News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CDC deletes statement that “mRNA and spike protein do not... by sazz on Monday August 15, 2022 @09:21AM (#32469299)
And for all those who downplay this process of deletion and think that's just how science works:

Where were you when YT and FB were deleting content and accusing people of spreading lies because they contradicted CDC information?

Where were you to say that error is part of science and people with a different opinion may well be right?

Where were you when people from the "team science" mob defamed people with an unpopular opinion and destroyed their livelihoods when they were blackballed by their employers?

So yes - actually, it would be a small thing if the CDC corrected this message after the fact. But after everyone elevated the CDC as the only incontrovertible truth, the fall down is now just a little longer.

Re:CDC deletes statement that “mRNA and spike protein do not... by cyanydeez on Monday August 15, 2022 @09:41PM (#32478278)
What matters is authority, after peer review; not peer distribution.

Don't confuse the matter with a random agenda.

Re:CDC deletes statement that “mRNA and spike protein do not... by davidguetta on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @05:13PM (#32501811)
My xp in peer review (in actual scientific research) is that it is VERY STRONGLY BIASED to the agendas of the reviewers, when it's not just failing bc of their incompetence.

If anything covid has shown that scientic "truths" are highly political.

Re:CDC deletes statement that “mRNA and spike protein do not... by kurupt213 on Monday August 15, 2022 @11:12PM (#32478795)
Peer review is not the gatekeeper for accuracy
Re:CDC deletes statement that “mRNA and spike protein do not... by drekk on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @02:07AM (#32492866)
Necessary but not sufficient for accuracy. Someone googling about molecular biology and posting it on Facebook isn't "contributing to the discourse". They're drowning out signal with noise.
[dead]
Re:CDC deletes statement that “mRNA and spike protein do not... by sazz on Monday August 15, 2022 @10:59AM (#32470511)
Please read my statement carefully. Do you understand the meaning of a Straw man argument?

I am not implying it to "everyone", but accusing people of a double standard who now argue that deleting a statement is "quite normal" because that is how it is done in science. And there are plenty of examples in these threads.

So I am not accusing these people of anything (because that would be a straw man argument), but I find it hypocritical when someone considers changes in CDC content to be "everyday scientific practice" without taking into the account that entire careers were destroyed based on precisely this content by a mob using CDC content as their religious truth.