News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No More “Insight Porn” by chowells on Monday August 08, 2022 @02:01PM (#32388846)
No one ever talks about the opportunity cost of building up a "luck surface". What is the expected value of doing so? What do you have to sacrifice to do so? Is there any evidence the EV is positive, or is this just another selection bias?
Re:No More “Insight Porn” by nickff on Monday August 08, 2022 @02:16PM (#32389019)
Well, one extreme example is buying lottery tickets; it's the best way to expose yourself to the potential upside of winning the lottery, yet the expected value is quite negative.

That example is quite bracing, but I think it points out that there are many ways to build this 'luck surface', and the expected values of each are probably very different, and likely situational.

Re:No More “Insight Porn” by deltree7 on Monday August 08, 2022 @03:14PM (#32389717)
Expected value is really a dumb way to evaluate lottery tickets. I can't believe even supposedly good mathematicians use it.

The next dumb way to evaluate lottery tickets is to compare it with other long odds (lightning strikes, marrying your favorite actor). If you want to play along, the probability of you winning the lottery is 10000000000000x more favorable than the probability of you existing in this universe.

Buying lottery tickets is a simple framework. The upside of winning a lottery is significantly higher than the downside of losing one (per week or per month). So do it.

The opposite is driving recklessly to save a minute of your commute. It has significantly higher downside risks than the upside of time savings. So don't do it.

A lot of lottery-bashing people make 10000x worse sub-optimal decisions in their life and yet pick trashing a lottery ticket to feel superior about their decision making ability.

Re:No More “Insight Porn” by Afton on Monday August 08, 2022 @03:45PM (#32390137)
Bashing on lottery tickets due to EV also really feels like it's really missing the point. Lottery tickets are a mechanism for enjoying a fantasy. Sure you could technically just pretend that you won $10^9, but there is a hard cliff from >0% to 0%. I buy lottery tickets (very very occasionally, but who cares!) because it helps me enjoy a fantasy about being radically independently wealthy.

There's no reason to hate on people for doing something that they enjoy, regardless of what the expected value is. For god's sake, I juggle! As a hobby! Can you imagine the expected return on THAT?

Re:No More “Insight Porn” by guntars on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:04AM (#32394696)
If buying a lottery ticket is a good idea, isn’t buying two better? How about spending everything you have on lottery tickets? Odds are the upside for you is still much larger than the downside. Maybe you’re saying that buying a single lottery ticket improves your odds of winning the lotto so much (infinitely many times in fact) that you just need one. There are a lot of lotteries in the world so.. get one of each? Also, how often should you buy one? One a week? One an hour? Maybe once a lifetime is enough, which is what I personally recommend.

It’s almost like there is another variable that determines if this is a dumb idea, and it almost always is. Maybe those math professors are on to something after all.

Re:No More “Insight Porn” by deltree7 on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @12:50AM (#32407959)
No they aren't.

Go back to the framework

Upside(Gain) / Downside(Risk) is a pretty simple framework.

All I'm saying is, Downside(Risk) is not f(Expected Value)

Downside(Risk) is not f(p(winning))

Re:No More “Insight Porn” by spoonjim on Monday August 08, 2022 @04:40PM (#32390729)
Buying a single $1 lottery ticket is fine. But I see people in gas stations etc. who look like they are spending a very large fraction of their disposable income on lottery tickets. People asking for "$60 of X" when they look like they make $50K a year or less. That's fucking insane and if they make 10000x worse decisions in their life it must be like putting their fingers in the electrical socket.
Re:No More “Insight Porn” by Firmwarrior on Monday August 08, 2022 @04:55PM (#32390905)
Yeah, I'll defend buying one lottery ticket, even a few per week, but more than that and you very quickly cross the line between "Fun Fantasy" and "Math Tax"
Re:No More “Insight Porn” by wizofaus on Monday August 08, 2022 @03:19PM (#32389776)
There's basically nothing I'm totally sure of, but I do know the probability of my existing in this universe is 1.
Re:No More “Insight Porn” by cwp on Monday August 08, 2022 @03:28PM (#32389908)
No. That's like flipping a coin and then saying the probability of getting heads is 1. The fact that something happened is not proof that it was guaranteed to happen.
Re:No More “Insight Porn” by wizofaus on Monday August 08, 2022 @03:41PM (#32390087)
Re-read what the GP claimed. Given the initial conditions of the universe, the probability it might eventually lead to my own existence may well be infinitessimal, but in the context of the probability of me winning the lottery (for example), my existence is already a given.
Re:No More “Insight Porn” by cwp on Monday August 08, 2022 @04:34PM (#32390668)
No, what he was saying was that the probability of you winning the lottery is quite high compared to the probability of you existing in the first place. His point was that mathematicians sometimes try to contextualize these very low probability scenarios so that lay-people don't collapse them all into a single "basically impossible" bucket. They're not wrong, but it's not a useful way to think about whether buying a lottery ticket is a good idea.
Re:No More “Insight Porn” by wizofaus on Monday August 08, 2022 @04:49PM (#32390836)
I'll quote: "the probability of you winning the lottery is 10000000000000x more favorable than the probability of you existing in this universe". That statement is categorically wrong. If you're going to consider the probability of my ever coming to existence in the first place, you need to count it as part of the probability of winning the lottery too. If it had said "the probability of anybody winning" I would've cut it some slack (though the probability that a universe might develop with sentient beings capable of inventing lotteries is still a prerequisite in both cases).
Re:No More “Insight Porn” by CRConrad on Thursday August 11, 2022 @02:51PM (#32430109)
> I'll quote: "the probability of you winning the lottery is 10000000000000x more favorable than the probability of you existing in this universe". That statement is categorically wrong.

Yup -- it was written in a universe where the poster they replied to exists, so that probability is = 1 here.

Re:No More “Insight Porn” by thisismyswamp on Friday August 19, 2022 @09:35PM (#32528192)
Being a bayesian, the probability of me existing in this universe is 1
Re:No More “Insight Porn” by yellowapple on Monday August 08, 2022 @05:50PM (#32391549)
> the probability of you winning the lottery is 10000000000000x more favorable than the probability of you existing in this universe.

Is it, though? This claim ultimately hinges on the probability of life occurring in the universe, and that's pretty hard to assess given our lack of encounters with extraterrestrial life.

Once life is established and subject to evolutionary processes, I hypothesize that intelligent life is - barring some mass extinction event preventing it - just about inevitable; evolution will select for greater and greater intelligence until the local lifeforms achieve sapience (and possibly beyond even that, i.e. levels of intelligence we mere apes are incapable of comprehending).

Re:No More “Insight Porn” by Miserlou57 on Monday August 08, 2022 @06:51PM (#32392107)
I had an argument with my boss about this. He is a business owner and pretty successful one, and he calls the lottery a poverty tax, or a stupidity tax. If it were a game you play in Vegas, then he’d be right.

It’s my opinion that just buying one ticket, for say $2, essentially is a trivial and inconsequential amount of money that exposes you to incredible upside. Imagine if the ticket only cost a penny. At that point it’s practically free, but free exposure to life changing wealth. I don’t know if that counts as zero to 1 according to Peter Thiel, but it’s basically zero to something, for essentially nothing

Re:No More “Insight Porn” by aaaaaaaaata on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @09:38AM (#32397683)
What about the people who do hundreds in instant lottery, or dozens to hundreds of dollars every week for the standard games (and no, they aren't ALL pooled for a frigging office).
Re:No More “Insight Porn” by hamiltonians on Monday August 08, 2022 @08:54PM (#32392961)
but it does not cost a penny, hence strongly negative expected value and waste of money and time.
Re:No More “Insight Porn” by tracerbulletx on Monday August 08, 2022 @09:05PM (#32393040)
There are sometimes jackpot sizes that have a positive EV.
Re:No More “Insight Porn” by eutectic on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @12:58AM (#32394316)
Probably the real value is even worse than the expected value, because money has diminishing returns to happiness.
Re:No More “Insight Porn” by ghaff on Monday August 08, 2022 @02:47PM (#32389383)
>there are many ways to build this 'luck surface', and the expected values of each are probably very different, and likely situational.

I agree. Something as straightforward as being known as someone who does good work, putting yourself out there somewhat (writing, speaking, etc.), basically developing a network of people who you know at least professionally is certainly a way a lot of people develop at least something of a "luck surface." It may well not produce the big win but it can certainly lead to "lucky" opportunities.

Of course, there are other options that are more like gambles that may have negative EV but if you don't play big you probably won't win big.

Re:No More “Insight Porn” by scarmig on Monday August 08, 2022 @02:54PM (#32389447)
All the talk about building a great "luck surface" is just an attempt to deny luck: something might seem like luck, but it's really part of an intentional strategy to maximize potential value!

For any given "luck surface" strategy, you can find far more people who haven't achieved massive success using it than those who have. Some strategies are probably better than others, but those are not foreseeable in advance.

Re:No More “Insight Porn” by tomnipotent on Monday August 08, 2022 @03:38PM (#32390039)
It's luck because you have no direct control over it - it happens by unpredictable circumstances.

Think of networking, and imagine every person you meet and build a rapport with as non-parametric distribution that you're randomly sampling from over time (future interactions). You have no clue if each sample is going to yield positive results, but you can increase your chance of a positive outcome overall by increasing the number of distributions (people) you're sampling from (maintaining relationships).

So much of it ends up by random chance, what else could it be but luck?

Re:No More “Insight Porn” by Uehreka on Monday August 08, 2022 @03:59PM (#32390308)
Any time you spend trying and failing to quantify the EV of luck surface area is time you could be spending building your luck surface area.
Re:No More “Insight Porn” by aaaaaaaaata on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @09:36AM (#32397655)
You just might cost yourself an unfulfilling life you live out of duty.