News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ubisoft about to take away games you bought by josephcsible on Saturday August 06, 2022 @12:52PM (#32369657)
The line is "whenever they're old enough that the publisher doesn't see any commercial disadvantage to releasing an update that removes all DRM, unlocks all DLC, and allows multiplayer without a centralized server".
Re:Ubisoft about to take away games you bought by teddyh on Saturday August 06, 2022 @03:33PM (#32370874)
A game does not exist in a vacuum. There is always going to be a commercial disadvantage to releasing anything, since that would divert attention from other, newer, more expensive games which the publisher would much rather that everyone bought instead of playing old games.
Re:Ubisoft about to take away games you bought by rfrey on Saturday August 06, 2022 @03:51PM (#32371011)
There's a commercial disadvantage to car owners continuing to drive 10 year old vehicles instead of purchasing new ones. Doesn't mean Ford (or Tesla, more likely) should be allowed to remotely brick sedans.
Re:Ubisoft about to take away games you bought by teddyh on Saturday August 06, 2022 @05:38PM (#32371794)
> Doesn't mean Ford (or Tesla, more likely) should be allowed to remotely brick sedans.

I agree – I was not arguing that anyone should be allowed to do that. It’s just obvious why they would do this, if it was allowed. And Ubisoft is allowed to do this, so they do it.

Re:Ubisoft about to take away games you bought by thaumasiotes on Saturday August 06, 2022 @04:05PM (#32371111)
I once read an article making the point that copyright is "[economic] protectionism against the past" - its purpose isn't really to accomplish anything in the present or future, but to prevent current producers of intellectual property from having to compete with the intellectual property produced by the past. When you read Pride and Prejudice instead of something "more appropriate" to the modern day, that's money taken out of the pocket of a book publisher today.

You've rediscovered that concept as applied to video games.

Re:Ubisoft about to take away games you bought by josephcsible on Saturday August 06, 2022 @03:46PM (#32370972)
If you never want to let your game that people already bought and paid for work without your central server being up, then I do think you should have to keep it up literally forever.
Re:Ubisoft about to take away games you bought by torstenvl on Saturday August 06, 2022 @02:02PM (#32370230)
Revamping multiplayer to be entirely P2P seems a bit excessive if there's no commercial advantage left.

I would be satisfied with releasing the server as freeware (or open-source!) and adding a feature to set the multiplayer server by domain or IP address.

Re:Ubisoft about to take away games you bought by bee_rider on Saturday August 06, 2022 @03:23PM (#32370822)
It would be kind of cool if the big engine developers would include a "switch to P2P mode" in at least their built-in multiplayer engines. Wouldn't help in this case, but would be nice going forward. Then at least we could say "well there isn't much commercial advantage but why not be nice? It isn't difficult."

I do wonder if Ubisoft would gain some commercial advantage from being known a company that isn't just waiting to rip off their customers. Hard to speculate as most of their games look pretty mediocre in the first place, IMO.

Re:Ubisoft about to take away games you bought by josephcsible on Saturday August 06, 2022 @02:08PM (#32370278)
Yes, I'd be fine with that too. As long as there's zero functionality lost by the central servers being turned off, I don't care how it's done.
Re:Ubisoft about to take away games you bought by Ekaros on Saturday August 06, 2022 @02:32PM (#32370465)
I'm fine with losing some functionality. Let's say community leader boards. Ofc, a nice thing would be then to provide API description and configuration options and allow fans to implement their own.