Re:Ask HN:Beautiful Web UIs - how?
by snowwrestler on Thursday November 17, 2011 @10:57AM
(#3248021)
Well Photoshop is a bit more complex software than a text editor; it's more of a deep toolset than just a frame. Being great at Photoshop means that at least the tool command is there to do great design work. It's probably more akin to a development platform, like saying someone is a "Ruby wiz." It still doesn't mean they'll do great work, but at least they CAN do great work. If someone sucks at Ruby (or Photoshop) they are going to have a hard time developing great products with it.
No, saying somebody can use Photoshop is not like saying they're a Ruby whiz.
Here's how you can tell:
"Oh, Bob! He's an Eclipse wiz!"
How much does that actually tell you about Bob's programming skill?
That definitely doesn't tell much about Bob's ability to craft beautiful code fast.
However, in my experience, people who have mastered their tool-chains are most likely good developers too.
Re:Ask HN:Beautiful Web UIs - how?
by snowwrestler on Thursday November 17, 2011 @12:22PM
(#3248376)
How much does saying someone is a Ruby wiz tell you about the programs they create? Knowing how to write functional, efficient code is no guarantee of producing a useful, interesting, or beautiful program.
Edit to add: beautiful software is a design problem--encompassing both function and looks. If the functional design is good, but the person doesn't know Photoshop, it makes sense to hire a Photoshop wiz to help them with the looks. I think we're in agreement, though, that being good with the tool is not by itself evidence of good design.
Unless, of course, you as a developer describe your main skill as being "a text editor wiz."