News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple expands Self Service Repair to Mac notebooks by dang on Monday August 22, 2022 @01:16PM (#32554377)
I think it's because those comments are provoked reflexively by the appearance of $BigCo in a story (automatically guaranteed to generate generic complaints about $BigCo), and if the story is the tuple ($BigCo, $Theme) (where $Theme = something like support, repair, price, you name it) then the reflex is even stronger to reproduce any-associated-complaint in that space.

Because this is reflexive, it's not really a response to the story at hand—such comments are more self-referential than on topic. That is not intellectually interesting—we're not learning much from them. It's satisfying, though, to those who have similar pre-existing associations and feelings, so inevitably it brings up a lot of me-too reactions and similar posts. But again, those aren't particularly related to the original story—they're just prompted by it, sort of like tapping on a knee—so they aren't interesting to people who don't personally have the same associations with that topic tuple.

Eventually, users who have opposite associations get tired of seeing these generic, not-particularly-on-topic comments, and respond by complaining about the complaints. Of course that's a reflexive and generic response in its own right. I sometimes call this the contrarian dynamic of internet forums (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...).

The only two things I know of to counteract this trend are (1) for users to consciously post more substantive, on-topic, curious comments, which provide nuclei for better discussion to organize around; and (2) for moderators to downweight generic and offtopic subthreads, which counteracts their unfortunate tendency to stick at the top of the page.

p.s. Another way of describing this is that curious conversation needs reflective comments rather than reflexive ones: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor....

Re:Apple expands Self Service Repair to Mac notebooks by widowlark on Monday August 22, 2022 @01:27PM (#32554524)
As always thanks for the insight, dang
Re:Apple expands Self Service Repair to Mac notebooks by choppaface on Monday August 22, 2022 @03:51PM (#32556318)
This is a good post to reflect upon when considering the bias in HN moderation. The moderation is not just invested in YC financially, but the depth of self-righteous philosophical conviction is there too. This isn’t Reddit nor your average Trust & Safety team that aims at neutrality, dang wants to be a Drudge or a Jeff Zucker.