Re:Cory Doctorow's next book: Chokepoint Capitalism
by deadpannini on Thursday August 18, 2022 @12:11PM
(#32511557)
My argument is that:
1) Consolidation as such is not intrinsically dangerous, especially when "consolidation" refers to "five large firms."
2) The Open Markets Institute website doesn't provide actual evidence of anti-competitive behavior. Instead, they use "monopoly" as an inaccurate scare word to muster a factually defective narrative about the source of social ills.
Their website enumerates actual anti-competitive practices for 2/36 industry headings (pharmaceuticals and automobile components). The rest just promote a simple idea, "big is bad," using an extremely flexible definition of what constitutes a market (where cowboy boots is only the most comical example).
Monopolies are qualitatively different than duopolies, to say nothing of quintopolies. It's not a smooth gradient of danger. Highly consolidated industries deserve more scrutiny, but they are not obviously and inevitably dangerous, especially in a globally competitive market.
I am against anti-competitive practices, and absolutely happy to discuss specific instances of those. But the lack of rigor here means I can't take Doctorow or the OMI seriously.
1) Consolidation as such is not intrinsically dangerous, especially when "consolidation" refers to "five large firms."
2) The Open Markets Institute website doesn't provide actual evidence of anti-competitive behavior. Instead, they use "monopoly" as an inaccurate scare word to muster a factually defective narrative about the source of social ills.
Their website enumerates actual anti-competitive practices for 2/36 industry headings (pharmaceuticals and automobile components). The rest just promote a simple idea, "big is bad," using an extremely flexible definition of what constitutes a market (where cowboy boots is only the most comical example).
Monopolies are qualitatively different than duopolies, to say nothing of quintopolies. It's not a smooth gradient of danger. Highly consolidated industries deserve more scrutiny, but they are not obviously and inevitably dangerous, especially in a globally competitive market.
I am against anti-competitive practices, and absolutely happy to discuss specific instances of those. But the lack of rigor here means I can't take Doctorow or the OMI seriously.