Re:Patent Trolls Inbound: Our First Lawsuit
by Yoofie on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @10:22PM
(#32588654)
Wow. The fact that this patent was even granted tells me we have morons in the patent offices or that there is serious corruption going on.
Re:Patent Trolls Inbound: Our First Lawsuit
by justapassenger on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @11:47PM
(#32589254)
Patent offices aren’t full of specialist in every single area, and they don’t pretend to be. You need to meet few fairly simple requirements and patent is granted.
If patent is invalid the way to prove that is to challenge that in court.
That system, that makes filling patents easy, is a whole reason why patent trolls exists. But it’s not a fault of patent offices, that they’re mandated to work that way.
Re:Patent Trolls Inbound: Our First Lawsuit
by KerrAvon on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @11:33PM
(#32589159)
We’ve had ex-patent examiners on Hacker News indicate that they’re radically understaffed.
Re:Patent Trolls Inbound: Our First Lawsuit
by barelycompetent on Thursday August 25, 2022 @02:46PM
(#32598197)
The above link is a published application rather than a granted patent. US20170170984A1 by itself carries no legal rights whatsoever.
In this case it was granted with largely similar claims (as US10027505B2). However, claims typically get significantly revised by the time they are granted, and less than half of applications are granted at all.
Re:Patent Trolls Inbound: Our First Lawsuit
by oldgradstudent on Thursday August 25, 2022 @09:43AM
(#32593610)
MITM, but in a vehicle. And there's also a relay somewhere.
What I would like to see is a deposition of the patent examiner who approved this ridiculous patent.
If you cut through the lawyer-speak, claim #1 is basically about MITM-ing the vehicle's internal message bus. Hardly novel, even in 2007.