Re:Tor in the Amazon cloud
by dfc on Monday November 14, 2011 @08:47PM
(#3236580)
If anyone is wondering about the risk related to running one of these tor cloud instances. The bridges are configured to only accept and relay traffic to and from other tor nodes. The exit policy is reject everything. These instances will never be the last hop of a tor circuit...
Re:Tor in the Amazon cloud
by bryogenic on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:52PM
(#3236768)
I've been running an exit node on EC2 for a few months and I've only received 1 DMCA notice and I responded that I was running a tor node and was not legally responsible for the traffic I was producing and it was resolved. Their EULA does not explicitly prevent you from doing this so if you don't mind dealing with the feigning bulldogs every once in a while it's not that bad.
Re:Tor in the Amazon cloud
by dfc on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @01:19AM
(#3237260)
I always thought that "not legally responsible for traffic" was the best guess at the legal theory. Is there now actual precedence supporting your statement?
Re:Tor in the Amazon cloud
by bryogenic on Monday November 14, 2011 @10:59PM
(#3236950)
Amazon sent the DMCA on behalf of the copyright owners, I responded with the EULA and a up front response about what I was using my image for, saying if I was in violation I would terminate my image immediately. They said thanks for explaining the situation and I haven't heard anything since then.
Re:Tor in the Amazon cloud
by dotBen on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @01:43AM
(#3237309)
I run an exit node, but not on a US-based server given DMCA complaints becomes tiresome.
Single best thing you can do is run the "this is a tor exit router" (google for it) web page on port 80 of your TOR exit node --- that demonstrates you know what your rights are.
Re:Tor in the Amazon cloud
by there on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @01:01AM
(#3237230)
if tor users would stop running bittorrent through it, my two nodes would still be exits instead of relays. DMCA complaints can quickly take down an exit node in the US.
Re:Tor in the Amazon cloud
by adrianN on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:27AM
(#3237396)
I would, but here in Germany I can be held responsible for any illegal acts that are commited through my connection ("Mitstörerhaftung"). I don't want to lose all my computers and face an expensive legal battle because someone posted some child porn through my node.
Re:Tor in the Amazon cloud
by dpark on Monday November 14, 2011 @11:58PM
(#3237095)
Edit: You were probably asking about EC2 exit nodes. It's a little better than having it in my house, but at the end of the day, I would still be worried about landing in court over the traffic the node handles.
Re:Tor in the Amazon cloud
by bryogenic on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:46PM
(#3236747)
I wrote a tutorial back in June on how to setup an ec2 exit-node for the Tor Challenge (https://www.eff.org/torchallenge). It also includes an automatic shutoff when you've reached the data limit of the free usage tier. I've only received one DMCA in the past 6 months I've had it running.
Edit: After reading through the site it looks like they basically did the same thing I did but created an AMI that you can just 'clone'. Either way, good for the Tor community.
Re:Tor in the Amazon cloud
by tedivm on Monday November 14, 2011 @10:32PM
(#3236880)
If a large enough group of tor servers resides on Amazon's network what is going to keep Amazon (or the government) from being able to reverse the anonymization? Isn't this exactly why Tor asks people hosting multiple machines to label them as in the same "family" to prevent them from directly communicating?
Re:Tor in the Amazon cloud
by fl3tch on Monday November 14, 2011 @10:58PM
(#3236947)
1. The US government can discover the user, but won't know what the user is doing, unless the user('s client) also chooses US exit nodes reliably / recurrently enough that a successful timing attack or somesuch can be mounted.
2. Presumably, the people who need bridges the most are in countries where Tor relays are censored (China, Iran, the Seychelles?, Cameroon?), and Amazon isn't in those jurisdictions, nor would the US government want to deanonymize them.
But yeah, if you're in the United States and have something to hide from your government, don't use Amazon Tor bridges.
Re:Tor in the Amazon cloud
by dfc on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @01:27AM
(#3237271)
The Seychelles? I did not realize there is a big human rights problem in the seychelles. A quick scan of the wikipedia page seems to indicate that the seychelles government ranked second for human rights in african countries.
Re:Tor in the Amazon cloud
by dfc on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:41PM
(#3236733)
A cloud DDOS would not scale that well. Even if amazon did not shut down instances because of ToS violations how many free accounts do you think could be created? Compare that with the ease of renting botnets...
Re:Tor in the Amazon cloud
by wyck on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @12:08PM
(#3239002)
Amazon cloud is not the only cloud service out there, I think spreading the bridges over multiple company's/countries that have similar products would make it more sustainable.
Re:Tor in the Amazon cloud
by dfc on Monday November 14, 2011 @10:02PM
(#3236809)
Why is amazon going to care about computers relaying traffic back and forth? As I already posted the nodes are configured as relay nodes only no exit traffic.
But more importantly why do you assume that amazon will think tor is bad and/or why do you assume tor is bad?
But exit nodes are a problem; how can we get people to run those?
Single best thing you can do is run the "this is a tor exit router" (google for it) web page on port 80 of your TOR exit node --- that demonstrates you know what your rights are.
http://bryogenic.com/eff-tor-challenge-amazon-ec2-free-usage...
Edit: After reading through the site it looks like they basically did the same thing I did but created an AMI that you can just 'clone'. Either way, good for the Tor community.
2. Presumably, the people who need bridges the most are in countries where Tor relays are censored (China, Iran, the Seychelles?, Cameroon?), and Amazon isn't in those jurisdictions, nor would the US government want to deanonymize them.
But yeah, if you're in the United States and have something to hide from your government, don't use Amazon Tor bridges.
What's going on in the seychelles?
I spent 5 hours at a Tor hackfest once, and was extremely impressed by both the pragmatism and creativity of those folks.
This is just one more elegant dent in the right direction. Their "Tor Browser" project is another nice one.
But more importantly why do you assume that amazon will think tor is bad and/or why do you assume tor is bad?