News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why does anything exist? by jiggawatts on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @05:39PM (#32418788)
> our universe requires a "sustaining cause" (as with a picture on a TV set).

The movie doesn't cease to exist because you turned the television off, only the projection of it into those particular photons.

Top Gun will continue to exist even if you break every Blu Ray of it into tiny pieces, crush those pieces to powder, and melt the result into a formless goo.

Movies are purely information, a sequence of bits. Those bits can have manifestations such as copies on a hard drive, blu ray, or whatever. The bit sequence doesn't stop existing just because we delete every manifestation. A sequence of bits is just a very big number, and all numbers continue to exist whether we write them down or not. We can discover specific interesting numbers, such as the number 'T' that is the H.264 encoding of the Top Gun Blu Ray movie. It is 40 billion bits long, but it's still just a number. It has adjacent numbers, integer factors, and everything.

Here's the thing: the number 'T' existed before Tom Cruise was born. It existed before the evolution of humanity and will exist after the heat death of physical universe. It exists independent of time. It didn't come into existence at any point in time, or "before" time, or any nonsense like that.

Similarly, if[1] you believe that the universe follows strict, mathematical laws of physics[2], then you can imagine it as pure information, like a Mandelbrot set. Fractals in fact might be a very good analogy. They're actually very simple things, exist independent of time, and yet can produce intricate detail if you look closely. That detail may appear chaotic, but "seems" to follow oddly consistent rules, much like physics.

So this is my point of view: The Universe is "just" mathematics, and mathematics exists independent of time, making the Universe necessary. As in-universe observers, we're part of the mathematics, not any particular manifestation or representation of it. Even if there were some sort of God scribbling the bits down on a napkin that represent the state of the Universe, he's discovering the numbers, not creating them. If he destroys the napkin, the bits will not cease to exist. Inside the universe, we would never know anything had occurred.[3]

[1] Granted, this is a "if"!

[2] The more we know about the universe, the more this seems to be true.

[3] This entire point of view is the main theme of the book Diaspora by Greg Egan, which I highly recommend.

Re:Why does anything exist? by sras-me on Thursday August 11, 2022 @09:34AM (#32425320)
>The Universe is "just" mathematics..

I have come to this conclusion as well. It came to be when I was looking at a fractal animation, and it appeared that things moved in it as if obeying some laws of physics.

I have expanded on this idea here, and have described a sort of thought expiriment where I try to "prove" this. You probably not want to read it. It is not very well written.

https://sras.me/the-root-of-all-existence.html

Later I came across Max Tegmark's paper, which describes the same thing..

https://arxiv.org/pdf/0704.0646.pdf

Re:Why does anything exist? by awinder on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @07:40PM (#32419850)
The h264 movie Top Gun is purely information, but it’s also derivative and with information loss, right?

From our perception at least, it seems like Tom and Val were a part of the earliest & highest fidelity information that makes up Top Gun when they were part of shooting it day to day. Or somewhere around there, the movie that the h264 derives from requires daily shots + editing/effects etc. If Tom & Val are in-universe observers, then wtf happened during those shooting days, and in their argument I’d imagine, the ideas & experiences they’d had on how they portrayed their parts?

Re:Why does anything exist? by prmph on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @06:01PM (#32418979)
Interesting point of view, but a few caveats:

- I don't think it can be taken for granted that math exists independent of consciousness to think of it.

- Even if math exists independent of time and consciousness, it need not have a physical manifestation (by your own logic). So why does a physical universe have to exist?

Re:Why does anything exist? by thethirdone on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @06:31PM (#32419252)
Why do you assume the physical universe is a manifestation?

The Mandelbrot set exists and contains self reference without any need for it to be graphed (a manifestation). Similarly the universe as we experience it may exist without any physical manifestation.

Re:Why does anything exist? by jiggawatts on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @06:23PM (#32419173)
Physics is the equation, not a scribble of one on a dead tree.
Re:Why does anything exist? by booleandilemma on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @07:25PM (#32419740)
> Top Gun will continue to exist even if you break every Blu Ray of it into tiny pieces

If you destroy every recording of Top Gun, it will cease to exist.

> The bit sequence doesn't stop existing just because we delete every manifestation

Yes it does.

And Top Gun didn't exist before 1986.

Re:Why does anything exist? by anthk on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @08:20PM (#32420105)
The concept of Pi and the irrationality of sqrt(2) predates the universe itself. Think about it.
Re:Why does anything exist? by erklik on Thursday August 11, 2022 @12:49AM (#32421703)
> The concept of Pi and the irrationality of sqrt(2) predates the universe itself. Think about it.

How? Get rid of the universe, and the concept of pi doesn't exist. Pi is the ratio of a circle's circumference to it's diameter. Circles didn't exist before the universe, thus no pi. There could be another universe where circles are impossible due to whatever laws of physics exist, thus no pi.

Re:Why does anything exist? by hackerlight on Thursday August 11, 2022 @02:29AM (#32422242)
> There could be another universe where circles are impossible due to whatever laws of physics exist, thus no pi.

Circles (perfect ones) are impossible in our universe, too. Circles are abstractions. If we have successfully deduced a conclusion from a set of axioms, wouldn't that deduction hold true in all possible universes?

The mathematical realist position is that these abstract math objects exist independent of an observer.

Re:Why does anything exist? by anthk on Thursday August 11, 2022 @06:31AM (#32423741)
This. Circles are just the set of all the infinite points from any point covering any degree around you having the same distance. That's why Pi it's infinite on decimals.

Ditto with sqrt(2), you need to "sharpen" the triangle made from half an square forever in order to get all the decimals.

Re:Why does anything exist? by hackerlight on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @10:32PM (#32420900)
We stop knowing about it, but it still exists. It's just a number. You can't delete a number from existence, you can just delete your copy of it.
Re:Why does anything exist? by booleandilemma on Thursday August 11, 2022 @07:34AM (#32424168)
Numbers don't exist in the first place. It's like saying unicorns exist. They're a shared fiction. (A highly useful fiction, to be sure)

I've noticed people in this thread are getting actual, physical things confused with concepts and mental representations of things.

Confusing the map for the territory.

Re:Why does anything exist? by hackerlight on Thursday August 11, 2022 @08:43AM (#32424808)
So you hold the Fictionalism view and reject Platonism. That's fine. This stuff has been debated ad nauseam and we're not going to break any new ground here.

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/fictionalism-mathematics/

> It's like saying unicorns exist. They're a shared fiction. (A highly useful fiction, to be sure)

I will mention that dogs are also a useful shared fiction. We assign the label dog to a perception of a configuration of atoms that we think satisfy the criteria for what a dog is. So I'd say that numbers are more like dogs than unicorns, in that they are an abstraction that is used by us in practice to map to perceptions of physical objects.

Re:Why does anything exist? by booleandilemma on Thursday August 11, 2022 @12:35PM (#32428249)
Thanks! I didn't have a word for this. I guess I'm a fictionalist :)
Re:Why does anything exist? by satori99 on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @10:31PM (#32420896)
Top Gun still exists in the minds of everyone who has seen it. It is an idea as well as a performance. And you don't need to consume any particular encoding of the performance to continue to either enjoy or hate it. Art is weird like that.
Re:Why does anything exist? by booleandilemma on Thursday August 11, 2022 @07:32AM (#32424155)
Top Gun won't exist, just people's memories of Top Gun.

And memory is fallible. It changes over time. People will all remember the movie differently.

The memory of Top Gun != Top Gun.

Re:Why does anything exist? by arrow7000 on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @05:47PM (#32418862)
Diaspora is an extraordinary book and I second your recommendation, but I didn't think of that as one of its primary themes. Although it does fit.