Re:FreeBSD – A Lesson in Poor Defaults
by ninefathom on Thursday August 18, 2022 @09:05AM
(#32509049)
For reference, this was several years ago- 2015 or thereabouts. The FreeBSD project has since added or improved various security features (or made them more accessible) directly as a result of the work from and/or the pressure exerted by HardenedBSD.
This was not the case early on, and to my memory, in the early days of HardenedBSD, the relationship between the two groups could have generously been described as acrimonious. For an example, see the ASLR-on-FreeBSD debate.
> For an example, see the ASLR-on-FreeBSD debate.
Not much of a debate? You either take contribution feedback or you don't contribute. When I open a PR to some open-source project, and maintainers/contributors give me feedback, I incorporate it and don't throw a tantrum.
Everything aside, ASLR is present since 13.0 and default in 14.0. Different implementation. Usefulness of ASLR in general is another debate.
To clarify, FreeBSD 14.0 is not out and probably won't be out for quite some time. All users of the current release are still without even basic ASLR.
That's not true - it is in all supported releases, but not enabled by default. It will be enabled by default in the upcoming 131.1
I meant by default. The title of this paper I'm commenting on should make it clear, but sorry if it wasn't.
Page 6 especially:
https://freebsdfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/Sev...
Full on "hardened" ;)
https://hardenedbsd.org/content/easy-feature-comparison