News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by edgyquant on Monday August 22, 2022 @03:36PM (#32556153)
My hunch is that the real geopolitical upheaval of the next 50-100 years will be post-decolonization. A number of these nations were thrown together by a completely foreign power not just with an interest in splitting countries up or grouping them together but doing so in a way that prevents them becoming a peer level opponent.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by rajeshp1986 on Monday August 22, 2022 @08:43PM (#32559215)
Absolutely, the neighbor Afghanistan is an example. US tried so hard to enforce democracy but in the end it didn't work. Western Media might say it was unplanned and chaotic evacuation by US but large swath of population supported Taliban and welcomed them.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by sk0g on Monday August 22, 2022 @09:58PM (#32559680)
Conversely, when I was in Iran some 10-15 years ago, a few people mentioned wanting to be bombed/ freed from the government by the US. Our taxi driver in particular seemed to have a rosy mental image of what was going on in Afghanistan, which was quite surprising.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by robocat on Monday August 22, 2022 @04:32PM (#32556824)
> splitting countries up or grouping them together [] in a way that prevents them becoming a peer level opponent.

Any links to research that shows (a) this was the intent, and (b) shows that it works?

Aren’t there plenty of counterexamples to that thesis (null hypothesis), of more homogeneous nations or island nations where countries haven’t become “first world”. Even the USA is rooted in non-homogeneous immigration.

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by edgyquant on Monday August 22, 2022 @06:05PM (#32557897)
Not really a hypothesis that the British lumped unrelated and rival ethnicities in Africa together for a magnitude of reasons. Most of these were geopolitical to the interests of the metropole and almost none of these border decisions were (initially at least) designed to accurately represent cultural and ethnic identities the way America was colonized for example or the way Europe was shaped by feudalism and war.

That’s the “they weren’t being actively malicious end” with the nation this thread is discussing having been the go to example of this being done. Pakistan only exists to be a thorn in Indias side

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by jcranmer on Monday August 22, 2022 @07:39PM (#32558734)
> none of these border decisions were (initially at least) designed to accurately represent cultural and ethnic identities the way America was colonized for example

I'm not sure what you're referring to here. American borders were laid out without any consideration for indigenous peoples (the general policy of colonial and post-colonial states towards such peoples being "exterminate them"), and colonial and post-colonial states fought lots of wars over transferring land between them for reasons that boil down to simply "I want more land."

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by kamaal on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @02:32AM (#32561182)
>>Any links to research that shows (a) this was the intent, and (b) shows that it works?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sykes%E2%80%93Picot_Agreement

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by robocat on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @06:55AM (#32562962)
Which part showed intent to “divide and conquer“ or intent to cause internal conflict? I didn’t see any, although I do admit I skimmed (because it was a long read that appeared irrelevant).

And the article surely isn’t corroborating your thesis of mix cultures to force a long-term fail.

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by kamaal on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:08AM (#32565131)
Sykes-Picot agreement is as far as things go in diplomatic speak for a proof for this.

Quite literally the western powers cut up borders in mid east, sitting in rooms in Paris, London and Moscow, people who did this didn't even speak arabic, had no idea about ethnic, cultural, religious, political and social make up's of the lands they were cutting up to divide among each other.

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by throw_m239339 on Monday August 22, 2022 @04:53PM (#32557075)
> Even the USA is rooted in non-homogeneous immigration.

USA used to be mostly Northern European and christian (protestant), black slaves who were moved there by force or pre European colonization inhabitants were never considered part of the foundations of US. US foundations were anything but non-homogeneous.

Now after WWII, US attempted to replace the racial and religious identity at the heart of "americanship" with some idealistic identity based on american exceptionalism, the american dream and the cult of the american imagery (flag, eagle, colors...). No need to point out that this re-invention of "americanship" is slowly crumbling as we speak. Who knows what will remain of that cohesion in the next 50 years.

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by xyzzyz on Monday August 22, 2022 @07:30PM (#32558647)
The “Protestant” Northern Europeans in colonial America were anything but homogenous. New England Puritans not only had laws requiring Quakers to stay away, they in fact whipped, mutiliated and even executed those that refused to do so. The four English cultures that settled colonial America were vastly different from one another. The idea that there existed some kind of “US religious identity” upon its founding is profoundly ahistorical, and, in fact, laughable.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by Calavar on Monday August 22, 2022 @05:35PM (#32557609)
You're applying a 21st century post-globalization lens to a 18th century world. Sure, today a German is welcome in France or the UK and seen as more or less equal. In the 1700s, there wasn't even a concept of equality for subcultures within a single country, let alone different cultures in different countries. See Scottish/English relations or Parisian/Occitan relations or Flemish/Dutch relations.

The fact that people of Anglo-Saxon descent and people of Scots-Irish descent had an equal hand in the early US government was remarkable in and of itself, let alone the fact that the Catholic population in Maryland had equal rights under the law from day one.

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by throw_m239339 on Monday August 22, 2022 @05:46PM (#32557716)
> You're applying a 21st century post-globalization lens to a 18th century world.

because we're discussing 20th/21st century geopolitics at first place? Of course I am. Pakistan or India didn't exist in the 18th century, in fact these are British constructs.

> The fact that people of Anglo-Saxon descent and people of Scots-Irish descent had an equal hand in the early US government was remarkable in and of itself, let alone the fact that the Catholic population in Maryland had equal rights under the law from day one.

Yes, fighting against the British empire certainly was an efficient motivator. But still black people and indigenous populations were still left out of what you consider a feat.

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by JumpCrisscross on Monday August 22, 2022 @05:58PM (#32557829)
> still black people and indigenous populations were still left out of what you consider a feat

If we concede no feats have been achieved in human history for not being unblemishingly perfect, sure. Fine. We'll leave the term with religion (and madness). Whatever the next rung of achievement is, the highest one in realm of the possible, America's founding matches it.

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by eynsham on Monday August 22, 2022 @07:05PM (#32558436)
The idea of Pakistan was created by Muslim intellectuals, not the British.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by rayiner on Monday August 22, 2022 @06:40PM (#32558200)
Remarkably ignorant post. Like saying that everyone in India/Pakistan/Bangladesh is homogenous because they're all subcontinental "brown" people. The conflict between whites on one hand and Asians/Latinos in modern America pales in comparison to the conflict that existed between different groups of northern european Christians at the time of the founding.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by skissane on Monday August 22, 2022 @07:49PM (#32558807)
> USA used to be mostly Northern European and christian (protestant)

You are completely ignoring here the huge role that anti-Catholic prejudice had in US history (and the rest of the Anglosphere as well). Indeed, the vast majority of historic anti-Irish sentiment was really anti-Catholic – "Irish" came to mean "Irish Catholic", and Irish Protestants in the US rebranded themselves as "Scots-Irish" (not only those Irish Protestants who had recent Scottish heritage through the Plantation of Ulster – Irish Protestants who lacked any recent Scottish heritage called themselves that too.)

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by jollybean on Monday August 22, 2022 @07:32PM (#32558673)
N1) no, that phase mostly already happened.

It's what took place after WW2 and was the battle ground for the cold war.

That's a little bit Pakistan can into existence in the first place.

Singapore, Jamaica, heck, even Canada made it's own constitution. Most of Africa (both sub saharan and north saharan), much of the Middle East. Huge portion of the world map.

2) This 'Colonials set everything pit one group against the other' is also wrong. Obviously, there were favourites and artifacts of that, but for the most part, left to their own devices, it would still be tribal chaos in most places.

The presupposition in that anti-colonial statment is that somehow, before foreign intervention, things worked in some meaningful way. In most places, it did not, and, there were previous colonial/external interventions. i.e. Ottoman Empire ruled over much of the Middle East ruthlessly, previous Islamic Caliphates were all over NE Africa with the slave trade for many centuries etc. etc..

Relatively few places are like 'Thailand' with a fairly coherent history.

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by spaceman_2020 on Monday August 22, 2022 @06:42PM (#32558228)
You’re 100% right.

Democracies are going to collapse in a lot of places because the people in these places never really wanted democracy or even cared much for it. They were just handed it down because the people the colonizers left in charge were born and bred within the colonizer’s own political systems.

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by rayiner on Monday August 22, 2022 @06:48PM (#32558286)
Good example: https://unherd.com/2021/04/the-culture-wars-of-post-colonial...

Although I think it's not quite about "democracy." Many people don't want liberal democracy. They might be fine with non-liberal democracy: https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2016/08/shadi-hamid-on-i...

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by PradeetPatel on Monday August 22, 2022 @08:27PM (#32559085)
Which arguably may not be a bad thing. Letting the indigenous people of the land govern it according to their own cultural norms and values will allow new and diverse values to flourish.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by xvector on Monday August 22, 2022 @09:47PM (#32559598)
"Cultural norms" and "diverse values" like the oppression and subjugation of women, or mass government censorship as above? Some nations don't deserve the sovereignty they have. I don't think anyone would shed a tear if the UAE was taken over and replaced by a government that actually guarantees some basic human rights.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by dendriti on Monday August 22, 2022 @10:34PM (#32559917)
You do know that the oppression and subjugation of women and minorities was often brought by colonizers, right? Singapore's anti-homosexual laws, for example, were promulgated by the British. They didn't always bring enlightenment.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by n4r9 on Thursday August 25, 2022 @06:25AM (#32591810)
Same with India. Homosexuality was an accepted (not necessarily always approved) part of the culture for hundreds of years until the British outlawed it in the 18th Century.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by pphysch on Monday August 22, 2022 @03:43PM (#32556239)
50-100 years is quite a long time; it's already happening at an accelerating rate. Washington is rapidly losing its foothold in Latin America and SEA, France is losing West Africa. The West is in an unprecedented crisis right now and will be unable to compete with the next gen foreign policies coming out of China, Russia, and the many other "enemy states".
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by ta8645 on Monday August 22, 2022 @04:07PM (#32556517)
China is in the midst of a demographic collapse, and will be struggling with internal issues for decades, they're not going to be a threat. Russia is isolated and may lose most of their energy export revenues. They're not going to be a threat to anyone but their immediate neighbours.

But globalization, that has been enabled by the American military, may be coming to an end. The US armed forces are retooling in a way less geared to policing global merchant shipping. This signals a likely return to more local trade, controlled by regional powers.

We have been lucky to live in the richest, most prosperous era of human history. But the party seems to be winding down, and most of us and our heirs, will be living more modest lives, with reduced travel, diversity of goods, diet, and wealth.

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by pphysch on Monday August 22, 2022 @04:23PM (#32556711)
Yeah, that is Zeihan's narrative, very sparsely backed by holistic analysis.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by jollybean on Monday August 22, 2022 @07:36PM (#32558709)
? Did you miss the last 100 years of history?

That already happened. 1/2 after WW1, the other 1/2 after WW2.

That was the story of the 20th century.

We're in a new era now.

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by pphysch on Monday August 22, 2022 @07:38PM (#32558730)
If you think the 20th century was the century of decolonization, you haven't dug very deep.

The Congo is a good example. One year after achieving independence in 1960, its sovereign leader was assassinated and replaced with neocolonial puppets. In the last 60 years, that "independent" country has been brutally exploited by foreign profiteers. A microcosm of the global south during the 20th century.

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by jollybean on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @05:53AM (#32562516)
The DRC is not remotely in any way a colonial vassal.

It's laughable to suggest they could be exploited by 'Colonial Powers' when they can't even get electricity where they need it.

'Outside Force' for exploitation, sure, but it's always been thus.

'Western Influence' - sure, but mostly in the name of 'stability'.

The 'West' can really only benefit from these places when they are stable enough to start to form contracts for export, which most of these places are not. Those that are, and ruled by dictators, fine, as long as it's 'stable' and as a state they play well.

Otherwise, the 'big prize' is when these places are stable enough that they have 'consumers' who can 'consume' iPhones and KFC.

How many iPhones exported to DNC?

How many iPhones can they buy when it's total rampant murder and chaos?

How many can they buy when the are stable, have an industrial base, have banking, laws etc?

Which situation do you think Apple, Google, Amazon, Disney prefer?

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by HappySweeney on Monday August 22, 2022 @03:45PM (#32556262)
Could you elaborate on "next gen foreign policies"?
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by jessaustin on Monday August 22, 2022 @04:10PM (#32556558)
Not OP, but I would offer "not sanctioning/embargoing a third of the world"...
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by pphysch on Monday August 22, 2022 @04:22PM (#32556688)
BRI, BRICS+, SCO, EAEU/"petroruble".

the post-Washington Consensus

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by daemoens on Monday August 22, 2022 @04:39PM (#32556896)
The "post-Washingtion consensus" is too fragmented to have any real coordinated actions. BRICS is not some united force willing to work together. BRICS was meant for economies of similar scale to work together. China is already more than three times the size of the other 4 combined.The only thing that aligns all 5 now is generally anti-americanism which isn't much of a unifying force. China and India continue to worsen ties and Russia has become a bit of a pariah. Brazil and South Africa are too far apart from the rest for any meaningful cooperation.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by pphysch on Monday August 22, 2022 @07:13PM (#32558513)
Judging by the global reaction to the Ukraine war, the post-Washington order is less fragmented than the Washington-centric order.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by daemoens on Monday August 22, 2022 @07:25PM (#32558616)
Yes because they have nothing to gain from sanctioning Russia. But they also have virtually no trade with it so whether they sanctioned it or not means nothing. Russia trades mostly with Europe and China, not BRICS. And the sanctions have already clearly dug in.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by pphysch on Monday August 22, 2022 @07:33PM (#32558678)
In theory, they have a lot to gain: brownie points with Washington. Unfortunately, almost no one respects Washington anymore. That ship has sailed.

The end result is that the Russian economy is afloat while the transatlantic power structure is collapsing.

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by daemoens on Monday August 22, 2022 @07:36PM (#32558714)
Brownie points mean less than nothing. Nations do not upon brownie points, just their self interests. If Brazil sanctioned Russia it would mean nothing and Washington would see it as such.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by pphysch on Monday August 22, 2022 @08:14PM (#32558986)
> Brownie points mean less than nothing. Nations do not upon brownie points, just their self interests.

Except when you behave like this, you end up like Saddam Hussein and Muammar Gaddafi -- lynched while their country is destroyed. "Brownie points" with the unipolar superpower is absolutely meaningful as long as they maintain that position. Which they don't anymore, circa 2020 or so.

Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by daemoens on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:11AM (#32566050)
Saddam and Gaddafi went directly against Washington, they weren't neutral.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by pphysch on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @12:46PM (#32567599)
Exactly. You need to be either neutral or favorable towards the superpower. If you are not, and you seek national interests at the expense of Washington's interests (e.g. nationalizing resources, competing with the USD), you will get wrecked.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by daemoens on Friday August 26, 2022 @04:14PM (#32612227)
So we agree? Most nations have stayed neutral or sided against Russia. The only nations that side with Russia are Syria, Eritrea, North Korea, and Belarus. None of them have either the economy or military to do even the small amount except for Belarus. And Lukashenko knows sending his troops to Ukraine makes him vulnerable to his citizens and Russia at the same time. His military is the only thing stopping the people or Putin from kicking him out.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by daemoens on Monday August 22, 2022 @04:40PM (#32556908)
What petroruble? Barely any countries are paying for gas in rubles, and the rest of the world certainly isn't.
Re:YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams s... by selimthegrim on Monday August 22, 2022 @03:48PM (#32556287)
Maybe he’s been listening to Zaid Hamid too much.