News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN:Beautiful Web UIs - how? by ahoyhere on Thursday November 17, 2011 @09:57AM (#3247803)
Good design has nothing to do with being a "photoshop wiz."

Unless, of course, you as a developer describe your main skill as being "a text editor wiz."

Re:Ask HN:Beautiful Web UIs - how? by snowwrestler on Thursday November 17, 2011 @10:57AM (#3248021)
Well Photoshop is a bit more complex software than a text editor; it's more of a deep toolset than just a frame. Being great at Photoshop means that at least the tool command is there to do great design work. It's probably more akin to a development platform, like saying someone is a "Ruby wiz." It still doesn't mean they'll do great work, but at least they CAN do great work. If someone sucks at Ruby (or Photoshop) they are going to have a hard time developing great products with it.
Re:Ask HN:Beautiful Web UIs - how? by ahoyhere on Thursday November 17, 2011 @11:51AM (#3248242)
No, saying somebody can use Photoshop is not like saying they're a Ruby whiz.

Here's how you can tell:

"Oh, Bob! He's an Eclipse wiz!"

How much does that actually tell you about Bob's programming skill?

Re:Ask HN:Beautiful Web UIs - how? by ultimoo on Thursday November 17, 2011 @11:08PM (#3250569)
That definitely doesn't tell much about Bob's ability to craft beautiful code fast. However, in my experience, people who have mastered their tool-chains are most likely good developers too.
Re:Ask HN:Beautiful Web UIs - how? by snowwrestler on Thursday November 17, 2011 @12:22PM (#3248376)
How much does saying someone is a Ruby wiz tell you about the programs they create? Knowing how to write functional, efficient code is no guarantee of producing a useful, interesting, or beautiful program.

Edit to add: beautiful software is a design problem--encompassing both function and looks. If the functional design is good, but the person doesn't know Photoshop, it makes sense to hire a Photoshop wiz to help them with the looks. I think we're in agreement, though, that being good with the tool is not by itself evidence of good design.