News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by MontyCarloHall on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @06:05PM (#32572202)
Serious question: what is so compelling about the FreeBSD desktop experience compared to Linux that makes it worth jumping through all these hoops?
Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by johnklos on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:21PM (#32574265)
The BSDs are much cleaner than Linux distros.

Also, because they don't change gratuitously, once you learn their quirks, you can move on to other things without needing to worry about re-learning tons about the next update. Linux is a constantly moving target with lots of churn that users of computers really don't want or need.

Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by horsawlarway on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:49PM (#32574421)
So I certainly understand some of the frustration around churn, and I get that on hardware selected to run BSD, this probably doesn't matter nearly as much

But...

This article describes (at least in my opinion) an unusable and unstable machine.

Basic HDMI out and Ethernet aren't "optional" on machines I run. Frankly - I'd rather lose wifi/bluetooth than HDMI and Ethernet (not that bluetooth is working here either...).

So I guess my point is that

>that users of computers really don't want or need

seems very much like a personal opinion. I not only want churn if it's bringing online more hardware support - I find the lack of support here completely unsuited to my needs.

If this is what you mean by "clean"... then It feels a bit like keeping a boardgame in the shrink wrap - rather than getting it out, bending a few cards, and having a good time. At least to me (fully admit this is also just an opinion).

Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by johnklos on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @03:32PM (#32584600)
Perhaps you're talking about a different kind of "churn". I'm not talking about adding drivers and things to make hardware work better - I'm talking about changing commonly used commands and changing how things work from one version of a distro to the next.

For instance, does "ifconfig" need to be replaced by "ip" in order to support new ethernet chips? Do you need all sorts of new invocations to systemd because a new generation of Intel graphics is supported? No.

It may be a personal opinion that people don't want or need churn, but what I mean is that when people want to use a system to get things done, learning new invocations for old commands is usually a distraction to getting those things done.

Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by horsawlarway on Friday August 26, 2022 @01:41PM (#32610550)
> Perhaps you're talking about a different kind of "churn".

I don't really think I am.

I'm going to pick on your exact example: ip is replacing ifconfig because linux distros are moving to netlink as a replacement for ioctl. Why are they doing that? Hardware support - Particularly WNICs.

So did ifconfig need to be replaced? Strictly speaking, no - but if you want better hardware support - yes...

ifconfig could have been updated, but the problem is that you're adding complexity to the system somewhere, either by expanding the old interface, or by replacing it with a new one.

You can argue expansion would have been preferable to replacement, but I'm not totally convinced - they both have tradeoffs. Someone is paying the piper either way.

The only way to avoid that cost (churn in the existing tool, or churn in the introduction of a new tool) is by not supporting that hardware. Which is what BSD is doing...

Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by johnklos on Saturday August 27, 2022 @02:44PM (#32621855)
Sigh. I hear you, but your example is bad.

ip replaced ifconfig NOT because of new hardware support. For one, ifconfig could, and has been, extended. Second, that wouldn't explain removing ifconfig. Third, other OSes, like the BSDs, have alternatives for additional functionality like wiconfig.

ip could exist alongside of ifconfig, if ifconfig were really a subset of ip. It's political. And if you're going to echo that, "oh, someone needs to sit around and spend all sorts of energy keeping ifconfig up to date", then remember that they clearly don't if you contend that ip is all about supporting new stuff.

In other words, there's nothing in what you're saying at all that would explain the need to remove ifconfig and break decades of common usage. That's unnecessary churn, in my opinion.

Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by badrabbit on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @03:20AM (#32575917)
BSD is like a partner you settle down for because of reliability and stability, Linux is that hot person that makes you love and hate them at the same time driving you ever so mad and addicted.
Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by sph on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @03:53AM (#32576117)
Well, I guess I'm into dramatic relationships.

I will talk about Linux with my therapist when I see her next. I wonder if childhood trauma is the reason I'm a Linux sysadmin.

Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by badrabbit on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @03:59AM (#32576155)
Maybe childhood windows trauma?
Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by badpun on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @06:17AM (#32577358)
Yep, Linux (the userland) is the Google of open source world. You can see similarly little respect for actual user's experience. At Google, it's driven by greed (promos), with Linux, by fun of re-writing things from scratch instead of improving on existing solutions.
Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by na85 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:16PM (#32574590)
>The BSDs are much cleaner than Linux distros.

I see this opinion a lot, but what tangible benefits does that result in?

Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by heywoodlh on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:57PM (#32574815)
As far as I understand it, anything a user installs with pkg that isn't included with the base system is installed into /usr/local.

For me, this is a nice benefit because I can know that anything installed into /usr/local can be removed and won't break the basic system's functionality. This organizational structure I think is also just very sensible imo.

Note: I'm mostly a Linux user but I play around with FreeBSD a lot. I wish that by default my Arch machine organized things similarly, but ultimately it's minor enough for me that I haven't switched

Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by prmoustache on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @05:21AM (#32576883)
>As far as I understand it, anything a user installs with pkg that isn't included with the base system is installed into /usr/local. > >For me, this is a nice benefit because I can know that anything installed into /usr/local can be removed and won't break the basic system's functionality. This organizational structure I think is also just very sensible imo.

I don't really see how it is relevant. First I don't see why would anyone want to randomly remove things. On my linux system everything that I compile or install by myself goes to /usr/local. Everything managed by packages goes to /usr, any thing that comes from a precompiled tarball is better installed in /opt. How is that different?

What I liked about freebsd when I was using it was the handbook that was fairly complete.

Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by heywoodlh on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @11:02PM (#32588936)
On FreeBSD you can quickly tell what is a part of the base system vs not based on where it is located. Your /usr directory typically isn't empty on a new Linux install, whereas /usr/local is totally empty on FreeBSD when you install it.

A simple example is if you run 'which vim'. If you have installed vim through pkg on FreeBSD it will show up in /usr/local/bin/vim. Whereas if you run 'which vim' on Ubuntu, it will show up in /usr/bin/vim -- but on Ubuntu Desktop (when I last used it) vim is preinstalled. You can't just look at the /usr directory on a Linux machine in most cases and know what was installed when you installed the machine.

I mean, try debloating an Ubuntu Desktop machine that's been used for a while and tell me if by looking at the /usr directory what was included in the install vs what you installed post-install.

Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by ruslan on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @12:12AM (#32574902)
Just out of my curiosity, what would be that little thing which could make you switch to FreeBSD from Linux ?
Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by heywoodlh on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @11:02AM (#32580367)
I heavily rely on Linux-based containerization for a lot of my tooling and workflows. This allows me to bring most of my workflows to Windows, MacOS and of course Linux as tooling like Docker Desktop is cross-platform.
Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by waynesonfire on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:43AM (#32575672)
cgroups and as great as zfs is, an overlayfs is missing for a better jail experience.
Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by na85 on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:37PM (#32583843)
Is randomly deleting stuff from /usr a big part of your use case?
Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by heywoodlh on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @10:59PM (#32588918)
No, but you can quickly tell what is a part of the base system vs not based on where it is located. Your /usr directory typically isn't empty on a new Linux install, whereas /usr/local is totally empty.

A simple example is if you run 'which vim'. If you have installed vim through pkg on FreeBSD it will show up in /usr/local/bin/vim. Whereas if you run 'which vim' on Ubuntu, it will show up in /usr/bin/vim -- but on Ubuntu Desktop (when I last used it) vim is preinstalled. You can't just look at the /usr directory on a Linux machine in most cases and know what was installed when you installed the machine.

Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by ruslan on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @03:43PM (#32584729)
From viewpoint of organizing backups separating system stuff from host specific makes some sense. Also, you can put /usr/local on separate volume, this allows mounting rootfs read-only which can be useful in some cases.
Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by LargoLasskhyfv on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @12:07AM (#32574870)
Less hassle.
Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by kloch on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @06:48PM (#32572597)
Some folks just prefer BSD over other variants. I learned on old school SunOS so that might be why I prefer it.

SysV based Solaris left a bad taste and Linux just seemed unnecessarily weird. 386/Net/FreeBSD was fast, a stable, simple to configure and most importantly familiar.

Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by IgorPartola on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @06:18PM (#32572342)
For me personally it would be the ability to run jails and ZFS on a desktop. That would in turn enable me to run the same in production because local/dev/prod parity would be a good thing.
Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by MontyCarloHall on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @06:21PM (#32572362)
Don’t Linux and FreeBSD both use OpenZFS these days?

Jails are a fair point, but if they’re essential to your production environment, why not just run your FreeBSD dev environment in a VM on your Linux laptop, or SSH into a dedicated FreeBSD dev box?

After all, OP is already running Linux in a VM in order to run working WiFi drivers.

Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by throw0101a on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @08:24PM (#32573466)
> Don’t Linux and FreeBSD both use OpenZFS these days?

Certain integrations between ZFS and the OS are more 'elegant' in FreeBSD:

* https://www.freebsd.org/cgi/man.cgi?query=beadm

* https://www.freebsd.org/cgi/man.cgi?bectl

Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by fomine3 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:02PM (#32573759)
Also ARC and page cache (kernel mm) integration isn't very good on Linux. It's fine for NAS but possibly not good for desktop usage. Perhaps good on FreeBSD?
Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by ladyanita22 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @06:27PM (#32572418)
I mean, Ubuntu does support ZFS, and there's LXC...
Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by somat on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:39PM (#32574730)
I Find openbsd makes for a very nice desktop operating system. first of all note that I am talking about a unix style desktop, if you are expecting something more like a mac or windows desktop you would find it lacking, the only thing I add(aside from the usual large desktop applications) is spectrewm as I like a tileing window manager.

But there is something very comfortable about the openbsd base system that I have not found in a linux system, don't get me wrong linux is one of the good guys. it does not actively anger me up like using a windows desktop system does. But I really feel at home on openbsd, I think it is because I feel I understand the system well.

Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by mbarbar on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @01:04PM (#32582419)
Could I ask what kind of work you do day to day? Does it feel sluggish in comparison to Linux for that use case?
Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by somat on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @01:51PM (#32583155)
Mostly sys-admin stuff, a lot of terminals, ssh, config editing, minor programing. but I keep a few desktop utilities (gimp, inkscape, blender) for when I want to make pictures, notably absent is a file manager, the shell takes care of all my file manipulation needs. but if I had to recommend one it would be xfe.

Speed-wise I think is is more sluggish than a linux system. I like and keep it because openbsd is so comfortable. openbsd was the first operating system where I felt I understood it and it's motivations. every once in a while I try to replicate my preferred system on linux(void linux comes close to what I like about openbsd) but usually find myself back on openbsd(usually with a sigh of relief) in a couple of weeks.

Re:FreeBSD on the Framework Laptop by retro64 on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @04:40AM (#32576535)
I use both. I've asked myself why I don't just streamline and standardize simply on Linux as overall it has more traction, but every time I have the opportunity to complete the switch I refuse to give up BSD. I think it boils down to control.

Thinking back I have had essentially the same experience/environment on BSD for years. Upgrading from one version to the next just works and is fairly painless, even across major releases (trying to think of the last time I've had issues). I keep my home directory on a separate physical disk, so upgrading the OS drive or moving to new hardware is a matter of installing the latest BSD and plugging my home drive back in and mapping it. After upgrading I can use pkg to reinstall the apps I need and the shortcuts all link back, and I'm done. Probably forgot a few steps in there but it doesn't take long. For example I upgraded from 11.x to 13.0 just a few months ago with a hard drive swap and it took me maybe 3 hours(?), including installing the physical drive.

I don't play a lot of games on it, other than complete source ports, or simple games that run on vanilla wine. Linux is for gaming and experimenting. On Linux I am far more free with what I install, and my experience has changed often over the years with different distros. Some of that was by my choice, but even at the most basic level I've found that distros tend to have a lot of flux between versions.

So, overall no real surprises with FreeBSD. Upgrade and keep chugging.