News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by philwelch on Sunday November 20, 2011 @12:29AM (#3257362)
> Google executive chairman Eric Schmidt, at speech in Taiwan on November 9, promoted Chrome OS in high-profile for the PC market, but PC players are rather pessimistic about the idea and believe if Google wants to cut into the PC market, the company will need to provide more resources and support.

It's possible that Chromebooks are just a shitty idea. That's a pretty boring interpretation and I have nothing interesting to say about it.

But it's also possible that none of the PC manufacturers have the vision to really execute this strategy. Why would they? They aren't technology companies, they just buy parts, assemble them, and distribute them. They live in a world that Microsoft and Intel created in the 90's. No way are they going to try anything different.

What Google needs to do if they're going to pursue this strategy is to contract a manufacturer like Asus and basically design and sell the thing themselves.

Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by potatolicious on Sunday November 20, 2011 @03:48AM (#3257660)
> "It's possible that Chromebooks are just a shitty idea."

I'm inclined to take that explanation. This is a classic case of "how can we make the customer do what we want" instead of "how do we make our customer's life better".

Yeah, Google's profit is all in ads, so it wants you to spend as much time on the web and as little time on native apps as possible. Guess what Google: your customers don't care about your bottom line.

They want the best device, for the lowest price.

So here are our two contenders:

- A "broken laptop" that can't do everything the user wants it to do. It can only go on the web. It uses a strange OS that nobody is used to but yet does not seem to offer any benefits.

- A full-featured laptop/netbook that gets the same battery life (if not better), runs a common OS everyone is already familiar with, runs all of their apps (and the ones their friends are running too), and does the web thing just as well.

And checking out Chromebooks and Dell/HP netbooks... They're even the same price.

So here's Google, offering substantially less value for the customer's dollar, and people are standing around shocked that it's not working.

The core question here is: is this product better than what it seeks to replace. And the answer, IMO, is an emphatic no. It's missing many features people have come to expect from such devices, and for that it's not even cheaper.

Google needs to turn this upside down and work from the customers. At the end of the day, as long as you don't have a monopoly, the users do what they want, you cannot push a product that has a shitty value proposition and expect people to latch on. That's insanity.

Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by ippisl on Sunday November 20, 2011 @05:06AM (#3257769)
Maybe google didn't have a choice. Since MS is talking about an app store, it just might be that the windows platform could become a closed platform(for the sake of security).

If google wants to do something about this , it basically have two options: the android option and the chromeOS option. They're trying them both(because of the risks involved). At some point if chromeOS fails , android will become a desktop OS. it's a natural step from using android on tablets, and google probably has people working on this too.

Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by DenisM on Sunday November 20, 2011 @12:58AM (#3257417)
I would like to add that PC manufacturers are not able to innovate precisely because Microsoft and Intel took all the money in the platform, commoditizing their complements. That's why PCs often suck in quality - they have to compete of price and they have to cut every corner, which sometimes they get away with, and sometimes not. And that's why they install crapware on their PCs - every penny counts in race to the bottom.
Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by lallysingh on Sunday November 20, 2011 @03:33AM (#3257635)
See, the funny thing is that I'm just not that price sensitive, and that's the case with a lot of customers. People can feel quality, and appreciate when they see it. But the PC manufacturers are running like coked-up lemmings in their race to the bottom. That behavior's really helped Apple succeed. Many people spend over half their average workday on a machine, and even medium-sized changes in the machine is going to have a large, substantive difference.

But, then again, I think some of this psychology directly stems from Windows. MS has traditionally had this feature-checkmark mentality that pushes for more checkmarks & features over substantive quality; and you can see exactly the same thing with most Windows PCs. Now, the consumer's left a complete-shit algebra to reason about which computer is best for them. Ugh, ok, I'm cutting the rant off here.

Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by philwelch on Sunday November 20, 2011 @01:26AM (#3257461)
Exactly what I meant by "in a world that Microsoft and Intel created". Their value added doesn't extend much further than manufacturing, distribution, and coordinating the suppliers. Sometimes not even the manufacturing.
Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by forensic on Sunday November 20, 2011 @01:06AM (#3257424)
Apple pretty easily dispels this notion.

The PC makers commoditized themselves by provided no added value.

Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by kissickas on Sunday November 20, 2011 @01:13AM (#3257438)
Hardware is not added value to a PC? I'm asking an honest question. Obviously I hate the "value" HP adds to PCs with terrible pre-installed software, but surely the manufacturing still counts as adding value to software, which would be useless without the hardware.
Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by philwelch on Sunday November 20, 2011 @01:35AM (#3257475)
The actual hardware is supplied by the CPU manufacturer, the motherboard manufacturer, the video card manufacturer, etc. The "added value" is basically distribution and sales--they buy the parts, have them shipped to a Chinese manufacturer, and then have the assembled computer shipped and distributed to retailers and customers. Some companies do the manufacturing themselves (generally the Chinese manufacturer, who's edged into the sales and distribution side a la Lenovo) and some companies design their own cases (poorly, a la Dell). It's really a boring industry.
Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by crag on Sunday November 20, 2011 @01:53AM (#3257500)
"What Google needs to do if they're going to pursue this strategy is to contract a manufacturer like Asus and basically design and sell the thing themselves."

Google doesn't have a marketing team on the ground. Selling to enterprise requires face time. Lots of it. Second, Google doesn't offer good support. The best you can get is email support. Which isn't gonna cut it.

Until Google makes serious investments in these area ChromeOS isn't breaking into the IT shops.

Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by adgar on Sunday November 20, 2011 @02:58AM (#3257579)
Disclaimer: I am a Google employee.

> Google doesn't have a marketing team on the ground. Selling to enterprise requires face time. Lots of it.

Perhaps I'm biased as a Google employee in NYC, but there are hundreds of sales and marketing employees in my building and across the street in Chelsea market. Google is very serious about expanding into the enterprise, and yes, that includes sales and marketing efforts. Why do you think that is not the case?

> Second, Google doesn't offer good support. The best you can get is email support.

The first result for the query [google phone support] on Google is http://www.google.com/support/a/bin/static.py?page=contactin..., which gives both US and international numbers for 24/7 phone support for Google Apps Business and Education editions. AdWords also has phone support. I do not know details about Chromebooks, but it is simply untrue that google only has email support.

Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by netcan on Sunday November 20, 2011 @03:49AM (#3257661)
Disclaimer: I am a Google customer. Not an app customer but I've been responsible for several million in ad spend over the years.

If the support you get you when you spend 10,000k+ per week is anything to go by, Google has the worst support I have ever encountered. By far.