News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by notch656a on Monday August 08, 2022 @08:46PM (#32392893)
I strongly believe there is probable cause to be found that Trump committed crimes, but I can't help but ask if these hunts against former presidents are positive for the future peace and prosperity of America.
Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by kmos17 on Monday August 08, 2022 @09:25PM (#32393173)
Making sure no one is above the law is a cornerstone of our legal system, so I would argue it is in fact essential. Of course this is assuming there must be really strong probable cause in this case.
Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by notch656a on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @12:43AM (#32394231)
If "being above the law" is discretionary prosecution and investigation letting some people off the hook, then it actually is for good or ill a cornerstone of our legal system. FBI has broad discretionary ability to pick and choose who to go after, and ensuring that is done in a uniform and politically unbiased way could arguably trump priority of any particular person being prosecuted.

It may be the case this is not politically motivated. But were there cases where investigations are politically motivated, I would much rather see those people get away than political bias of investigatory agencies being used to undermine democratic system, even if the criminals themselves were also undermining the democratic system.

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by kadoban on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @12:58AM (#32394320)
If our leaders can break the law without consequence, it undermines everything. The rich and powerful in the US need to be under _more_ scrutiny, not less.
Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by hackerlight on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:06AM (#32395349)
Two things are independently bad: (1) politically biased enforcement, and (2) powerful politicians not being accountable for crimes committed.

Ideally we can avoid (2) without committing (1), but concerns about (1) shouldn't be brushed aside.

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by notch656a on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @01:00AM (#32394329)
There was definitely consequences. Trump was voted out of office as a result of the various crimes the people witnessed. Also there was an impeachment that failed to convict.

Also I'm not sure the prosecution of any particular individual necessarily outweighs the need to keep our justice system politically unbiased. Again I'd much prefer people go free rather than FBI and other agencies being used in a politically biased manner to undermine democracy. I'm not saying that is what is happening here, although it could be the case.

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by kadoban on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @01:08AM (#32394360)
> Trump was voted out of office as a result of the various crimes the people witnessed.

That's not enough. If it's all just politics, then it's part of the game. We need law enforcement to stand up and do their job. "Some people are pretty sure I'm a criminal" isn't the same thing as a court of law saying it.

> Also there was an impeachment that failed to convict.

That's barely a consequence. It did essentially nothing.

> Also I'm not sure the prosecution of any particular individual necessarily outweighs the need to keep our justice system politically unbiased.

The justice system isn't seen as politically unbiased by the people who will yell about Trump getting prosecuted anyway. If they're going to cry bias regardless, let's drag the evidence into a court of law and shine some sunlight on it.

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by notch656a on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @01:20AM (#32394419)
I understand the desire for criminals to face their crimes.

The fact that this happens in the recent aftermath of the election of the leader of the executive branch, under which the FBI is contained, against his adversary just leaves a very politically charged taste in my mouth. I wish this were applied uniformly. Pretty much all presidents have likely committed crimes so I'd at least like to see them serve warrants against Obama for his approval of drone strikes that killed children and Bush for orchestrating the lying about WMDs in Iraq and subsequent carnage. Hopefully we can use Rico charges to put all current living presidents in jail, all the way up to Biden.

It seems all too convenient and politically motivated that only the adversary of FBI's branch of government has a warrant issued. This kind of targeted attack while ignoring war crimes of former presidents IMO is even worse than no justice at all, because it creates a precedent for political targeting.

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by kadoban on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @01:31AM (#32394487)
> The fact that this happens in the recent aftermath of the election of the leader of the executive branch, under which the FBI is contained, against his adversary who is now being elected just leaves a very politically charged taste in my mouth.

In practice, that's pretty close to just saying no President should ever be investigated.

> Pretty much all presidents have likely committed crimes [...]

I would definitely be in favor of a special prosecutor being set up to investigate the current President, every time. Let's not wait until they're out of office.

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by notch656a on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @01:48AM (#32394585)
>In practice, that's pretty close to just saying no President should ever be investigated.

It would be if you missed my context, which is about applying this in a non-uniform way. That is if FBI goes after both Obama as a bomber of children and Trump as a <whatever the warrant was for>, then it would lend a little more credence towards a true effort to work in an unbiased fashion. Purely going after your adversary but none of the warcrimes of other presidents just comes off as politically motivated. Maybe it's not, but it certainly seems quite possible. Again IMO it undermines the nation more to convict people for political motivation rather than it does to let some criminals go free. If the option is politically motivated prosecution or none at all I would definitely prefer "none being investigated" -- but I think that would be a false dichotomy.

>I would definitely be in favor of a special prosecutor being set up to investigate the current President, every time. Let's not wait until they're out of office.

I mean that already exists, it's called congress, and they didn't convict Trump.

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by kadoban on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:27AM (#32394824)
> It would be if you missed my context, which is about applying this in a non-uniform way. That is if FBI goes after both Obama as a bomber of children and Trump as a <whatever the warrant was for>

I don't know of any actual US crimes that Obama is legitimately suspected of. War actions are generally treated quite differently compared to non-war actions. With all likelihood, the US drone campaign is only evil, not illegal.

The FBIs actions here are uniform exactly because there is probable cause enough to start an investigation of Trump and not of Obama. What actual crime would Obama be investigated for, and what warrant would be gotten?

A search warrant was issued for Trump because he _already_ was caught keeping classified documents that he wasn't allowed to keep, and whatever followup they're doing based on that.

> > I would definitely be in favor of a special prosecutor being set up to investigate the current President, every time. Let's not wait until they're out of office.

> I mean that already exists, it's called congress, and they didn't convict Trump.

Congress isn't primarily an investigative body, they're not special prosecutors, they cannot charge people with crimes, and they cannot do a whole bunch of things that actual law enforcement can. Also, impeachment only has two possible punishments, removal from office and forbidding future office.

They also kind of suck in general at being non-political, by nature of how Congress works. For example, the J6 committee investigation really should have been a special prosecutor of some sort, but they couldn't get it done because the Republicans simply refused.

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by notch656a on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:58AM (#32394980)
>I don't know of any actual US crimes that Obama is legitimately suspected of. War actions are generally treated quite differently compared to non-war actions. With all likelihood, the US drone campaign is only evil, not illegal.

18 U.S. Code § 2441. Not enough to convict, but definitely enough for PC. If an agent claiming a dog sniffing me was enough for a federal judge to serve a search warrant against me (true story), then by uniformity principle an order followed by blown up dead droned kids should be enough PC to investigate Obama.

>A search warrant was issued for Trump because he _already_ was caught keeping classified documents that he wasn't allowed to keep, and whatever followup they're doing based on that.

Sure again I don't doubt there was PC to get a warrant for Trump involving something. Again the issue is the possibility of using criminal system for targeted political persecution, in this case of the immediate historical adversary of the sitting lead of the branch in which the FBI sits.

>Congress isn't primarily an investigative body, they're not special prosecutors, they cannot charge people with crimes, and they cannot do a whole bunch of things that actual law enforcement can. Also, impeachment only has two possible punishments, removal from office and forbidding future office.

>They also kind of suck in general at being non-political, by nature of how Congress works. For example, the J6 committee investigation really should have been a special prosecutor of some sort, but they couldn't get it done because the Republicans simply refused.

Point taken, I can see the merits you note here and agree a less political system could be useful for investigating presidents.

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by kadoban on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:50AM (#32395269)
> 18 U.S. Code § 2441. Not enough to convict, but definitely enough for PC.

I don't really see it, but I'm not a lawyer either. Either way, I'd be very fine with it being investigated.

> If an agent claiming a dog sniffing me was enough for a federal judge to serve a search warrant against me (true story)

Ugh, sorry that happened to you. The war on drugs has been just the worst thing for law enforcement in this country.

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by Dylan16807 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:57AM (#32395305)
> There was definitely consequences. Trump was voted out of office as a result of the various crimes the people witnessed.

The election was too close to know if it even made a difference at all, let alone count as definite consequences.

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by cmurf on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:44PM (#32404754)
Being above the law is less like discretion, and more like a pardon. If you know something is prosecutable, but you decide not to on the basis of the person (being more important than accountability), you're pardoning.
Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by notch656a on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @12:56PM (#32415118)
Discretion isn't just about the subject but also about greater society and even the one investigating. Sometimes a fleeing traffic violator are let go not because they individually are somehow worthy but so that a chase doesn't result in greater risk to innocents. Sometimes a cop walks away from a riot because he'll get his ass beat if he tries to seek justice. Sometimes a brutal dictator is allowed to walk away into exile in the interest of greater peace of society. It's not as simple as you say "on the basis of the person."
[dead]
Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by hvl2 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @06:33AM (#32396087)
Care to explain?
[dead]
Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by effingwewt on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:02PM (#32403459)
Oh come on now, this didn't survive a one second google search[1],[2],[3],[4],and their search us terrible.

No wonder my bullshit meter was going off.

[1] https://www.texastribune.org/2022/02/01/henry-cuellar-fbi-ra...

[2] https://www.forbes.com/sites/joewalsh/2021/09/16/former-demo...

[3] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-california-yee/california...

[4] https://www.tallahassee.com/story/news/local/fbi/2022/06/22/...

Etc ad infinitum.

Edit formatting

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by anigbrowl on Monday August 08, 2022 @08:57PM (#32392983)
South Korea seems to be doing OK despite being ahead of the US in this particular domain.
Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by yongjik on Monday August 08, 2022 @10:46PM (#32393754)
Yep, South Korea sent four ex-presidents to prison (three were pardoned, one is still in prison). It's not a perfect solution (obviously we'd prefer if we had presidents who didn't commit crimes), but I think it's a net positive. Surprisingly, when you throw an ex-president in jail, the society doesn't break down. The stock market barely even notices.
Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by joezydeco on Monday August 08, 2022 @09:14PM (#32393096)
All we can hope is that we keep enough people with integrity and apolitical viewpoints as a buffer between the political parties and the White House.

This raid was certainly signed off by Christopher Wray, the director of the FBI.

Wray was appointed by Trump.

Feel free to call it a witch hunt, but you don't go into a warrant like this unless you are fairly certain of the outcome.

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by notch656a on Monday August 08, 2022 @09:20PM (#32393133)
I just hope this doesn't turn into a trolley problem where one side of the tracks is justice dying and the other side is mass violence and instability.
[dead]
Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by joezydeco on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @09:58AM (#32398014)
"and we have seen time and time again that they're fishing expeditions which achieve nothing"

You sure about that? There are at least eight Trump administration individuals convicted of crimes because of those "fishing expeditions", with many more under indictment. And there are others that are still in contempt of congressional subpoenas.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-trump-bannon-associat...

And I think it's been made really clear that you don't get permits for "fishing expeditions" easily. It needs approval on many levels, including judges and magistrates installed by both parties.

Funny thing, these "fishing expeditions" have been deployed against Democratic officials but come out with way less indictments and convictions. How many hours of testimony did Clinton sit down for over Bengazhi? 11? Did that result in anything? Why not?

Oh yeah, and she showed up when subpoenaed.

The party of "law and order" needs to put up or shut up.

(PS: If this search of Mar-A-Lago was an abuse of power, Trump is more than free to release a copy of the warrant which shows exactly what the FBI was searching for. Let's see if that happens.)

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by klyrs on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @12:30PM (#32400164)
The irony here is that the FBI has been going after activists on the left for decades, and only goes after those on the right in the most egregiously extreme cases. So here, we've got trump flagrantly breaking the law and bragging about it on tv for years and when the FBI finally gets off its ass that's "persecution."

Dude operates like a mob boss, or a New York Democrat. Eventually, they're gonna come after you.

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by hvl2 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @06:35AM (#32396095)
Examples of similar raids?
Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by codefreeordie on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:58PM (#32402372)
I tried to give examples, but apparently giving examples just gets your posts deleted.
Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by codefreeordie on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @11:35AM (#32399384)
https://thehill.com/opinion/judiciary/3594107-the-mar-a-lago...

This article shows a barrage of Democrats not raided on similar warrants and a whole slew of Republicans raided on similarly-flimsy ground.

It's simple: the FBI is the enforcement arm of the democratic party, and it operates transparently as such. It is in no way a legitimate law enforcement agency.l, and performs no legitimate function.

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by joezydeco on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @10:04AM (#32412140)
I think it's noble that you wish for equality. We all do.

Let's hope you press for the same in all other aspects of your life and your vote at the ballot box. Vote for the candidates that work to represent everyone and not just wealthy white males.

Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by hotpotamus on Monday August 08, 2022 @09:26PM (#32393176)
I'm going to suggest that to the police next time I commit a crime.
Re:FBI Searches Trump’s Home in Florida by klyrs on Monday August 08, 2022 @10:39PM (#32393699)
Is this a hunt? There is already a large body of evidence that he attempted to destroy records that he was legally obligated to keep, and quite a few credible claims that he succeeded by flushing records down the toilet. To say nothing of the emoluments clause.

Trump was entrusted with the highest office of the land, and flagrantly violated the laws and his oaths. At the head of the party that consistently claims that "law and order" is a guiding principle, bringing him to justice should be a no-brainer, right?