News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by mlindner on Monday August 15, 2022 @05:45AM (#32467652)
There's numerous examples of it stopping for children, including in official testing. It was already stopping for children in 2019. Including in sudden appearance of them from behind an object (see at 2:20). https://youtu.be/x7Hp2zACGmg?t=126

In fact it does it better than most other vehicles in the above test.

The more interesting thing here is that I want to know what's going on with the algorithm on how this thing has 213,000 likes and 26,000 retweets despite only having been posted 5 days ago. Twitter bots at work here?

Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by orlp on Monday August 15, 2022 @05:56AM (#32467740)
I don't think that "it doesn't always kill or seriously maim a child - there are numerous examples where it didn't" is as powerful an argument as you think it is.
Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by mlindner on Monday August 15, 2022 @06:01AM (#32467775)
> it doesn't always kill or seriously maim a child - there are numerous examples where it didn't

Don't intentionally misquote me to twist my argument.

Give me an example where it did actually kill or seriously maim a child.

Also you don't get to automatically ignore all the children that were saved from inattentive drivers by this system. It works even when autopilot is inactive.

Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by orlp on Monday August 15, 2022 @06:50AM (#32468068)
> Also you don't get to automatically ignore all the children that were saved from inattentive drivers by this system.

You are right about this of course, I just found the wording quite strange.

Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by kaba0 on Monday August 15, 2022 @07:29AM (#32468315)
And is available in a low-end suzuki at the fraction of the price.

I am all for computer-assisted breaking, but I hate the mislabeling of tesla’s featureset as FSD, as that’s just a scam.

Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by mlindner on Monday August 15, 2022 @11:46AM (#32471166)
It can do long distance self driving runs with zero takeovers, just not every time yet. I wouldn't call it a scam just because it's not working perfectly yet. See this video for example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pf37o-cKOMs
Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by kklisura on Monday August 15, 2022 @05:54AM (#32467722)
That video is from 2019. How many updates of Autopilot or FSD where there since then? I mean the general question is are previous tests invalid once updates rollout and should the official testing be done every time there is update to Autopilot/FSD?
Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by mlindner on Monday August 15, 2022 @05:56AM (#32467734)
Here's more recent: https://twitter.com/WholeMarsBlog/status/1558876752062976000

The point is the video is likely faked. This is a well known feature that works in many examples of testing and is one of the things that's been working since forever. Detecting pedestrians was one of the first things they added before it was even called 'full self driving'.

Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by simion314 on Monday August 15, 2022 @05:54AM (#32467717)
Yes, sometimes is stops for train and trucks too, but some other times depending on lighting or who knows what it will drive you into a truck at full speed. And on top of that all old tests are invalid since new updates could change things. As long as the driver does it's job the human saves the FSD and you will never see publish by Elon the number of how many times the human saved the day.
Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by mlindner on Monday August 15, 2022 @05:58AM (#32467750)
> And on top of that all old tests are invalid since new updates could change things.

Convenient way of discarding any evidence you don't like.

> Yes, sometimes is stops for train and trucks too, but some other times depending on lighting or who knows what it will drive you into a truck at full speed.

Not sometimes, always. The only times it doesn't of note is what I would call "small overlap into lane" situations. By that I mean the vehicle is almost entirely out of the fixed lane lines on a highway, but a police vehicle is sitting partially into the lane to block the traffic which is something that they do sometimes. Some Teslas have apparently had issue with this which is why they're working to improve that. I haven't heard any recent events of it in the last month or so so it may be fixed by now.

Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by simion314 on Monday August 15, 2022 @06:37AM (#32467998)
>Convenient way of discarding any evidence you don't like.

I am sorry that reality and logic upsets you, after a software update you need to run tests again, the history of old tests does not guarantee anything useful.

Blah, blah, it only hits trucks if bullshit reasons, it should not hit giant solid objects ever.

Also what is the excuse for this one? https://www.thedrive.com/news/watch-as-teslas-autopilot-almo...

Last time the excuse was "that is normal, it is alpha software, it will be fixed in the next update". But if you read tesla subreddit you see people complaining that years old issues are still not fixed, like having issues with specific streets, road borders and similar.

Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by mlindner on Monday August 15, 2022 @06:40AM (#32468012)
> Also what is the excuse for this one? https://www.thedrive.com/news/watch-as-teslas-autopilot-almo...

That's not a child.

I never vouched for it's ability to avoid all possible objects. So I have no excuse.

> Last time the excuse was "that is normal, it is alpha software, it will be fixed in the next update". But if you read tesla subreddit you see people complaining that years old issues are still not fixed, like having issues with specific streets, road borders and similar.

This will be a thing for decades to come as we reach further and further into the number of 9s of reliability. We have 1 maybe 2 9s at this point of reliability and as you get rarer and rarer things there will always be specific instances where it doesn't work.

Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by simion314 on Monday August 15, 2022 @06:56AM (#32468094)
>This will be a thing for decades to come as we reach further and further into the number of 9s of reliability.

Cam you clarify? Tesla has 0.0 since they only have tested with a human driver + a driver assist that was marketed as FULL self driving. The Tesla numbers look similar with similar expensive cars that include drive assist. Tesla is not publishing the numbers when the human intervene or when the software gave up so your numbers are pulled out of Tesla PR or you mean something else(sorry for that but you are not clear).

Some organization can put Tesla to the test and record it traveling and count how man times it gave up and how many times the human intervene, when this number is zero in a few tousands test then you can claim Full Self Driving or Autopilot, until then you have a driver assist , that can keep lane in some conditions and stop for some objects or peole in soem conditions.

Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by mlindner on Monday August 15, 2022 @07:15AM (#32468238)
> Tesla has 0.0 since they only have tested with a human driver + a driver assist that was marketed as FULL self driving.

I'm not sure what you're saying. Are you saying you can't achieve 9s of reliability if it's not driving without a person in the seat? I wouldn't want a car with only 90% (one 9) reliability for example driving without a person in the seat.

> The Tesla numbers look similar with similar expensive cars that include drive assist.

I'm not personally aware of any general system that doesn't rely on geolocking that can do this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pf37o-cKOMs If you know of an example, I'm open to looking at it. (In the above video if you want to look at any scene without the fast forward there's a link to the raw footage in the video description.)

> Tesla is not publishing the numbers when the human intervene or when the software gave up so your numbers are pulled out of Tesla PR or you mean something else(sorry for that but you are not clear).

I'm not using any Tesla numbers for my above comment. I'm going off of first hand experiences of non-employees who drive using the system.

To be clear, the system is not in a state that I would pay the price that is being charged for it yet, personally. But it is a very good system at the top level in the industry at the moment and the best system you can actually buy (i.e. not based on a rental/taxi system like Waymo).

Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by simion314 on Monday August 15, 2022 @07:45AM (#32468434)
I am not attempting to sell you an alternative to Tesla, so I have no numbers of other company that is less shit then Tesla.

If thins are as great as yuu say then there is a mystery why Tesla is not publishing the all the numbers. Most FFSD users are extreme Tesla fans, because they paid and pass some checks from Tesla so it is obvious that this extreme fanboys will only praise Tesla, show only cool videos and hide the bad stuff or try to excuse it with bullshit like "it hits trucks only if they are white or parked half a road, and I never said it won't hit all objects".

Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by mlindner on Monday August 15, 2022 @08:06AM (#32468618)
> If thins are as great as yuu say then there is a mystery why Tesla is not publishing the all the numbers.

I think because frankly they would be misleading. Other self-driving car companies only publish their disengagement rates for areas that they actually rate as supporting (i.e. within geolocked areas). Tesla is tackling the entire country at the same time.

> Most FFSD users are extreme Tesla fans, because they paid and pass some checks from Tesla so it is obvious that this extreme fanboys will only praise Tesla, show only cool videos and hide the bad stuff or try to excuse it with bullshit like "it hits trucks only if they are white or parked half a road, and I never said it won't hit all objects".

Several people on youtube will set out to drive their regular drives to work, and go through the work of narrating it while driving. They're not going to drive to work multiple times going to the bother of narrating it each time just to end up not publishing it. Of course some people will selectively choose which videos to show when not narrating (likely what the example video I just showed did), but that doesn't mean the drive didn't happen.

Just note, if these drivers who post videos on youtube were crashing their Teslas they wouldn't be still posting videos. They're not being paid by Tesla.

> "it hits trucks only if they are white or parked half a road, and I never said it won't hit all objects".

I mentioned the parked in half the road because that was a legitimate problem that's been hitting the news in the last few months where they were a few cases of it hitting parked police cars that were partially in the lane. The collision avoidance system couldn't determine if the vehicle was in-lane or not because of the very small overlap.

Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by simion314 on Monday August 15, 2022 @09:51AM (#32469675)
>he collision avoidance system couldn't determine if the vehicle was in-lane or not because of the very small overlap.

And this some small glitch? This should not be the first problem you would solve, detect big objects, then you move to the next problem detect the object speeds, then you move to determine the objects next position.

It seems they did not solved the first essential problem yet.

Teslas hit cement lane separators, hit firetrucks, would have hit a tram/train, hot those small metal poles, dis-engaged in many regular city conditions. This tech is far from ready this decade - what I think it needs is better sensors that can detect solid objects or maybe 100 times more GPU power and 1000 times more training data.

The numbers are not public because it will show that the AI is less safe then a human, if it were close then for sure Tesla PR could have spin it in a good light for them.

Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by mlindner on Monday August 15, 2022 @11:53AM (#32471257)
> And this some small glitch? This should not be the first problem you would solve, detect big objects, then you move to the next problem detect the object speeds, then you move to determine the objects next position.

As far as I'm aware it was a regression (though I could be wrong), as it's a very rarely seen thing in reality and there was a sudden rash of news articles about it and then little since.

> It seems they did not solved the first essential problem yet.

That's not how neural networks work.

> The numbers are not public because it will show that the AI is less safe then a human, if it were close then for sure Tesla PR could have spin it in a good light for them.

Again, as I stated, it would result in the media comparing apples and oranges as Tesla does not restrict where you're allowed to drive. I'm sure if you took a Waymo to a snow covered dirt road in the winter time it wouldn't be able to drive at all so is that infinite dis-engagements?

> The numbers are not public because it will show that the AI is less safe then a human, if it were close then for sure Tesla PR could have spin it in a good light for them.

The released numbers show that at least where people drive with autopilot, there are less fatal incidents.

Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by simion314 on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @02:49AM (#32479906)
>As far as I'm aware it was a regression (though I could be wrong), as it's a very rarely seen thing in reality and there was a sudden rash of news articles about it and then little since.

This can be because the "bad press" made it that the human driver also pays attention, if we would have access to all the data I am 100% sure we will find daily cases where the human prevents this frontal colission with trucks, trains and walls to happen.

How can it be a regression? Any official explanation from a Tesla engineer? Did they had some bad detection and some dude decided to change some parameter values or was this blamed on the AI? I am super curious to read this, if it was on HN I missed it.

>That's not how neural networks work.

I know how ANN work, but good engineers always use best tool for the job and split a big problem in smaller independent problems, it is easy to developer and test. I assume the fault is with people above that rush the engineers and force them to work with impossible constraints.

>Again, as I stated, it would result in the media comparing apples and oranges as Tesla does not restrict where you're allowed to drive. I'm sure if you took a Waymo to a snow covered dirt road in the winter time it wouldn't be able to drive at all so is that infinite dis-engagements?

This makes no sense dude, you are trying to hard to bend logic. Tesla can show numbers limited to a city or a road. Let me think for you and Tesla PR

"On the road from A to B, 25km of heavy traffic, 500k cars daily, Tesla had 3 dis-engagements daily but the same number of humans in similar cars cause in average 5 accidents on this exact road and conditions".

If the data is precise and correct and shows Tesla is better then humans then it would be public, if Waymo can do better then good for them.

Though I would prefer Tesla would publish data for theentire city not only one street.

Btw I notice how you Tesla and Apple fans defend the giant companies with shit like "the press will say mean things" or "some bad customer will sabotage the device" or "some idiot might do idiotic things and go to the press so let's remove your rights".

The press did a good job to show that the AI can't be trusted and probably saved lives. This would not have been needed if Tesla would not have used false advertising.

Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by kaba0 on Monday August 15, 2022 @07:34AM (#32468353)
> I never vouched for it's ability to avoid all possible objects

Well, that’s the lowest of the low requirement for any form of FSD, that my robot vacuum passes. Should I call Tesla that by buying some cheap chinese robot vacuum company, they could reuse their software stack?

Re:It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children by kaba0 on Monday August 15, 2022 @07:32AM (#32468340)
> Convenient way of discarding any evidence you don't like.

In a black box algorithm this is quite literally the case.

Even in just regular programming, you ain’t claiming that master is correct just because the previous relase’s CI pipeline is all green, do you?

Car tests are stable when they only test hardware - once software is in the picture, they are all invalid instantly.