Yes. These nuclear weapons were a more efficient way of obliterating a city through fire: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Tokyo_(10_March_194...
It turns out that if you drop thousands of tons of incendiaries on a city made from wood and paper, you can kill a really large number of people at once.
We can re-litigate these questions, but I'm not sure we'll reach any answers. A more salient one is "how can we prevent this from ever happening again?" including "how can we prevent states from launching wars of aggression?"
All sides are probably at least a little wrong here, and ultimately, it probably boils down to a feud between Russia and various aspects of the West going at least back to the Crimean war, if not earlier, and the back and forth animosity that has perpetuated the cycle over that time. Perhaps the question then isn't "how can we prevent launching wars of aggression," but rather "how can we successfully reach an agreement where all sides agree to finally bury the hatchet."
As long as we refuse to consider the longer cycle of revenge and posturing at play we'll likely continue to be confused in the face of it perpetuating itself.
I think the simple answer is that before the scale of Hiroshima was really understood, everyone though of it as mostly just a more efficient way to perform the atrocity that they were already doing. On this point check out Wellersteins earlier text on the 67:th anniversary: http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2012/08/06/hiroshima-at-67-th...