payment for me to manage and another system I need to update when I get a new credit card.
I'm very happy to pay $50+ every year or two for a password manager with great UX and cross device support. It is not ok if any functionality is contingent on a subscription though. I really like the Jetbrains model, where if your subscription lapses your software just keeps on working — no updates though.
They have a fairly generous policy is case you'd account is frozen: https://support.1password.com/frozen-account/
This is why I only use password managers that save as KeePass databases, like Strongbox or KeePassXC.
The world is going in this direction, however: everything is turning into Cloud+SaaS to charge for use instead of bill once and forget. The next big thing will very likely be a service that makes extremely easy to aggregate and manage the 465 or maybe 3044 micropayments per year one will need to use his compu... er... stupid terminal a few years from now.
And here come the downvotes for stating a fact, yay!
It's a real stretch to call any of this "critiquing software".
This seems pretty ordinary for HN xD
They also used to be pretty bad about cross-platform support; no idea if that's still true.
Speaking for myself: because 1Password works everywhere I need it and it means I don't have to think about it. OSS is great at a lot of things. KeePass's user experience is indicative of a place where OSS frequently is not. If I have to think about my password manager, it isn't doing the job I need it to do; when I trialed KeePass, it made me think about it, therefore it doesn't work. For me, of course. Your mileage may vary.
I was a 1Password user before they moved to a subscription model, and I was mildly affronted that I would be stuck on an older version if I wanted to keep out-of-band syncing. More than mildly, honestly. Then I tried a bunch of alternatives and they were all, for my purposes, significantly inferior, either in the "I do not trust them to hold onto data" sense or in the features sense or both. So I tried 1Password again, realized that yup, it's still tops, and that $3 a month is way, way too little money to be agitated over. I have realized way more value from 1Password than I have paid either for the original purchase--which I used for quite a long time--or from my subscription.
I use it because it makes my life better. Surely you can understand that.
> And for large teams, LastPass has owned the market for a while now
I don't think that I know a single security professional in my circles who would recommend LastPass unless the alternative is "don't use a password manager".
1Password used to let me buy the software and sync how I see fit. That is, it was decent and reasonable software. I was happy to use and recommend it.
That’s no longer the case and I feel like a fool for recommending it, having left those people stuck in a predatory model that I consider at best a bad deal and at worst unethical.
So yeah, I’m going to criticise.
And no, I don’t feel sorry for the staff of a company operating on a business model that should probably be illegal.
There are plenty of people and organizations that I prefer the Teams, family and subscription model for.
Its just a bad experience. And yes, their audience has also used Keepass, Bitwarden and others, and see 1Password as the one capable of not fucking it up but simple did any way?
I get it that they don't see an obvious way to do subscriptions that people can't circumvent. It just also brings a lot of skepticism for what other economic pressures are going to guide their decisions, and when.
Then there’s the SaaS model where my data is stored on US servers. If at any point the someone in the Internet decides to break BGP, sever an optical fibre, or any number of other shenanigans, I am left with what is effectively read-only access to my vaults. I have no option for self hosting to protect against hostile action between international parties that involves me or Agile Bits as collateral damage. We run our own optical fibre networks to ensure continuity of communications in the face of hostile/negligent behaviour, but with 1Password we do not have the option to host our own security.
Then there’s data sovereignty. Agile Bits is a US company, and the US government has shown its willingness to spy and sabotage in the past. Whether it’s intercepting sensitive data in transit (echelon/airbus) or building weaknesses into encryption standards or installing malware on equipment in-transit or sabotaging chip fabs to produce less random RNG, the US has done that.
There is no trust here.
Agile Bits even put out a “survey” to gauge interest in self-hosting as a means of shutting down discourse on the topic. If there was any intention of supporting self-hosting they would just release a trial product which would be a great demonstration that their business continuity plan would work because self hosting would be the same as Agile Bits hosting. Just run the containers on your own docker instead of Agile Bits cloud.
The most “entitled” comment here is yours, talking down to everyone else as if you are the only adult in the room.
To include Windows users in this fun, previously one could invoke a hotkey and 1P would offer to auto-type into almost any Windows dialog on the screen. Poof, gone
I bet I could come up with 15 other things if I thought about it. Engineering is filled with tradeoffs, and so they made the "we don't enjoy writing cross platform code" versus "we really made our user's lives better by having native code integration capabilities"
This feature still exists, and it is even easier to use. You no longer have to drag any windows around. The QR code just has to be on screen and you press the button. :) If you're having trouble with it please reach out as we'd like to troubleshoot.
> nor its ability to detect native application's bundle-id and fill in passwords based on the application currently in focus
1Password 7 didn't do this? It didn't fill in any 3rd party apps except browsers that had our browser extension installed. 1Password 8 actually not only detects these apps but also fills in them. https://support.1password.com/mac-universal-autofill/ If that is not working for you, please reach out.
> To include Windows users in this fun, previously one could invoke a hotkey and 1P would offer to auto-type into almost any Windows dialog on the screen. Poof, gone
Agreed. I miss the one too. I'm hopeful we're going to be able to bring it back soon.
-Ben, 1Password
And the Windows app was in need of a serious update, the experience was not great.
We can't pretend that engineering for different platforms has no overhead. If they can now move faster shipping new features to all platforms on day one, users will win. There is going to be a transition period where things aren't at parity yet and that's understandable.
So you admit they are removing features at the same price point, but are somehow still confused as to why some folks are upset?
But, electron: no. I use a Mac primarily, and I want Mac apps that take the platform seriously, and integrate well with it. Regressing from that means you lose my business.
Btw, "unlock on secure desktop" basically opens a desktop where no other app/windows can spy or modify the window. This is the envirnoment used when you have to do the UAC approvals in Windows.
Since when is it desirable to pay for software on a subscription model until the end of your life? Sounds like someone else needs to grow the fuck up here.
It's not desirable as a consumer, but I'd rather just get everything for free and just the way I want it as well. It's a compromise. OP wasn't saying that they prefer it this way, just that if you're literally mad and offended by what they're charging, then you're both blowing things out of proportion and not reacting proportionallyy.
Other than that, feels good, I like it. I pay for it for home and work.
I still don't get the Electron hate? Seems a bit insane honestly.
The complaints about it being a subscription are weak - software doesn’t exist in a closed system. Keeping up with all the platforms and the OS updates etc. takes perpetual maintenance even if they shipped zero new features.
And the features they do ship (family vaults, built in OTP) are really useful.
It’s a refreshing escape from the “free” ad-driven hellscape many of the HN commenters complaining are probably employed by.
You don’t need to cast aspersions against other people to make your argument. Why would you do that? Grow up.
What features and utility were lost? It has way more features and utility now that it had previously. The happy path is the 99% use case, but it also stores non web passwords, docs, and notes etc. just fine.
I am a professional, and don’t mind paying their very reasonable subscription so they can continue to actively maintain the security and functionality of the software that literally protects my entire digital identity. I’m baffled by how many people in our industry are upset by their business model. If you’re making six figures writing software and think $3/month for a cornerstone of your security suite is offensive, you need to grow the fuck up, frankly.
Likewise, I don’t care how they moderate their forums.
The comments in these threads always feel so self entitled. Use another piece of software if those things are important to you. Plenty of us understand and appreciate the value these guys are creating for us. For me, nothing compares. I’ve tried Keepass, Bitwarden, Apple’s built-in thing, Enpass; they are all either amateurish or missing key functionality that 1Password has that I use every day. All the same, I’m happy they exist. Some day I may need them. I hope more pop up.
Anyways, if you’re a dev or employee at 1P I’m writing this for you. Sorry about the jerks. Plenty of us out here love what you are doing.