News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany: 1 Dead, 9 injured after BMW self driving test ca... by cmsj on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @12:39PM (#32485257)
> seems all too comfortable ignoring the other crashes that happen daily

In your view, what is the MVP for self-driving car safety, in terms of the number of crashes/deaths per day?

Re:Germany: 1 Dead, 9 injured after BMW self driving test ca... by joshstrange on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @12:49PM (#32485435)
1 less death/accident than cars with only human drivers per capita. And level 1+ automation must be in separate buckets.

For example:

9 accidents out of 100 cars on the road in some level of driver automation (bucketed per-level) is acceptable if there were 10 accidents of 100 cars on the road with only a human driver over the same timespan (probably some kind of rolling average).

We should absolutely investigate the causes of driverless car (at any level) crashes and penalize companies if they are at fault and the issue was foreseeable but a lot people seem to think the only acceptable answer is “0 accidents” which is just absurd. Don’t let good be the enemy of great.

Re:Germany: 1 Dead, 9 injured after BMW self driving test ca... by cmsj on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @12:56PM (#32485571)
I'd like to invite you to consider that with the (I would say) utilitarian view that one less death is an acceptable MVP, you are implicitly saying that you'd be ok with products being sold in the full knowledge that they would autonomously kill tens of thousands of people per year.

While it may be true that perfect is the enemy of good, there is also such a thing as setting the bar too low.

Re:Germany: 1 Dead, 9 injured after BMW self driving test ca... by joshstrange on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @01:02PM (#32485665)
> you are implicitly saying that you'd be ok with products being sold in the full knowledge that they would autonomously kill tens of thousands of people per year.

Which is the status quo for both cars and a bunch of other industries (pharma, tabaco, alcohol, fast food, the list goes on). Nothing is ever perfect (though many things don't have "death" as a potential failure case) but you are only looking at the downside and ignoring the lives that would be saved.

I don't think many families think "Well our Bobby died in a car accident that would have been preventable by technology but even if he had access to it thousands of other people would still die even while using that tech so we are ok with him dying".

Re:Germany: 1 Dead, 9 injured after BMW self driving test ca... by aidenn0 on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:05PM (#32486495)
> Which is the status quo for both cars and a bunch of other industries

The key difference here is that alcohol and tobacco do not autonomously kill people. We can feel safe blaming deaths caused by them on the individuals who purchased and used those products. Same with automotive deaths. As soon as the blame goes from diffuse individuals to a single locus, the torts will come out in full-force. If a self-driving car kills 10% as many people per vehicle-mile as the average individual driver, then the company making it will get sued out of existence.

Re:Germany: 1 Dead, 9 injured after BMW self driving test ca... by Arnt on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @01:07PM (#32485719)
If you don't accept that cars may be sold that cause slightly fewer deaths than the Ford F-150, what's your argument for accepting that the Ford F-150 is sold?

(Or, if you will, substitute any other concrete existing model of car for the one I named.)

Re:Germany: 1 Dead, 9 injured after BMW self driving test ca... by cmsj on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @07:00PM (#32490127)
We accept that human drivers are not perfect and are going to cause thousands of deaths per year with their vehicles.

It's a whole different ballgame to accept that computers are going to choose to kill thousands of people per year, and it is not much comfort to know that it's slightly fewer thousands of people. I think this is especially true when the response to such deaths is not "we will investigate thoroughly and ensure this never happens again".

This is not a logically consistent argument, but humans are not logically consistent beings.

Re:Germany: 1 Dead, 9 injured after BMW self driving test ca... by abracadabra_ on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @01:03PM (#32485673)
Have you considered that by not allowing that product to be sold you are indirectly responsible for any extra deaths caused by human drivers?
Re:Germany: 1 Dead, 9 injured after BMW self driving test ca... by cmsj on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @07:01PM (#32490135)
I don't think the answer is to not allow autonomous cars to be sold, I think the answer is to engineer self-driving cars with the same kind of rigour that the aircraft industry uses, rather than the kind of rigour that startups use.
Re:Germany: 1 Dead, 9 injured after BMW self driving test ca... by pvaldes on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:00PM (#32486441)
Hum, It depends. In absolute terms, yes, of course. But 9 accidents by machines among 100 drivers aren't necessarily an improvement in all aspects over 10 accidents caused by humans among 100 drivers.

In the first case, we "remove" people at random from a pool of drivers good and bad, so we have more percentage of bad drivers after all. In the second we remove much more bad drivers than good drivers so is much more safe for the rest. Humans can learn from past experiences and apply creative solutions to complex problems, machines are slower in this sense.

Re:Germany: 1 Dead, 9 injured after BMW self driving test ca... by shultays on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @12:44PM (#32485364)
Lower than human driven cars? I think it is just basic math at that point when you try to generalize things.
Re:Germany: 1 Dead, 9 injured after BMW self driving test ca... by cmsj on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @01:00PM (#32485628)
The question was not really a quantitative one. The purpose of asking that question is to determine the mindset of the person answering.

Safety systems don't generally get built with an MVP mindset, but that seems to be what is happening with autonomous cars and it's concerning to me on multiple fronts.

Re:Germany: 1 Dead, 9 injured after BMW self driving test ca... by notatoad on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @12:46PM (#32485386)
https://www.iihs.org/topics/fatality-statistics/detail/state...

somewhere around 1 death per hundred million miles seems reasonable.