News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by isolli on Thursday August 18, 2022 @08:51AM (#32508906)
The move from saturated fats (e.g. butter, beef tallow) to trans fats (e.g. margarine) was not necessarily a good one. Sometimes I wonder if most nutritional advice just follows constantly changing fads...
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by bluGill on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:18AM (#32509168)
Doing a long term nutritional study is hard. You can often say about attempts as having one of two outcomes: "despite our best efforts we were unable to get participants to eat their assigned diet", or "This result only applies to those confined to prison/a hospital bed" (both of which implies other major lifestyle differences from normal people that were not controlled for). Otherwise people will eat what you tell them to for a week and then go back to whatever they were doing before (and often they don't remember what they ate and make things up later to fill out the diary)

This study gets around this because the trans-fat ban (which took a long time to come because of the above factors) was a nationwide thing and so lack of access means we can make assumptions. Even then they had to figure out what was this ban, what was smoking becoming less common, and what was increased use of statins, which is statistics that depending on input assumptions.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by asdajksah2123 on Thursday August 18, 2022 @10:51AM (#32510492)
That's why the Pollan advice to "Eat food. Not too much. Mostly Plants" is so good and more profound than is commonly understood.

1) Eat food. This is basically saying eat stuff that is traditionally considered food in different cultures (i.e., stuff that has been eaten for centuries) because doing nutritional studies is hard, but the fact that certain cultures have thrived for centuries and even millenia eating "food" provides decent evidence that it works.

2) Not too much. This is necessary as a restriction to #1 because in the past it wasn't easy or even possible to eat "too much" since you didn't have modern conveniences that make it easy to prepare food and you couldn't just order it for delivery. So you have to explicitly ensure you don't eat "too much", something that was implicitly enforced in the past.

3) Mostly Plants. If there is one thing all nutritional studies have found, and the one thing that pretty much all the science in this area can agree upon, is that eating plants (i.e. vegetables) is good for you, and for the most part, the more the better. But also note that he is saying "Plants" and not "Veggies" in a nod to the idea that it should be largely simply prepared and as close to its natural formation as possible, so buying a bag of "veggie straws" does not count.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday August 18, 2022 @12:20PM (#32511643)
> eating plants (i.e. vegetables)…in a nod to the idea that it should be largely simply prepared and as close to its natural formation as possible

Plenty of cultures heavily process their plants, and for good reason: the raw form is less nutritious. Plants != vegetables. Vegetables exclude fruits and uncultivated plants; wildflowers are delicious and definitively plants but debatably veggies [1].

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vegetable

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by Isamu on Thursday August 18, 2022 @12:45PM (#32511995)
Some common foods (e.g. kidney beans) must be properly cooked for them to be not poisonous.

Chocolate is an example of a food that is highly processed just for it to be reasonably less bitter and unpromising as it is in raw form.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by copperx on Thursday August 18, 2022 @02:28PM (#32513197)
Pollan's advice is based on hunches. I'd like some science to back all of that up, especially the "mostly plants" bit. Eating mostly plants increases your exposure to pesticides significantly, especially if eating organic produce.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by hombre_fatal on Thursday August 18, 2022 @05:21PM (#32515060)
How hard did you look?
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by 331c8c71 on Thursday August 18, 2022 @04:42PM (#32514627)
Imo there's nothing profound about the quote but your writing is very convincing. You could do sales/marketing (if you aren't doing it already).
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by dfxm12 on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:10AM (#32509099)
I don't think the move was due to nutritional advice. For example, margarine is cheaper than butter, and really gained in popularity during the depression and the war when dairy supply was shortening (ahem). It also has different culinary properties from butter, including being possibly vegan and behaving differently in baked goods. Overall though, at least since 2000, butter is far outselling margarine, so it seems like these days, it is a niche product and not really a "healthy" butter alternative.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by acdha on Thursday August 18, 2022 @02:08PM (#32512966)
It was. The 80s were crammed with doctors & advertisements promoting margarine as the responsible choice and saying that using butter or lard would kill you. That’s because the Nixon administration felt that they needed to do something about the obesity crisis, and they added nutrition to what had previously been a commission about hunger and gave them a deadline for a plan.

Unfortunately, the need to get recommendations out on a political schedule meant that they went ahead of the available evidence. This Washington Post piece from 1977 debating the then-proposed guidelines includes an interesting quote:

> Dr. Mark Hegsted, professor of nutrition at Harvard University and one of the three nutritionists who helped write the report, said: "There will undoubtedly be many people who will say we have not proven our point; we have not demonstrated that the dietary modifications we recommend will yield the dividends expected.

> "The question to be asked therefore, is not why should we change our diet, but why not. "What are the risks associated with eating less meat, less fat, less saturated fat, less cholesterol, less sugar, less salt and more fruits, vegetables, unsaturated fat - and cereal products - especially whole-grain cereals? There are none that can be identified and important benefits can be expected."

That “but why not” line of reasoning is interesting given the mixed status of the recommendations in the next sentence. Eating more fruits, vegetables, whole-grains, etc. and less sugar is still widely accepted as good advice now but the remainder of the guidelines are problematic, particularly now that we have a better understanding of e.g. how fat interacts with satiation or how the food industry scrambled to produce alternate versions of familiar foods without key ingredients.

What we do know now is that millions of people had worse health outcomes due to that rush because even though studies came out only a few years later in the 80s rejecting the theories about salt, fat, specific foods like eggs, etc. the ghost of that Nixon-era rush job hung around until the 2010s and isn’t completely gone yet. You can still see a ton of food loaded with sugar because the recipe was modified decades ago to remove the fat & salt which made it taste good, not to mention how often people pass over vegetables because someone said it was unhealthy to butter or fry them without considering that this made the most likely outcome skipping them entirely.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by isolli on Friday August 19, 2022 @03:41AM (#32518427)
A devastating example of ignoring the "first do no harm" principle.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by acdha on Friday August 19, 2022 @11:47AM (#32522501)
Yeah, the intention seems good – there’s some question about whether sugar industry funding shifted viewpoints but from what I have read that seems dubious compared to the simple explanation that the President wanted a policy now and people went with their instinct. He was later fired by Reagan because the beef industry didn’t like the low-fat guidelines so it’s not like this field doesn’t have all kinds of politics pulling in other directions, too.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by Jensson on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:17AM (#32509153)
But fastfood restaurants and precooked meals continue to use margarine instead of butter. For example McDonalds switched away from animal fats in early 90s and never switched back. They wont mention margarine in the ingredients, instead they just say "vegetable oils".
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by dfxm12 on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:20AM (#32509182)
That has nothing to do with nutritional advice, which is what OP is saying. That has to do with lower cost and/or maybe some other property (like longer shelf life).
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by kaesar14 on Thursday August 18, 2022 @11:58AM (#32511364)
Correct me if I’m wrong but McDonalds originally made that switch due to the “animal fats are bad for you” push during that time which is what OP is probably referencing?
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by allturtles on Thursday August 18, 2022 @12:36PM (#32511858)
It was for health reasons, this is well-documented in secondary sources [0] and primary sources [1].

[0]: https://www.eatthis.com/mcdonalds-french-fries-taste-differe... [1]: https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-1990-07-24-900302...

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by kixiQu on Thursday August 18, 2022 @11:50AM (#32511274)
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by analog31 on Thursday August 18, 2022 @12:39PM (#32511900)
They also switched from beef tallow to vegetable shortening for the fryers, perhaps for the sake of vegetarians.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by Hnaomyiph on Thursday August 18, 2022 @10:12AM (#32509859)
I think the move wasn’t following fads. In the mid 1900s there was ample evidence pointing at sugar being the culprit for rising obesity rates and other weight-related aliments, but there was a large push from industry to willfully ignore that and label fats as the bad guy. As a result consumers wanted low-fat foods and “healthier” alternatives to traditional fats.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by ParksNet on Thursday August 18, 2022 @12:18PM (#32511627)
Fat goes rancid. Sugar is shelf stable and preservative.

Nutrition is not guided by fads, but by food manufacturer and retailer profit margins.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by mixmastamyk on Thursday August 18, 2022 @08:47PM (#32516560)
A good doc on the subject, reminds one of the tobacco industry a bit earlier:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sugar_Coated

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by phkahler on Thursday August 18, 2022 @10:31AM (#32510186)
>> The move from saturated fats (e.g. butter, beef tallow) to trans fats (e.g. margarine) was not necessarily a good one. Sometimes I wonder if most nutritional advice just follows constantly changing fads...

The reason for change is often forgotten or even misunderstood. From what I've read there is nothing wrong with eating saturated far or unsaturated fat, but transfat (a.k.a. partially hydrogenated) is very bad for you, as it chokes the machinery for "consuming" one or the other by being a bit of both.

After the crusade against fat, people also seemed to get the idea that eating fat makes you fat (the original reasoning had more to do with heart disease), but keto and low-carb diets that work would beg to differ. You gotta read the actual results to get to the bottom of things.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by echelon on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:23AM (#32509212)
Just consider the biochemical basis.

The body can deal with saturated and unsaturated fats. It has the enzymes to transport and handle them. They're a normal constituent of membranes.

Trans fats have no place in the body, and they do not arise naturally. You don't have the programming to deal with them. Their structure increases membrane rigidity, decreases lipid raft mobility, impairs cellular function.

Don't put trans fats into your body in any quantity.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by amelius on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:30AM (#32509309)
> Trans fats have no place in the body, and they do not arise naturally.

But, from wikipedia:

> A type of trans fat occurs naturally in the milk and body fat of ruminants (such as cattle and sheep) at a level of 2–5% of total fat.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by Finnucane on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:35AM (#32509361)
But it’s a vey small amount relative to what is added in processed food. And it still has no nutritional benefit.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by SketchySeaBeast on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:33AM (#32509337)
Trans fats do exist naturally - they exist in meat and milk fat, just not to the level we're not consuming them. As usual, it's the dose that makes the poison.
Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by Zigurd on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:18AM (#32509171)
A lot of it is motivated by a search for easy answers: Eat too much butter, get fat. The answer should be "Eat less butter, move more." It is unsurprising that "Eat margarine instead" is the wrong answer.

Not everything about traditional food is good. Cured meats, for example. But a too-convenient solution is often too convenient to be true.

Re:Benefits of the Danish transfat ban for coronary heart di... by kleton on Thursday August 18, 2022 @10:30AM (#32510158)
Just this year, the American medical association changed their recommendation for children from whole milk to 1% milk. I thought it was mendela effect when the pediatrician said this at the last yearly checkup.