News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by DennisP on Monday August 08, 2022 @05:06PM (#32391007)
Meanwhile a hammer was used to bash someone's head in.
Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by viro on Monday August 08, 2022 @05:09PM (#32391039)
what use outside of money laundering did this tool have?
Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by carlosdp on Monday August 08, 2022 @05:13PM (#32391083)
Having private transactions using a public blockchain ledger.

It's the same as asking "why do people need E2E encrypted chat," because they want to and there's nothing wrong with them not wanting you to read their chats, that's why.

Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by xur17 on Monday August 08, 2022 @05:17PM (#32391127)
100% this. I use ETH, USDC, etc to pay friends back for a trip, in much the same way that one would use Venmo or cash. I'd love to be able to do this without showing the recipient ALL of my other crypto transactions, and as such have seriously considered using Tornado Cash in the past (but haven't because of fears of exchanges blacklisting my address).
Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by ajross on Monday August 08, 2022 @05:25PM (#32391229)
> Having private transactions using a public blockchain ledger.

The question was what other use the tool had. "Private transactions" are 100% isomorphic to money laundering, the only difference is the words you use to explain it.

In fact, "private transactions" are, in fact illegal. You're not allowed to do that in the industrialized world. It's true that small-value cash transactions are de facto private, in the sense that the government decides to look the other way and focus its laundering enforcement on larger players.

But no, that ship sailed decades ago. You're not allowed to have private transactions, because if you have them then the criminals will, and we as a society have made a bargain to give them up to reduce crime and corruption.

Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by DennisP on Monday August 08, 2022 @05:36PM (#32391360)
> Money laundering refers to a financial transaction scheme that aims to conceal the identity, source, and destination of illicitly-obtained money.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/money_laundering

It's not just "private transactions."

Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by ajross on Monday August 08, 2022 @05:48PM (#32391513)
And exactly as I said, the words you use to explain it may differ, but the action does not. You can't have "private transactions" in the sense you imagine. They aren't legal. They haven't been legal in the United States for a half century since the Bank Secrecy Act of 1970.
Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by DennisP on Monday August 08, 2022 @06:00PM (#32391645)
From what I can tell, the BSA does not prohibit a private individual from paying a large sum of cash to another private individual. It simply adds reporting requirements to businesses.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_Secrecy_Act

If you know a specific provision of any law that does prohibit such transactions, please post a link.

Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by ajross on Monday August 08, 2022 @06:31PM (#32391944)
This is so frustrating to argue. I genuinely don't understand how you think circles like this will ever lead back to "huge private transactions are totally valid".

Where exactly do you expect to get that "large sum of cash" except from a bank? (Or conversely, what is the recipient expected to do with it except deposit it?) You're right that the enforcement of the law focuses on the entities (banks and other financial actors) who manage large transactions. If you had an "individual" doing that sort of thing regularly[1], you should absolutely expect to seem them regulated under AML statues.

What you want you can't have. You don't have it now. You won't have it in the crypto future. We've decided to make what you want illegal, and no amount of arguing on HN is going to change that.

[1] Like, for example, an operator of a money laundering tool on the ethereum network.

Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by DennisP on Monday August 08, 2022 @07:20PM (#32392334)
Ok but you're making unsourced claims again. I'm just asking for a source. You mentioned the BSA before, and when I looked it up it didn't seem to apply.

There are people who occasionally sell expensive things for cash, and people who keep a lot of cash in safes. My claim is that those activities are legal. You have not provided a statute or regulation saying it's illegal.

(There's no way for me to reference a statute for my claim, because we write laws saying what's prohibited, not what's allowed.)

Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by ajross on Monday August 08, 2022 @07:38PM (#32392440)
> There are people who occasionally sell expensive things for cash

There are not, not in practice. And to the extent there are they they do so by converting that cash to traceable assets in banks subject to know-your-customer rules who are able to attest to the validity of those transactions. To the extent that you have private entities doing very large, regular cash transactions that are not visible to AML regulators, that practice is not presumptively legal (nor common, except for literal criminals). You know this. I know you know this. Just ask a lawyer if you think you could get away with that. You can't.

Hiding behind a "if this and this and this were true then you could evade AML rules" as a technicality (effectively: that there are edge cases not covered under existing statutes) is not arguing for the legality of the kind of pervasive laundering enabled by a crypto mixer, and you know it.

Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by DennisP on Monday August 08, 2022 @07:46PM (#32392495)
I never claimed it was legal for "regular" large transactions, which would imply the person is in business. I do claim it's perfectly legal for occasional, large personal transactions. (Of course it's also legal for regular small transactions.)

But I'll quit since it's clear you're not going to reference any sort of law saying this is illegal.

Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by carlosdp on Monday August 08, 2022 @06:05PM (#32391707)
What are you talking about my dude, every transaction you do with cash is inherently "private". Nobody is tracking your identity to that transaction.

This is just a digital form of that.

Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by acdha on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @12:25PM (#32400093)
It seems different from end to end encryption in a key way: we need things like TLS because sending a message unavoidably requires network traffic to traverse networks outside of your control. In contrast, using cryptocurrency is a choice to use a system modeled on the wrong data structure for either privacy or efficiency. Trying to kludge privacy on top of that seems like a very expensive and highly risky alternative to acknowledging that the system is incorrectly architected for the problem.
Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by kevingadd on Monday August 08, 2022 @05:22PM (#32391194)
That is a reason to launder money, it's still money laundering. It's valid to believe that this justifies money laundering and to believe that money laundering should be legal, but it is what it is.
Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by carlosdp on Monday August 08, 2022 @06:07PM (#32391724)
Money laundering is the act of hiding the source of funds from *illegal activity*, all my funds that I want to privately transact with are legitimately earned.
Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by viro on Monday August 08, 2022 @07:21PM (#32392340)
prove it
Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by c0nducktr on Monday August 08, 2022 @10:53PM (#32393792)
Yes, "prove you're not guilty of a crime", a classic phrase used in free societies.
Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by carlosdp on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:33PM (#32404633)
I know this is a troll, but Tornado Cash literally provides a frontend that lets you prove where funds came from / went to auditors and law enforcement.
Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by capableweb on Monday August 08, 2022 @05:20PM (#32391171)
What use cases does E2E encryption have besides hiding criminal activities from law enforcement? Exactly the same goes here. As long as you're not doing illegal things and file your taxes, everything should be perfectly fine.
Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by ShaneMcGowan on Monday August 08, 2022 @05:11PM (#32391051)
Anonymising the purchase of hammers
Re:GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account by froh_away on Monday August 08, 2022 @05:39PM (#32391399)
It may be interesting source code to read.

Or is that also an illegal/illegitimate use now?