Re:The rise of ‘ARPA-everything’ and what it means for scien...
by walleeee on Monday August 08, 2022 @12:13PM
(#32387387)
Agreed. Worked on an ARPA-E funded project and it was reported as a success even though the primary deliverable was never completed and was probably not viable anyway. Everyone involved meant well, but I sensed the PIs viewed it more as a vehicle for their ICs' careers than as a mission-driven enterprise.
This is a wicked incentive problem and I don't know how to solve it.
Re:The rise of ‘ARPA-everything’ and what it means for scien...
by elefanten on Monday August 08, 2022 @05:10PM
(#32391049)
Curious to what degree the "low-hanging fruit" dynamic comes into play when comparing the current era to the past.
It keeps coming up in many other fields.
Re:The rise of ‘ARPA-everything’ and what it means for scien...
by malfist on Monday August 08, 2022 @01:00PM
(#32388059)
For those not familiar with the jargon, can you expand what PI and IC means? Private Investors and Individual Contributors?
Re:The rise of ‘ARPA-everything’ and what it means for scien...
by walleeee on Monday August 08, 2022 @01:10PM
(#32388214)
sorry, Principal Investigator and Individual Contributor
Re:The rise of ‘ARPA-everything’ and what it means for scien...
by elzbardico on Monday August 08, 2022 @03:46PM
(#32390155)
But, did the project significantly advance the knowledge in the field, even if the deliverable couldn't be completed?
In that case, I would call it a success anyway.
Re:The rise of ‘ARPA-everything’ and what it means for scien...
by walleeee on Monday August 08, 2022 @06:26PM
(#32391897)
It produced some modest results which slightly advanced the field. Not groundbreaking. The applied work did demonstrate the viability of a few robotics applications and the infeasibility/insufficient ROI of a few others. I would say that was the most valuable output.
It did not begin to approach the goals in the project description, which I've since come to believe are detached from reality. A moonshot may have seemed collossally ambitious in 1961 but we already had most of the basic capabilities necessary to succeed. In this case, however, I don't think we're anywhere close, and even if we were, it would be a suboptimal solution to the problem it's meant to solve. (It would however be politically and economically convenient).
Re:The rise of ‘ARPA-everything’ and what it means for scien...
by two_almonds on Monday August 08, 2022 @03:08PM
(#32389619)
For those less informed about its history, is there any transparent accounting of ARPA's cost-vs-success during its initial decades that you recommend reading?
I am only marginally familiar with some of the 'big-impact wins' that are frequently mentioned, so I would love to read a comprehensive analysis of its accomplishments.
That said, I'd probably like to see high-level visibility on some accounting of cost versus success in, say, the past 15 years. From what I've seen, there haven't really been the kind of big-impact wins you usually see touted from further back in history. Instead it's mostly been PR, shrug-worthy output, and outright graft (e.g., a golden parachute for a certain Solyndra exec).