We are participants in those decisions, on both sides. We are part of the targets of those decisions (eg domestic spying, provision of military equipment to local and regional police forces), as well as tacit supporters of those decisions (or do you think an American civilian can travel the world without being blamed for those mistakes? I have heard of a lot of Canadian flags being added to travel luggage...).
Our tax money pays to kill children in deserts. Our tax money pays to destabilize governments. Our parents and children and brothers and sisters who ARE veterans directly participate in executing those bad decisions. And then many of them commit suicide. My father shot himself three years ago, near his 50th anniversary of shipping out to Vietnam, because of the mistakes he was part of there and later which stayed with him for so many decades. I don't think our second-guessing of those decisions taken in our name is at all inappropriate.
> Yeah, a lot of mistakes have been made. Many of them will continue to be made.
There must be a threshold of "too many" or "too heinous" mistakes at which point one stops trying to improve an organization and instead withdraws support, right? Otherwise it may as well be a religion.
> It’s simple to sit there behind the desk...
Most of DoD employees, including enlisted men, sit behind desks most of the day.
The military is an excellent welfare institution. One of the limited forms of socially celebrated welfare in a lot of the United States, like the South.
Theres a lot of Palestinians subjected to war crimes that aren't very excited about the same US military action
There have been several successful actions, but we’re talking about the net impact not specific instances.
We outspend every other country by a lot, including China and Russia combined... and then the next three added on top. We are not the only world power who has a moral obligation to keep the world safe, if that is what you say we are doing.
I say this as the son of an Army veteran who died to 5 different cancers caused from agent orange, only 3 of which would the VA cover after we fought (hard) with them. And the cousin to a Navy admiral whose almost up to his 25 years.
The fact of the matter is the US is one of only 3 powers that can help maintain a stable world order, that reduces piracy, stops things like ISIS, and helps keep megolmanical dictators like Kim Jung Un in check.
You can argue other countries should be willing to contribute to that, but they don't. So those are your options China, Russia, or the US. You let me know which one you'd prefer, because as much as you don't like it those are your choices.
As for the EU, why would they meet their obligations when they could spend their money elsewhere? They're the fat 30 year old bachelor playing video games in their parents spare bedroom because they were never forced to leave. The US needs to take a step back and make them pay their own check at some point. It's time for the adults in the room to start adulting.
Unless you think China should regime change North Korea and risk the death and displacement of millions of people?
If they could get Kim out without massive disaster then they would have done it yesterday. He causes them a lot of issues and they have been very reluctant to help him - they would have been well within their rights to, for example, veto all sanctions against North Korea.
N. Korea's population and military would have broken away long ago under such conditions without some outside support.
It's very very well documented that the Chinese are incredibly displeased with Kim Jong Un. Plenty of retired generals talk and write about it.
NK's population and military breaking away without outside support is far from guaranteed to bring a better outcome for anyone. It's not clear to me a military dictatorship is going to be less brutal or repressive than the Kims and it's not clear either that the population could ever break from the yoke of the military should the Kims lose power.
Among those purposes is to ensure that dictators maintain power and can torture their citizens, to ensure that american companies have control over said countries natural resources and pollute the environment with impunity.
To like the American military is the same as to like the american police. Sure, beating up random black people is good for somebody, but that doesn't mean that there isn't good in not beating up random black people.
Otherwise the actions of the US Military and intelligence services would be much different, with longer term consequences thought through and impacts on peoples lives taken into broader consideration.
To me, it looks like the hope is actually maintaining financial control of the resources of other nations. Every action I see indicates that.
But the US is hardly alone in this respect either, just the most recent example.
Those damn soviets would have won if we didn’t torture US citizens.
Yeah, a lot of mistakes have been made. Many of them will continue to be made. The hope is that we still leave the world better off than it was before.
Inaction can lead to just as bad a result, if not worse, than taking an educated action at all. It’s simple to sit there behind the desk reading articles and history when you’re not one making the decisions, good or bad.