News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by avhception on Thursday August 25, 2022 @06:14PM (#32600609)
As late as 2011, we had a custom payroll system on MS-DOS. I was always blown away by the speed it's users achieved. They really flew through the menus and knew all hotkeys and commands of the TUI by heart. When they got "upgraded" to a modern GUI based system, it really slowed them down. Of course learning a new thing always takes time, but that's not the whole story. Especially with ever-changing websites that usually don't care about hotkeys, the mental load of visually scanning for elements and clicking them with the mouse can be really slow. And it always fascinates me how it was perfectly normal and expected for mere users to use a TUI while today I've heard grunts even from junior devs and self-proclaimed power-users when I told them to use the CLI for this or that.

How times have changed.

IBM i is fascinating, and in a world of ever-changing tech-stacks I sometimes yearn for a stable environment where you don't have to fight with 10,000 node.js dependencies every other month just to keep that payroll website going. I've never came in contact with IBM i or POWER tech in a professional capacity, but have purchased an RS/6000 and, more recently, a TalosII system to play around with ppc64le :)

Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by bombcar on Thursday August 25, 2022 @06:25PM (#32600723)
The biggest key with the "green screen" terminals is they would NEVER EVER lose a keypress and they would buffer them, too.

So even if the computer was actually quite slow, if you knew what you were doing you could "type ahead" a few screens into the system, and then wander off and do something else.

That just doesn't work on GUIs (some rarely are well designed so that it can) and certainly has zero chance of working on webpages.

Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by salmo on Thursday August 25, 2022 @09:16PM (#32602193)
One of my first gigs was replacing a VAX/terminal based software package with a Windows NT/PC thick client one.

17 year old me scoffed at the dumb terminals. When we converted users and they hated it, I learned SO MUCH. They could fly through the TUI. They’d have a form filled out before the screen could paint.

The thick client didn’t even have keyboard shortcuts for most things. But the company had bought a ton of PCs and was moving everyone to the first iteration of Exchange. So I got the VAX up on the LAN and set them up with telnet.

The users liked that. White text on a blue background became the most popular color combo. The internet was becoming a more popular thing, so they could begin the proud tradition of screwing off at work staring at a browser.

Eventually the original package was retired and keyboard navigation was added to the thick client. But you couldn’t go “ahead” of it. And flipping between the keyboard and mouse is just slow for “real” work. They adjusted but I learned a lot about how a computer can best augment someone’s abilities. It’s not always the cool or most intuitive way.

That exercise forced me to learn VMS, then I touched Solaris and fell in love. I couldn’t afford a pizza box as a college kid, so installed RedHat 4.1 from a CD in a book.

Now I get mad when I have to edit text without vi.

Same as it ever was.

Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by protomyth on Thursday August 25, 2022 @06:56PM (#32601052)
I honestly wish someone had come up with some text markup language and "browser" so enterprise developers could deploy text UI apps. The web is just awful for the back office people. Frankly, I wonder how much money is being spent on the web when a TUI would have been more productive.
Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by p_l on Thursday August 25, 2022 @08:32PM (#32601871)
That's literally how IBM block terminals operated, and it was AFAIK most visible with CICS which was designed around similar model to Web 1.0 apps - blocks of code ("transactions") in CICS would send a (possibly multipage) form to terminal, then when the terminal send back the response (usually just the filled in fields of the form) another transaction would get fired and perform processing on it, and so on and so on.

Of course the screens had rudimentary markup to support this including client-side validation of sorts.

Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by naikrovek on Friday August 26, 2022 @01:19AM (#32603626)
I personally don't care about how it's implemented, markup or otherwise, I'd just be happy to see TUIs return in numbers for modern terminal emulators. SSH apps are slowly becoming a thing, thankfully, but not quickly enough for my liking.
Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by pxc on Friday August 26, 2022 @02:02AM (#32603828)
Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by lifeisstillgood on Thursday August 25, 2022 @07:46PM (#32601521)
I like the idea of a Text UI markup language. It's envisage some kind of nested table describing the layout? More declarative?
Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by worthless-trash on Friday August 26, 2022 @03:42AM (#32604325)
I -think- that it might be possible to do so something like ncurses forms.
Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by _glass on Friday August 26, 2022 @04:05AM (#32604502)
Honestly I work with SAP and for power users we still implement text UIs for certain special tasks. SAP's language ABAP is actually optimized for this and it works amazingly well. You can implement in 20 minutes a working UI that does a lot.
Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by jon_adler on Friday August 26, 2022 @07:44AM (#32606071)
I’m an ex-Peoplesoft dev and the productivity was pretty mind blowing in that environment. More recently I was involved with a SAP project, and the development estimates for what seemed like trivial things were days and weeks. Your experience and my experience differ. Maybe the developers were just excessively padding?
Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by _glass on Monday August 29, 2022 @04:57AM (#32636076)
Yeah, SAP folk are always very conservative. A lot of stuff is actually quite fast, but you need to know an incredible tech stack nowadays going literally back to the 80s to new technology. But if you're in the known, it's fast.
Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by Gibbon1 on Friday August 26, 2022 @04:26AM (#32604656)
Someone could write a curses package in web assembly.
Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by IIsi50MHz on Friday August 26, 2022 @12:22AM (#32603330)
> So even if the computer was actually quite slow, if you knew what you were doing you could "type > ahead" a few screens into the system, and then wander off and do something else. > > That just doesn't work on GUIs (some rarely are well designed so that it can)

I used to do this in Macintosh System 7, since Macintosh System Software used a similar keyboard buffer. Of course, the UI heavily encouraged the mouse, and often required it. But I miss being able to tell apps "Do these 17 things, because I know what you're going to ask me and I know you're gonna be busy, and I can't be bothered to script it right now.".

Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by bombcar on Friday August 26, 2022 @10:21AM (#32607904)
The older OSs seemed to work correctly even if you switched windows.

I.e., select a window, type ahead a few screens/commands, switch to another window and continue work - the keyboard buffer would stick with the previous window.

That sometimes works now with Terminal, etc, but sometimes it doesn't. I think it's a question if the OS is buffering, or the application, and/or if the application tracks which window was in focus when it buffered.

Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by LeftHandPath on Thursday August 25, 2022 @06:20PM (#32600679)
I've noticed a lot of the more experienced people in our office stop trusting things as soon as they see drop shadows and branded color schemes. And they are all very quick with the old terminals.
Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by at_compile_time on Thursday August 25, 2022 @09:18PM (#32602209)
My favorite are the gratuitous animations that the program is too bloated to render smoothly.
Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by ordiel on Thursday August 25, 2022 @06:28PM (#32600752)
Developers of newer versions of a system even if it is a migration from TUI to a Web GUI should really strive to maintain the shortcuts and hotkeys, an upgrade its suposed to be "that", extra functionality not a replacement of the existing one. Sadly there is this assumption that given it has a GUI there is no need of shortcuts or hotkeys, forcing users to use the mouse.

Gmail does provide some hotkeys and I think even those "few" ones really help, also Atlassian applications yet most web pages I have interacted with have none

Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by fiddlerwoaroof on Thursday August 25, 2022 @08:52PM (#32602011)
Part of the problem here is that desktop development frameworks included keyboard shortcuts essentially for free: Mac associates them with menu items, emacs/vim's key -> command -> action design give an obvious place to implement shortcuts; Delphi and similar programs had similar places to automatically slot in keyboard shortcuts. Web frameworks focus on visuals and mouse interactivity and keyboard control is almost an afterthought (aside from some minimal attention to tab-order because of accessibility).
Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by mook on Thursday August 25, 2022 @11:03PM (#32602911)
Another part of the problem is that the contents of the browser is mostly untrusted, and the browser itself already has a giant pile of shortcut keys that would conflict.
Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by bombcar on Friday August 26, 2022 @10:27AM (#32607969)
Excel had Lotus-123 shortcut compatibility for decades after Lotus-123 was no longer a going concern.

It's still somewhat in there with / triggering the menu on Windows Excel.

Re:What have we lost? – Demo of exotic OSes (2021) [video] by holri on Friday August 26, 2022 @04:34AM (#32604697)
As a pianist I am not surprised. The keystrokes a TUI requires is like a piece of piano music. You can learn the required keystrokes pretty fast and play it very fast, reliable and unconscious.

Image a piano played by touchscreen or mouse.