Re:Man who robbed bank to get his own money back hailed as n...
by jimmaswell on Saturday August 13, 2022 @09:53PM
(#32455614)
French Revolution?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Man who robbed bank to get his own money back hailed as n...
by jesushax on Saturday August 13, 2022 @10:53PM
(#32455921)
Which famously resulted in the Reign of Terror (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reign_of_Terror) before collapsing into Napoleon's imperial dictatorship.
Re:Man who robbed bank to get his own money back hailed as n...
by jacquesm on Saturday August 13, 2022 @11:27PM
(#32456056)
Which in the longer run benefited France quite a bit. It's hard to immediately judge whether something is beneficial or not. See also the 'We'll see' parable.
Re:Man who robbed bank to get his own money back hailed as n...
by guerrilla on Sunday August 14, 2022 @12:58AM
(#32456479)
And what happened after that? You're not being serious if you just end there. Liberal democracy, capitalism and the metric system in most of the world...
Re:Man who robbed bank to get his own money back hailed as n...
by Tyrek on Sunday August 14, 2022 @02:01AM
(#32456808)
Are you implying that the Napoleonic wars, all of the resulting politics, etc. are the natural result of revolution? That the revolutionary ideal requires military defeat in order to reach a positive end state?
You're not being serious if you end there.
Re:Man who robbed bank to get his own money back hailed as n...
by guerrilla on Sunday August 14, 2022 @07:31AM
(#32458393)
No. I'm stating that the world today depended on the French Revolution happening.
Re:Man who robbed bank to get his own money back hailed as n...
by sdoering on Sunday August 14, 2022 @02:07AM
(#32456824)
The question is if these ideas, already in place would have come to fruition without the suffering of people up front. We just can't know. I remember a similar discussion with my history professor and us students when talking about the French Revolution and about the Enlightenment. We basically have only one history and are not able to state that the French Revolution was the cause for these good ideas to follow. We couldn't even state it as a catalyst with certainty.
Edit: Typo
Re:Man who robbed bank to get his own money back hailed as n...
by guerrilla on Sunday August 14, 2022 @07:32AM
(#32458395)
> The question is if these ideas, already in place would have come to fruition without the suffering of people up front
Of course not. Those in power don't just willingly give it up.
Re:Man who robbed bank to get his own money back hailed as n...
by kevin_thibedeau on Saturday August 13, 2022 @11:28PM
(#32456060)
They're on their 5th constitution so not exactly a resounding success.
Re:Man who robbed bank to get his own money back hailed as n...
by anigbrowl on Sunday August 14, 2022 @03:55AM
(#32457369)
Not a meaningful metric. Changing when you need to change is a good thing. One could just as easily argue that the US elevation of its original constitution into a quasi-religious document has a lot to do with the country's current dysfunction.
Re:Man who robbed bank to get his own money back hailed as n...
by aaaaaaaaata on Sunday August 14, 2022 @06:43AM
(#32458174)
If the US was actually interested in following the document, you might be able to make that argument.
Re:Man who robbed bank to get his own money back hailed as n...
by sofixa on Sunday August 14, 2022 @03:18AM
(#32457202)
I don't think the country realising it's mistakes and trying a different thing is all that bad. Compared to the American model where the constitution ia considered as the word of god and it cannot be touch, i know which one i prefer.
Re:Man who robbed bank to get his own money back hailed as n...
by bobthepanda on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @08:06PM
(#32503500)
Technically the current US one is the second.
Re:Man who robbed bank to get his own money back hailed as n...
by travisgriggs on Saturday August 13, 2022 @10:48PM
(#32455895)
Which one?