Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by CamperBob on Thursday November 17, 2011 @09:16PM
(#3250260)
Not clear what legal issues surround the release of patented (and licensed) source code. The whole idea behind a patent is to reveal the details of a technique to the public.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by rmc on Friday November 18, 2011 @06:31AM
(#3251404)
id wants to release the code as GPL. To be GPL there can be no legal obstacle to distributing and modifying the code. The patent is not held by id, and I doubt the patent holders have allowed anyone to copy & use this patent as much as they want, ergo you can't copy & use the code as much as you want. So you can't release it under the GPL.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by lambda on Friday November 18, 2011 @02:05AM
(#3250909)
The issue is that they will be releasing the source under the GPL, which requires that you give anyone who receives the code a patent license, but they probably can't give a patent license as they can't sublicense the patent from Creative.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by sp332 on Thursday November 17, 2011 @11:00PM
(#3250549)
The point of a patent is to prevent other people from making things that implement your idea. The patent was licensed to id, but maybe the license only covered one project.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by Jach on Thursday November 17, 2011 @09:22PM
(#3250279)
> The whole idea behind a patent is to reveal the details of a technique to the public.
No it's not. That may have once been the ideal but has never been the case.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by burgerbrain on Thursday November 17, 2011 @09:29PM
(#3250310)
It was in fact the idea, but never has effectively been the reality.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by brown9-2 on Thursday November 17, 2011 @09:51PM
(#3250370)
id doesn't hold the patent in question.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by CamperBob on Thursday November 17, 2011 @10:07PM
(#3250411)
Doesn't matter. There are no requirements to keep a patented implementation secret, unless for some reason they agreed to do so when they licensed the patent.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by rmgraham on Thursday November 17, 2011 @11:28PM
(#3250604)
Under patent law any user would be violating the patent by playing the game (or possibly just having a copy on their computer), unless they bought a license from the patent holder or were covered by someone else's license.
Yes, patent law is that ridiculous.