Re:DreamWorks Animation to release MoonRay as open source
by ziddoap on Friday August 05, 2022 @12:43PM
(#32358587)
Why are you framing this in such a negative light?
They open something up, let people use it, and hope that some people might contribute back. Cool, sounds great to me. They aren't forcing me to contribute back to the project. Seems pretty win-win.
Re:DreamWorks Animation to release MoonRay as open source
by colechristensen on Saturday August 06, 2022 @03:14PM
(#32370756)
It’s clearly business, not self sacrifice. Your interpretation of that as negativity is a reflection of your own judgement not mine.
Re:DreamWorks Animation to release MoonRay as open source
by tpmx on Friday August 05, 2022 @01:21PM
(#32359111)
That's not how it works. What they're after is mindshare, establishing their codebase as a standard etc.
You're not going to get a free work force just by open sourcing your very context-specific code. Most companies/people learned this ~22 years ago.
Re:DreamWorks Animation to release MoonRay as open source
by erichocean on Friday August 05, 2022 @12:31PM
(#32358426)
> runners up trying to compete
MoonRay likely has the best volume rendering in the world, certainly that's open source.
Only Weta's internal renderer is in the same league.
Re:DreamWorks Animation to release MoonRay as open source
by berkut on Friday August 05, 2022 @12:45PM
(#32358622)
Not necessarily: it would depend on what Dreamworks' requirements have been up to now as to the current state: obviously, they use volumetrics, but almost all their stuff is CG and not necessarily photo real, being more artistic-driven.
That fact might have allowed them to take short-cuts.
How do you know what Manuka's capable of? :)
Re:DreamWorks Animation to release MoonRay as open source
by mkaic on Friday August 05, 2022 @01:58PM
(#32359585)
I'd guess that the volume rendering in MoonRay is pretty top notch considering Dreamworks was also responsible for creating OpenVDB. Furthermore, while their characters and environments are often stylized, watch a few minutes of How To Train Your Dragon 3 and you'll see their volumetric rendering is stunningly believable.
Translation: we think making this open source will bring in significant outside contribution so we can get a better renderer with less investment ourselves while not having to pay external providers
Open source is a good strategy for the runners up trying to compete, you get the good will from giving something away in exchange for other people improving your product for free.