Part of the discrepancy here - and housing needs its own entire article - is how low interest rates factor into affordability. In the 80's, a 30-year fixed cost 18%. Last year it was 2.5%.
On a monthly basis (which is how many calculate affordability) a $166K loan at 18% APR is $2500/mth. A $635K loan at 2.5% APR is $2500/mth. These houses are equally affordable on a monthly basis. Even though one home is $200K and the other is $800K. The only delta is the down payment.
In a very real way, the 'starter home' became a 60/40 equity/bond portfolio plus a rental unit.
Between that and FHA as a peer comment pointed out, folks could actually be quite a bit better off today in spite of the bigger sticker - and yes, in spite of PMI (generally only 0.5% to 1%) which can be waived once you reach 20% LTV. (2.5% + 1%) is still way - way - lower than the 18% rates we saw in the 80s.
That's why I said housing deserves its own post, rather than letting it get lumped into with the chart crimes.
Owning is not always better than renting (although it can be). The biggest driver of the delta between owning and renting is actually the opportunity cost associated with not investing the down payment into the equity markets. The point at which folks buy has shifted older, yes. That isn't always a bad thing. A higher down payment is still your own capital. You get it back when you sell.
You don't get the same optionality if you buy with interest rates at an all time low.
Housing affordability is actually at an all-time low right now, close to 1982 levels, after the interest rate rise.
https://www.atlantafed.org/center-for-housing-and-policy/dat...
Just because houses have gotten bigger and families have gotten smaller, doesn’t mean you can buy an average 1970s house in major cities for the same inflation adjusted price. A lot of those old homes are either gone, extremely expensive, or situated in different metro areas than younger generations live in today.